The Frontstretch: Pace Laps: BumperGate 2012 - The Aftermath, "Calling" It Like It Is And Indy Pairings by Amy Henderson -- Monday April 30, 2012

Go to site navigation Go to article

Did you see all of the race action this weekend? Or, like a lot of busy fans, did you miss a late-night adventure, a Friday controversy, or a juicy piece of news? If you did, you’ve come to the right place! Each week, The Frontstretch will break down the racing, series by series, to bring you the biggest stories that you need to watch during the week ahead. Let our experts help you get up to speed for the coming week no matter what series you might have missed, all in this week’s edition of Pace Laps!

NASCAR Sprint Cup Series: Edwards Call was Legit With Richmond now in the rearview mirror, it’s hard to say that this week was uneventful. The controversy began with the opening technical inspection for the Nationwide Series on Thursday and didn’t end with the checkered flag in the Sprint Cup race on Saturday. The hottest topic of conversation this week: Carl Edwards’ penalty for jumping the lap 318 restart. In case you missed it, that restart was a game-changer for Edwards, who dominated much of the race but was only able to finish tenth after being black-flagged and forced to serve a pass-through penalty. Edwards and his fans are still questioning the call.

Carl Edwards’ frustration with NASCAR for black-flagging him was all for naught, but can similar penalties be avoided in the future?

There are three things to take into consideration here. First, Edwards’ team alleges that they thought they were leading. The scoring pylon at Richmond and the ticker on FOX’s broadcast showed the No. 99 on top… but it wasn’t—meaning that when Edwards passed on the poutside before the start-finish line, he was in violation of NASCRA’s rules. That error was caused because the scoring system is triggered by the transponders on each car; Edwards had edged ahead of actual race leader Tony Stewart while cleaning his tires as they took the one to go, and that put the No. 99 incorrectly on top of the pylon. In reality, there was no way that Edwards could have been the race leader, as he had pitted under the caution and Stewart stayed out, and there was no way he could have taken the lead under those circumstances. NASCAR was firm that the No. 99 team should have known that. And you do have to wonder why, if Edwards truly didn’t know he wasn’t the leader, he didn’t try to push the issue before the restart and take the onside lane. That he didn’t says his team had an inkling.

Second, even if he had been the race leader, Edwards clearly accelerated before the restart zone. Even though the leader controls the start, he can’t start before that area on the racetrack, and the replay shows that Edwards clearly did. So, according to NASCAR, he’d have been black flagged even if he was the leader. He’d already come close earlier in the race, making NASCAR pay close attention to him this time.

But finally, should the restart have been allowed to happen? Going forward, NASCAR could make a couple of minor changes, including reviewing timing and scoring info on the pylon or TV feed before allowing a race to go green and having a pit road official notify the team who is leading, or by prohibiting drivers from passing the leader under caution, even while scrubbing tires. Whether changes are made remains to be seen. –Amy Henderson

Izod IndyCar Series: Some New-And Surprising Indy 500 Pairings Emerging There are 33 spots on the starting grid for the Indianapolis 500 but only 26 teams competing on a weekly basis in the IZOD IndyCar Series. That means there are always one-off special combinations of owners and drivers. Dan Wheldon’s winning effort last year is proof that some of these pairings can be pretty potent in a race where just about anything can happen.

Rahal Letterman Lanigan Racing announced a deal this week for Michel Jourdain, Jr. to race the 500 with sponsorship from Office Depot Mexico. Jourdain competed in the 500 only once, in 1996, where he finished 13th, one of three starts he made in the Indy Racing League. He went on to make 152 starts in CART and Champ Car between 1996 and 2004, some of those with Team Rahal before that team moved to the Indy Racing League. Jourdain moved to the NASCAR Nationwide Series and Camping World Truck Series from 2005 to 2008 and has been racing in various rally and sports car series since. He will be classified a veteran but will participate in a refresher course in conjunction with the Rookie Orientation Program on May 10. Jourdain will run as a teammate to Takuma Sato, the team’s full time driver, who got his first podium result with a third place finish in Sao Paolo this week. The team won the Indy 500 with Buddy Rice in 2004.

With spots up for grabs, don’t be surprised to see more one-off owner-driver pairings happen before teams roll into Indianapolis. With money and prestige on the line, everyone wants a piece of the pie. –Toni Montgomery

NASCAR Nationwide Series: Visual Inspection Nabs Six at Richmond… Now What? Think the fallout from Jimmie Johnson’s C-post violation at Daytona was a big deal? This one’s has the potential to be bigger. ESPN’s pre-race show at Richmond noted that NASCAR was far from happy after confiscating six front bumpers from Richard Childress Racing’s and Turner Motorsports’ NNS teams in pre-race inspections, and there seems to be little doubt that points penalties are going to stem from what was reportedly a very deliberate effort to gain a competitive edge.

Of course, there’s the inherent problem of penalizing six race teams for equipment that never saw the race track, and thus never gained said competitive edge. But the larger issue is that, unlike the No. 48 team episode in the Cup Series, one that impacted only one race team in a series where the points get reset with 10 races to go, three Nationwide Series teams in the top 10 in points are all going to be impacted by any penalties to come. Further, there is no reset to count on, so the fallout is going to stick with Elliott Sadler, Austin Dillon, and Justin Allgaier, as well as the other teams who got caught, through all of the 2012 season.

Like the Cup Series penalty, the infractions were discovered on visual inspection. However, unlike the C-pillar, because the nose section of the car is factory designed, NASCAR has an exact factory piece for each model to compare against. But the waters are once again muddied by the fact that Sadler says his team raced with the same piece twice before—and won—and it has therefore been subject to—and passed—several previous inspections; this was a key point in the No. 48 appeal, which eventually resulted in their penalty being drastically reduced. In light of the recent appeal and subsequent overturning of a similar penalty, what NASCAR chooses to do with this is a bit cloudy. Will they come down harshly on the teams for violation a specific rule about altering a factory-designed piece, or will they back off given the recent sting of defeat on the No. 48 appeal?

Granted, this is not an issue specific to the Nationwide Series. But this story is going to impact the title chase in a big-time way. –Bryan Davis Keith

Grand-Am: Rain, Rain, Go Away! In the third race of this season, this weekend’s Grand Prix of Miami, the big story was the torrents of rain which resulted in multiple spins, sending cars off the track. At times, visibility was so low spectators could barely see the headlights from the cars. Drivers also carried the infamous “towel on a stick” to clear the inside of their windshields. With water pooling up in the corners and the grass, there were more cars spinning than wrecking from other causes, especially in turn 2, where most of the incidents happened. Amazingly, no one ended up stuck in the muddied grass, and most were able to make their way back onto the track.

Perhaps the most impressive spin came from Barber Motorsports Park winner, the Spirit of Daytona No. 90, with Richard Westbrook behind the wheel. Leading the race following the second caution period for heavy downpours, Westbrook hit a large puddle in turn 2 and spun, thanks in part to some help from Enzo Potolicchio. Grand-Am officials were not pleased with the contact by the driver of the No. 8 Ford and assessed a stop-and-go penalty that dropped his team to fifth in the Daytona Prototype running order. The problems for the No. 8 team continued when they spun, ultimately forcing a pit stop for cleanup. With nearly an hour remaining, officials chose to throw the white flag in the interest of safety, giving SunTrust Racing their first win of the season in the Daytona Prototype class. In an impressive run, the No. 69 Ferrari, piloted by Jeff Segal at the time (teammate Emil Assentato), took the GT Series lead under green flag conditions and held on through pit stops, giving the manufacturer its first victory since November 2003.

But even after this impressive victory, the rain was what will be remembered by most fans. And though all ended well, could there have been more precautions taken to keep drivers safe? -Rick Lunkenheimer

Short Tracks: Josh Richards has decided to make the ultimate leap of faith in his young career, relocating to Charlotte, NC, and giving up a second place standing in the World of Outlaw Late Model Series in order to try to find a full time home in NASCAR. Richards has made several starts in the Camping World Truck Series for Kyle Busch Motorsports and had hoped to make the move to a full-time Truck ride for 2012. Unfortunately for Richards, that did not materialize; so he made the last minute decision to return to dirt for the season. Now he is very close to announcing a NASCAR ride in the next week or two and so has chosen to get out of his family ride and focus all of his attention on the asphalt world of NASCAR.

For this past weekend, the Richards family decided to put Tim Fuller in the two-time series championship seat, which was a boon for Fuller. The 2007 World of Outlaw Late Model Rookie of the Year had just decided to abandon his own efforts at chasing the series, so this is an opportunity of a lifetime for Fuller to show what he can do in top flight equipment.

Nothing is guaranteed beyond this weekend for Fuller or the Richards’ house car. Fuller finished in fifth place in the North Alabama WoO event, for a good start to the weekend. The second race, at Tazewell Tennessee, didn’t end quite as well for Fuller. He came home in 18th place in the fastest 50-lap feature in the history of the World of Outlaw Late Models.

What is up next for both Fuller and Richards is anyone’s guess at this point. Fans will certainly find out over the next week or two what the future holds for both drivers and the Richards famous house ride. Stay tuned; this could be a big step for two up-and-coming young stars. -Mike Neff

Connect with Amy!

Contact Amy Henderson

Connect with Toni!

Contact Toni Montgomery

Connect with Bryan!

Contact Bryan Davis Keith

Connect with Rick!
Contact Rick Lunkenheimer

Connect with Mike!

Contact Mike Neff

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Amy Henderson and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

04/30/2012 01:39 AM

I agree 100%
Can not believe this is the first time that the scoring pylon showed the 2nd place car in 1st on the restart.

I find it hard to believe there was no talk during caution of who was leading. Every time I have listened to nascar scoring while at the track, they give an update on position leading up to the restart.

Brian France Sucks
04/30/2012 04:03 AM

You forgot one key point. A NA$CAR official on the spotter tower told the 99’s spotter they were leading multiple times. This was relayed to the driver. NA$CAR is culpable in this mess, but have tried there best to weasel out of any culpability, which is surprising.

As for Josh Richards, he deserves a ride. He has obvious talent, is a winner, and should be an easy sell to sponsors. Plus he’s already a better driver than Danica Patwreck.

Doug in Washington (State)
04/30/2012 04:11 PM

There were multiple things that caused the confusion.

1) The caution came during green-flag pit stops, which always screws things up.

2) Tony’s pit location meant that to stay on the lead lap, he had to beat the pace car (or the leader if no pace car was out) to the start/finish line. He did that, but didn’t beat the pace car to the exit of pit road so he “lost” a lap via the scoring loops.

3) NASCAR determined he had had beat the leader to the start/finish line, and let him around the pace car. (this was before they waved Kyle around as the Free Pass car). Tony ran around the track and caught the back of the field.

4) Meanwhile, Carl pitted while Tony was at the back of the field. Now you had a mess of cars ahead of the leader. The scoring loops still weren’t valid as it would take more laps to sort it out.

5) For some reason, officials told both the 99 and the 14 they were the leader. I suspect the official who told the 99 crew simply mailed it in by looking at the scoring pylon rather than getting word from race control.

6) Carl tried to make up for the “disadvantaged starting position” by mashing the gas right at the restart box… except he was about a car length early. Tony saw Carl jump out, and he too mashed it but unhooked (just as he had all night) and made it REAL obvious.

Either way, Carl incurred a penalty. Even if he WAS the leader, he still hit the gas early.

05/01/2012 12:22 PM

If the 99 was scored the leader when the crossed the start/finish line for the 1 to go, why didn’t the 14 regain it at the next scoring loop? Or is it only controlled at the start/finish line. Or was Edwards ahead of the 14 at each scoring loop? That part doesn’t make sense, unless I’m ill informed on how that all works.

Regardless, Nascar’s call on Edwards was correct. He jumped the restart and it wasn’t close. Those saying the restart area was the white box to the inside are wrong. It was a double red line on the wall next to Carl.

Carl should be happy with that finish, considering he was rumored to be the one calling for the caution for debris after his penalty. Being one of Nascars favorites, they gave him his wish apparently and he got a chance to catch the leaders again. They probably felt bad for penalizing him.


Contact Amy Henderson

Recent articles from Amy Henderson:

Earnhardt Ganassi Racing Announces Partnership with Cessna, Textron
Fans To Decide Format of Sprint Unlimited at Daytona
UNOH and Kentucky Speedway Extend Sponsorship Agreement
Earnhardt Out For Charlotte and Kansas After Talldega Concussion
Piquet, Jr. Wins K&N East Opener

Want to know more about Amy or see an archive of all of her articles? Check out her bio page for more information.