The Frontstretch: And the Winner of the No. 5 Ride Should Be... by Amy Henderson -- Friday May 16, 2008

Go to site navigation Go to article

And the Winner of the No. 5 Ride Should Be...

Holding A Pretty Wheel · Amy Henderson · Friday May 16, 2008


It seems that Silly Season gets earlier and wilder every year, but this year it’s… well, silly. Touched off by contract extension talks between Carl Edwards and Roush Fenway Racing and a rumor that Tony Stewart could leave Joe Gibbs Racing as early as this year, the grind that is NASCAR Silly Season cranked into high gear.

One place where the rumors swirl thick and fast is around the No. 5 car of Hendrick Motorsports. The car, driven by Casey Mears, made the Chase in 2007 with Kyle Busch at the wheel, and Mears moved over from the No. 25 when Dale Earnhardt, Jr. replaced Busch for the 2008 season. Mears is currently 27th in the Sprint Cup driver point standings, with just two Top 10 finishes. In comparison, teammates Earnhardt, Jimmie Johnson, and Jeff Gordon have eight, four and five Top 10s, respectively. While only Johnson has a win, Mears does look like the oddball at Hendrick — and may very well end up the odd man out.

With many drivers reportedly looking for greener pastures, it’s been persistently hinted at that the No. 25 will be up for grabs. With three other teams in the top twelve in points, how long can Rick Hendrick put up with the weakest cog in the wheel? A ride at HMS, whose teams dominated last year, finishing first and second in points, would be a coup for any driver, and there are some outstanding ones currently looking for a ride of that caliber. Tony Stewart, Ryan Newman, Greg Biffle, and Martin Truex, Jr. are among those reported to be looking for new digs next year. Stewart is a two-time champion, and the others are all proven winners. With those enticing options, which one should fill the seat of the No. 5 in 2009?

Casey Mears has struggled in the No. 5 car this season; but the current slump shouldn’t be enough to keep him from driving the car in ’09.

The answer is Casey Mears.

Why? Mears’ numbers are deceptive, for one thing. He was the best of the Hendrick Motorsports stable in the late going of the Daytona 500; in that one, it looked like Mears had a car that could win it until a spotter error caused him to crash in the closing laps. Otherwise? It’s hard to speculate, but it could well have been the No. 5 in Daytona USA right now. The next week at California, NASCAR made a terrible call to start the race on a wet track and Mears was the victim, hitting a wet spot and spinning — taking Earnhardt with him on that one. More recently, another spotter error ended a strong run at Richmond; with a little luck on his side, Mears could have three or four Top 5 finishes by now.

Here’s another consideration: Mears is with his fourth team in four years. Though he’s been with only two owners in his Sprint Cup career, Mears was bounced from the No. 41 to the 42 at Chip Ganassi Racing when sponsor Target wanted Reed Sorenson behind the wheel in 2006. He moved to HMS the following season, and after one year in the No. 25, Mears was bounced to the No. 5 car. Geez … the guy must dream of being a pinball at night. The irony is that Mears was hitting his stride in the No. 41 in late 2005, nearly winning twice – but then promptly got moved to a new team, with a new crew chief to learn to communicate with. He moved to Hendrick a year later, and came on like gangbusters late in the season – just before another team shift. Alan Gustafson is a great head wrench at the No. 5, and Mears loves working with him; but driver/crew chief relationships don’t happen overnight, and Mears and Gustafson are still on the upside of a long learning curve. Still, the cars are getting better, and there’s no reason that Mears can’t heat up this summer like he did one year ago.

Mears is a great fit at Hendrick for one more reason – his personality. Mears isn’t looking to be numero uno in a stable that already has three of them; in fact, he’s just as happy to the guy in the background who does his job and does it right. He’s laid back, and is one of the most fan-friendly drivers you could ever hope to find. Mears is at his souvenir rig signing autographs on race morning virtually every week, and one of his concerns when he came to HMS was that he’d still have time for that. By far the most outgoing of the Hendrick drivers, Mears enjoys spending time with his fans; and that in itself is good PR in a NASCAR where increasing sponsor demands keep many drivers from the level of interaction that fans enjoyed a decade or more ago. Mears is personable and has a sense of humor that he seems willing to show, a far cry from his more reserved teammates.

Mears is also the polar opposite of Jimmie Johnson, the reigning two-time champion who is his teammate at HMS. Mears is as relaxed in the car in situations where Johnson is emotional; that’s not to say that Mears isn’t just as passionate as Johnson, though. He’s not just as much a bulldog behind the wheel; but the ultra-laidback Mears balances the hyperemotional Johnson. The two are close friends off the track, and have known one another since neither was old enough to drive a street car. It’s not bad to have that kind of balance on a team. Mears is also friends with Jeff Gordon, and has a budding friendship with Earnhardt as well. His get-along-with-everyone personality is a part of the team chemistry often overlooked.

While there are more talented drivers in the garage than Mears, his fit at HMS is undeniable. Tossing Stewart into the mix might well mean too many cooks. Newman has been criticized for being stingy with information, and is unlikely to embrace the open-book policy that Hendrick Motorsports thrives on. Biffle is likely to remain at Roush Fenway or head to a team like Dale Earnhardt, Incorporated, where he can rebuild a team to his own style. And Martin Truex is Dale Earnhardt, Jr.’s close friend. While that could potentially reap benefits, what kind of team chemistry would it create to replace Johnson’s best friend with Earnhardt’s? Some things are best not meddled with on a personal level.

Casey Mears said recently that he’s good through 2009 at Hendrick Motorsports. Still, the rumor mill grinds his name out almost daily, and that is hard to ignore. There are a lot of drivers looking for a new deal for 2009 and beyond, and all will command top rides and top money. Many will look to be the best fit in a new team.

But the best fit for Hendrick Motorsports and the No. 5 is already in the car.

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Amy Henderson and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

05/16/2008 08:38 AM

Wow, I’m pretty sure that’s the first time anyone has ever labeled Jimmie Johnson “emotional.” Usually “robotic” is the term tossed around. You’re right with your story, though. There are several things wrong with the #5 team other than the driver that need to be addressed.

05/16/2008 09:39 AM

Maybe there’s something about Casey Mears that I’m not seeing, but I don’t get why he’s gotten so many chances. He’s a good guy, no doubt, but just about everyone that’s been in every car he’s been in has performed better than he has.

MïK ("mike") Watson
05/16/2008 10:19 AM

…and I thought he was in a car because he drove the motorhome for the other three.

05/16/2008 12:07 PM

The way I see it Ricky Craven had the same amount of dumb luck while at Hendrick in the #25 and he lasted what a total of 2 years, taking out the Texas concussion? Mears is a decent enough driver, but obviously has gotten a lot of mileage out of his last name. Call me crazy, but I thought Randy Lajoie was the perfect driver for that car when he subbed.

Now saying that I think the real reason Casey stays there is that he doesn’t have the ego like the other 3, which I feel is what bit Vickers in the rear end. Casey to me seems content to be the backup quarterback on that team and not make waves but get a good finish when he can. If Mears did go, I think a Kozlowski would be a good fit in that car to kind of bridge the gap so to speak and be the developmental guy like Carl Edwards was at Roush.

05/16/2008 12:09 PM

just so you know, they swapped the #25 team to the 5 ride and the 5 team aside from a few of Dale Jr’s cousins came over.

05/16/2008 01:03 PM

I personally have no problem with Mears being in the 5 car. I do have a problem with his haircut though. Either grow it out long enough to comb or shave your head! That stubble is just to darn annoying.

05/16/2008 01:21 PM

If, and a big one at that, Mears was to leave the #5 team, the best fit IMO would be Kenseth. If available and if the right opportunity presented itself.
The Stewart story sounds like he’s gonna do his own thing. Truex and Biffle will re-sign.

mike ravesi
05/17/2008 08:44 AM


05/17/2008 02:26 PM

Thank you for recognizing Casey’s true worth to HMS. Being on a 4 car team with 3 superstars has to be tough, but Casey handles it with grace and good humor. I just can’t see drivers like Tony Stewart or Ryan Newman blending with the group the way Casey does. He’s suffered bad luck and new team problems without complaining or making excuses—and unlike some drivers I won’t name, you’ll never hear him whining to the media! Casey proved in the latter half of last season that he knows how to run up front, and he’ll be there again. Once he’s established a stronger relationship with his crew I have no doubt the wins will come.

05/18/2008 08:50 AM

Wait a minute folks. The 5 car is really the previous 25 car. Lets look at history
Ken Schaeder, a capable enough driver 10 years ago
Ricky Craven didn’t burn it up in the 25.
The car is an R&D. It doesnt matter if you put Speed Racer in the car, it just is not a winner. The motors are wound to the very edge, the set ups are in the gray area, everything about it smells of leading the other teams to victory. Multi car teams are not going to have championship caliber drivers in their research machines.

05/18/2008 10:03 PM

First of all…who is Kozlowski? Sorry your lack of spelling or my lack of knowledge on who this driver is has confused me. Second of all…It is all about Jr. (mind you hasn’t won in 2 years), Jimmie, and Jeffy! Sorry still confused why there is so much hype about Mears being gone next year. Until I hear otherwise HE IS in the car next year. Not a huge Mears fan (actually I’m a Jr. fan) but when facts are presented they need to be. This article is good and hopefully Casey will show all the haters he isn’t bad. And if you want to talk about your name getting you somewhere I’m sure my man Dale Jr. had some help with his daddy’s name, 17 races wouldn’t keep you on my team, you better be winning more considering where your genes came from.


Contact Amy Henderson

Recent articles from Amy Henderson:

Earnhardt Ganassi Racing Announces Partnership with Cessna, Textron
Fans To Decide Format of Sprint Unlimited at Daytona
UNOH and Kentucky Speedway Extend Sponsorship Agreement
Earnhardt Out For Charlotte and Kansas After Talldega Concussion
Piquet, Jr. Wins K&N East Opener

Want to know more about Amy or see an archive of all of her articles? Check out her bio page for more information.