The Frontstretch: The Big Six: Questions Answered After NASCAR's All-Star Race Weekend by Amy Henderson -- Sunday May 19, 2013

Go to site navigation Go to article

Looking for the Who, What, When, Where, Why and How behind Saturday night’s race? Amy Henderson has you covered with each week with the answers to six race day questions, covering all five W’s and even the H…the Big Six.

Who…gets my shoutout of the race?

Sprint Showdown How about some props to Travis Kvapil for his top-10 finish? Even in a diminished field, Kvapil was the only driver in the top 10 who drives for a small team. He outraced Danica Patrick when push came to shove, passing her in the late going to grab an eighth-place result for his effort. The finish will give his BK Racing team something they don’t often have: bragging rights among their true peers. This team needed a boost, after a flurry of DNFs to start 2013 and they got one this weekend as best in their own class.

All-Star Race If there was a trophy for driving your heart out, Kurt Busch would have a shelf full of them, and Saturday night was no exception. Busch won two segments and was the first onto pit road for the money stop. Unfortunately for Busch, his crew wasn’t as fast as their driver, and their slow tire change cost Busch more spots than he could make up on the track. He came home fifth, a good night most of the time but not when a victory seemed so close. Races can be won and lost on pit road… and this one was both won and lost in the pits.

What… was THAT?

Danica Patrick won the Fan Vote, but can we trust NASCAR’s fan base really were the ones pushing her over the top?

Sprint Showdown Was anyone really surprised to learn that Danica Patrick won the Fan Vote? NASCAR bent over backwards to make sure she did, even going so far as to waive a previous requirement of finishing on the lead lap in the Sprint Showdown in order to transfer.

I hate to say it, but I’m a bit skeptical of this one. Sure, Patrick has a huge fan base, and props to them for voting for her as often as they could. But she’s a polarizing figure, and also has a large number of detractors who were voting for others. That could have worked against her. In the end, the totals appear irrelevant to me because NASCAR had to want her in the big race badly — she gets coverage for the sport no matter where she finishes. Thinking back to a few years ago, when one car was called to inspection (usually signifying they’re going to transfer) only to have another one, driven by a bigger-name driver, rolled out when all was said and done, I do have to wonder. (That was before NASCAR got wise to fans listening on the radio to the officials and started calling the top 3 in). Perhaps Brian France really is his sport’s biggest fan.

All-Star Race Whether you like Jimmie Johnson or loathe him, he made history on Saturday night with his fourth All-Star win. No other driver has won that many in the more than 25 years the event has been held. Johnson is an incredibly consistent driver, and that’s how he got by Kasey Kahne in the closing laps. But what should have the competition worried was the pit stop that got Johnson out for the final segment in second place. After a couple of botched stops at Darlington cost Johnson, crew chief Chad Knaus made a pair of changes that worked beautifully. Their money stop on Saturday night was lightning fast, under 12 seconds and ultimately, the race was decided from the front row, where Johnson’s penchant for running the bottom while Kahne preferred the top made the difference. In a nutshell, Johnson’s pit crew gave him the chance, and he went out and won in a way they haven’t since his run of five championships. Uh-oh.

Where…did the defending race winner wind up?

Sprint Showdown Last year’s winner is smiling, because this year he didn’t have to race his way into the main event, where he finished seventh. Dale Earnhardt, Jr. broke his long winless streak last year, last June at Michigan and that got him an automatic pass into this 2013 edition. While winning the hooligan race is nice, nothing beats coming into the weekend knowing you’re an All-Star already.

All-Star Race Jimmie Johnson admitted that he “played the game” last year with the race rules, running far behind and out of trouble for three segments after winning the first. As a result of him and others doing that, NASCAR changed the rules for 2013. So Johnson simply stepped up his game this year, and as a result, made the winning pass on Kasey Kahne with eight to go and never looked back until he reached Victory Lane for the second year in a row, making him only the second driver to win consecutive All-Star races and the first in two decades (Davey Allison went back-to-back in the early 1990s).

Was it just me, though, or did the camera angle in Victory Lane make it look like the confetti gun was aimed directly at the back of Johnson’s head, a la Chick Hicks in the Disney movie Cars? Perhaps the confetti man, like many fans, was fed up with Johnson’s seemingly effortless winning?

When…will I be loved?

Sprint Showdown One unwelcome part of the Showdown, possibly resulting from that fan vote lead-lap rule change, was that nobody even raced particularly hard once the top two opened up a lead in the final segment. Other than Casey Mears’ no-tire gamble (which killed his chances) nobody really bothered to mix it up. Once race winner Jamie McMurray checked out and Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. laid claim to second, the wind was taken out of the other teams’ sails, and most of them simply logged laps, not wanting to tear up their racecars. Perhaps the final segment needs to be shorter in this race, just five laps, which would encourage more teams to gamble either in the pits or on the track. The racing with 15 to go was pretty exciting — imagine if that had been for the transfer?

Mark Martin was on the wrong side of on-track contact after being hit by Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. during the All-Star Race.

All-Star Race For a million-dollar, non-points race, it sure was quiet in Charlotte on Saturday night. Nobody did anything particularly untoward, though Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. may have driven over his head a little, which resulted in him bouncing off the wall into Mark Martin and sending Martin on a wild ride, and in angry radio comments from Tony Stewart and Clint Bowyer. Still, Stenhouse was no villain, and perhaps that’s why the race was enjoyable — there was plenty of hard racing after the first segment, but nobody got dirty or ran out of talent… they just raced. Imagine if they “just raced” each and every week?

Why…can’t they qualify like that every week?

Many fans were captivated by the qualifying procedure for the All-Star Race: three laps, including a mandatory four-tire pit stop where there’s no speed limit on pit road. While I’ll be the first to say they should have used the same procedure for Sprint Showdown qualifying, it would simply be too dangerous at many tracks. NASCAR completely cleared pit road for the session, except for the pit crews for each team. There are a lot of people on pit road at every track these days, and at some tracks, like Bristol and Martinsville, the remnants of the old two-pit road system would make it a real risk.

The time it would take to complete a qualifying session would also be significantly lengthened. Besides, it wouldn’t be All-Star special if they did it every week. It was a great format for this race, though. NASCAR needs to keep it for the All-Star event – and the last-chance race — each year going forward.

How…could All-Star weekend be made even better?

As noted above, step one is to change the format of the Sprint Showdown to a much shorter final segment in order to really let teams race for the transfer spots. Clean air is too big a factor anymore to let them run 20 laps. The top cars are too easily able to pull away, and because many of the teams in that race are smaller teams to begin with, they don’t take any chances on tearing up equipment… and that doesn’t make for compelling racing.

NASCAR also needs to change the Fan Vote rule back to the way it was prior to 2013. If a driver can’t stay on the lead lap for 40 circuits, they aren’t going to be remotely competitive against the best drivers and richest teams in the sport. Patrick, for the record finished 20th, the last car on the lead lap in the All-Star Race.

For the night’s biggest event, the rule changes after drivers took advantage of last year’s version were good. I’d still like to see eliminations after each segment, to take it down to perhaps ten cars at the end (though that would have eliminated Danica Patrick and Dale Earnhardt, Jr., so NASCAR will never consider actually doing it). Additionally, although it was never a factor the idea of unlimited green-white-checkered finishes in this race was a good one and I hope NASCAR brings it back. This one doesn’t need a lot of changes, though… NASCAR should concentrate on making the Showdown a better race next year and leave this one alone.

Connect with Amy!

Contact Amy Henderson

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Amy Henderson and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

05/20/2013 12:32 AM

Eliminations after each segment would be great and get it down to the top ten running the final.

I can only hope funding for Danica dries up in a few years. Tired of hearing about her and she isn’t ever going to win a race in Sprint Cup

05/20/2013 04:11 AM

Throw an invert in somewhere for good measure. That’ll mix it up

05/20/2013 08:12 AM

NASCAR threw the real numbers out the window because the don’t care what fans think. Danica was going to make the race no matter what the fans voted.

05/20/2013 08:36 AM

This was the ALL-Star race.

In Nascar’s backyard.

With, I’m guessing, 40% empty seats.

Amazing. No wonder Nascar doesn’t give figures anymore.

Tom Dalfonzo
05/20/2013 09:12 AM

I am a very strong supporter of the All-Star Race being held at a different track every year. NASCAR should go for that. Imagine the All-Star Race running at Bristol? Darlington? Daytona? Talladega? Martinsville? Richmond?

05/20/2013 10:01 AM

Tom D…I agree that changing venues periodically would spice things up. But, knowing the brain power at NASCAR, I can see them picking, say, Chicago, KC, or New Hampshire instead. Wouldn’t THAT be a thrill? How about that race for Iowa?

Michael in SoCal
05/20/2013 11:25 AM

I’m with Sal – how about having the 2014 All-Star race at Iowa speedway?!?

05/20/2013 12:42 PM

Run it at a short track; “clean air” shouldn’t determine an all-star winner.

05/20/2013 01:04 PM

Eliminate 2 cars after each segment and invert the field between the 3rd and 4th segment.

05/20/2013 05:16 PM

Take the pit crew out of the equation the last segment. Exit pits as you enter. Finish is determined by driver and fastest car. Leave it up to Johnson and Knaus to make another race boring. What happened to the All Star races of old? The bumping and rubbing the last few laps.

05/21/2013 08:23 AM

The promoting of this race is a joke. It pretty much is at all of Brutons tracks. So much hype for so little substance.

I’m sorry but a million dollars to win for guys that are already millionaires doesn’t give them much incentive to go no holds barred and it showed. Even if they don’t win they still get paid, regardless of how FOX tried to spin it in their prerace.

And I hope that you are not implying that Mears staying out was a bad thing. it was the only way he could win the race so he stayed out and rolled the dice. I can’t blame him for that.

I wonder how many people are looking forward to the 600 this weekend. After Saturday’s race I’m guessing people will be finding other things to do with their weekend besides wasting time watching a 4 hour parade.

05/21/2013 03:09 PM

AAhh The obvious bias of some journalists…Oh pardon me -glorified bloggers..If your going to be a credible reporter ..Leave your personal bias at home


Contact Amy Henderson

Recent articles from Amy Henderson:

Earnhardt Ganassi Racing Announces Partnership with Cessna, Textron
Fans To Decide Format of Sprint Unlimited at Daytona
UNOH and Kentucky Speedway Extend Sponsorship Agreement
Earnhardt Out For Charlotte and Kansas After Talldega Concussion
Piquet, Jr. Wins K&N East Opener

Want to know more about Amy or see an archive of all of her articles? Check out her bio page for more information.