The Frontstretch: Put the Past Champion's Provisional Where It Belongs-In the Past! by Amy Henderson -- Thursday May 17, 2007

Go to site navigation Go to article

Put the Past Champion's Provisional Where It Belongs-In the Past!

Holding a Pretty Wheel · Amy Henderson · Thursday May 17, 2007


Just when you think it can't get any crazier, it does. Taking advantage of a long-standing NASCAR rule and a new twist on that rule, Wood Brothers/JTG Racing announced Thursday that Bill Elliott will take over driving duties in the No. 21 Little Debbie/Motorcraft Ford, beginning with the Coca-Cola 600 next weekend.

Prior to the announcement, veteran Ken Schrader and rookie Jon Wood were scheduled to split seat time this year, with Schrader grooming Wood to take over full time in 2008. Now those plans are on hold, as Elliott takes the reins for the foreseeable future. He won't be mentoring Wood as a driver, because Wood won't be driving and Schrader will no longer have to rely on a cardboard cutout if he wants to take a quick donut break. Apparently, the next several weeks will all be one big donut break for the four-time Cup Series winner and his protégé.

Why the sudden change of heart? Easy. Elliott is a past Nextel Cup Champion. This gives him automatic entry into the next six races that the car doesn't qualify for on speed. Good, I suppose, for a team that is 39th in owner points and in danger of not making races. They missed the field at Talladega and Richmond before Schrader qualified eighth at Darlington last week. Having Elliott on board would guarantee the team a start in the next six races. Bad for the team’s regular drivers, the fans, and the other drivers in the field.

The way the current rule reads, a past champion who does not qualify on time may use a provisional to start in 43rd spot. The rule was instituted when Richard Petty missed a race, prompting backlash. It's been tweaked to limit usage to six per year after a few drivers used it numerous times in the late 1990's and early 2000's, making their qualifying efforts look foolish. The rules also stipulate that the driver receiving the spot must have participated in the Cup series in the previous season, but nothing about a full-time bid in either the previous or current season. If two drivers are eligible for the spot, it goes to the most recent past champion. The last part is of no consequence to Elliott; Dale Jarrett has used his season allotment, and other recent past champions Jimmie Johnson, Tony Stewart, Kurt Busch, Matt Kenseth, Jeff Gordon, and Bobby Labonte are all firmly inside the Top 35 in owners' points, locking them into the field on points.

Given the current level of competition in Nextel Cup racing, it's time to revamp this rule or give it the heave-ho. In all six races that Jarrett used the rule, a faster car went home. When it is coupled with the Top 35 rule, a lot of faster cars went home in the first eleven races. And now, it's being used to oust two well-liked and hard-working drivers out of a ride.

Sure, Bill Elliott is a nice guy and Most Popular Driver for like 800 years in a row. But he's retired. He keeps getting persuaded to strap in one more time, but is the move because the teams want a nice guy, who was once the fastest thing on four wheels and popular to boot? No. They only want the guaranteed starting spot he can provide. It's not fair to Elliott. It's not fair to Schrader and Wood. It's not fair to the fans or the team that goes home when the provisional gets handed out.

It's time for NASCAR to reconsider this archaic practice. It's no longer for the fans. It's for the teams to buck the system and frankly, it's getting a little old. If NASCAR has to keep up appearances, the rule should at least be limited to drivers slated to run in the series full-time in the current season. That would keep the drivers hired in the seat unless they were ousted for another full time driver as is the nature of the game. It's one thing to fire a driver, it's another to shelve him until another guy has outlived his own use to the team. The way the rule is written, just about anyone with a Cup on the mantle could attempt one race this year (that's "participating") and get six free rides in 2008, taking either the seat or the starting spot away from someone else who wants to race full time, who can go faster, and who is running the full schedule for all the glory they can get on their own-without an outdated rule on their side.

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Did You Notice? … Breaking Down A Sprint Cup Season Eight Races In
Beyond the Cockpit: Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. on Growing Up Racing and Owner Loyalties
The Frontstretch Five: Flaws Exposed In the New Chase So Far
NASCAR Writer Power Rankings: Top 15 After Darlington
NASCAR Mailbox: Past Winners Aren’t Winning …. Yet
Open Wheel Wednesday: How Can IndyCar Stand Out?


©2000 - 2008 Amy Henderson and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

05/18/2007 06:16 AM


Eliminate the Past Champions Provisional! As a matter of fact, ELIMINATE the 35 guaranteed starting spots for owners!


Travis Rassat
05/18/2007 06:59 AM

You’re right on Amy, and I agree with Doug – the fastest 43 cars should make the race. One of the most exciting stories this year has been the go-or-go-home guys on qualification day, so why not spice it up a bit and extend that to the whole field?

Looking back at Talladega, since it was a impound race, the top 35 cars all qualified with race setups, but the go-or-go-home guys probably had to gamble with qualifying setups, using lighter oils, etc. When David Reutimann blew his motor with a few laps left, I had to think it was potentially because of that.

Now if everybody had to take that gamble, imagine how exciting things would be? I can see so many advantages to getting back to pure qualifying.

John Park
05/18/2007 08:39 AM

I’m surprised Mikie hasn’t put DW in the 55 before now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

05/18/2007 02:45 PM

I also agree with Doug. Not only should we get rid of the provisionals, we should also get rid of the guaranteed spots. Make every driver, whether it be Jeff Gordon or Robby Gordon fight for their spots every week. Sure, we might have someone like Jeff Gordon or Jr. miss a race once in a while, but imagine the incentive that it will give that team to do good the next week. Also, imagine all of the press attention that the team (and their sponsors) would get the next week as everyone wonders whether they will rebound and qualify.

05/18/2007 09:35 PM

This may make a few upset. I think we need to do away with the past champion and the top 35 rule. Let everyone qualify. There have been a lot of cars going home that are much faster than others. Last race there were at least some that were faster than some of the top 35. Let’s see the best each week.

Junkyard Jan
05/18/2007 11:14 PM

I don’t suppose that any of you older fans would enjoy seeing “Awesome Bill” back in a Ford product where he belongs racing again? Would you rather see ‘Never Was” Waltrip or “Has Been” Jarrett putting around the track in their Japanese garbage? I’d much rather see Bill…whom everone professed to love until a very short time ago back in the make who made him a Champ rather than the second rate Slo-Pars and Chivvies he’s raced parttime the past few years. Nascar can change the rules next year. Right now Bill and the #21 Ford may just make the top 35 without champ provisionals and amaze you newbee fans. The only one that I feel sorry for is K Schrader who made the mistake of going with Hendrick instead of Ford 20 years ago.

john wyckoff
05/20/2007 01:11 PM

The whole system needs to be totally eliminated altogether. NA$CAR has been touting this idea of an even playing field for many years now and it has been anything but. All entries should be able to qualify and have the oppurtunity to make the field based on speed alone. This fan could care less what a driver has done in the past, to me it comes down to what you have right now to make the race. The whole premise behind qualifying is how fast you are at that particular race track and not where you are in the standings. What’s the incentive to work on the car in getting it to qualify better if you know guaranteed you are spot in the field no matter how fast you are if you in the top 35 in points. If the likes Jeff Gordon, Jimmie Johnson, Matt Kenseth and so on aren’t fast enough to make the field then so be it. A change like this just might keep the points race a little tighter.


Contact Amy Henderson

Recent articles from Amy Henderson:

Earnhardt Ganassi Racing Announces Partnership with Cessna, Textron
Fans To Decide Format of Sprint Unlimited at Daytona
UNOH and Kentucky Speedway Extend Sponsorship Agreement
Earnhardt Out For Charlotte and Kansas After Talldega Concussion
Piquet, Jr. Wins K&N East Opener

Want to know more about Amy or see an archive of all of her articles? Check out her bio page for more information.