The Frontstretch: What Tire Problem? by Bryan Davis Keith -- Saturday April 2, 2011

Go to site navigation Go to article

What Tire Problem?

Bryan Davis Keith · Saturday April 2, 2011


Arriving at Martinsville a day removed from opening practice sessions for the Truck and Cup Series, it was impossible to avoid the sounds of race teams and media screaming that, for the second time in as many short track races in 2011, a massive tire debacle was about to play out on NASCAR’s biggest stage.

But is that the case? Is Sunday going to bring 500 laps of disaster, 500 laps of undriveable race cars, tire failures and racing that will have fans tuning out? The answer’s nowhere near as certain as so many have made it out to be the first two days of this annual spring weekend in Martinsville.

With this weekend’s Goodyear’s struggling to ‘rubber up’ the racetrack, many drivers are concerned these tires will blow rather than last the course of a full fuel run.

The paperclip-shaped speedway has long been a facility that the modern NASCAR machine has struggled to function at. The media center is the very definition of tight confines, nestled mere feet away from both roaring engines in the garage area and a makeshift tent that both houses scores of Goodyear Eagles and doubles as the home of driver meetings. Parking lots are nothing more than the rolling hills natural to this part of Virginia, with the occasional private residence thrown in. The track is considered one of, if not the single most difficult venue by NASCAR media insiders with regard to situating the vast armada of television trailers and equipment needed to make broadcasts happen. For all the upgrades over the years, Martinsville today resembles 1949 as much, if not more, than most short tracks nationwide – not just at the Cup level.

It is thus perhaps not surprising, then that the modern field of drivers has been so nearly unanimous in decrying the tire that Goodyear brought to Martinsville this weekend. It was the same compound that was eventually replaced before the green flag flew at Bristol two weeks ago, these Eagles didn’t “rubber the track in” as most every tire in recent Cup history has done, leaving a trail of rubber in the groove and turning racing surfaces black. Rather, this tire “marbles,” kicking little balls of rubber up to the higher groove of the track while leaving the lower groove of the racing surface all but clean.

This lack of a “rubbered” in racing surface has led many to conclude that tire wear could be an issue when the Cup guys take the green Sunday… and that the racing product itself would suffer.

“Right about lap 40 or 42, my car would just basically lose about seven-tenths on that lap and you just kind of ride around from there out,” said Kasey Kahne of his experience on track with the tires. David Reutimann noted “it [the tire] will go longer than that [about 20 laps], but then the cars become pretty unstable and very difficult to hang on to.”

Perhaps most pointed in his remarks was Dale Earnhardt, Jr., who called the entire situation “pretty disappointing” while noting that without rubber buildup “you couldn’t get out of the bottom groove. You had to run right next to the curb. If you got in the marbles, it would ruin you.”

Since the Cup drivers had their say and made their qualifying runs early Saturday afternoon, the Truck Series raced 250 laps on the surface using the same tires, as Johnny Sauter bumped his way past Kyle Busch with two laps to go to score the win. What those 250 laps showed was twofold; the track did not rubber in, and tire failures were not epidemic. The tires wore out. They did not fail.

“As bad as they feel, there’s still rubber on the tires [after a run],” said Kyle Busch in his post-race remarks. “There’s just no grip in the tires.”

Which begs the question, is there a problem at all? Saturday’s race at Martinsville was not visibly different from any other; with tons of banged up sheet metal, lots of wrecks, hot tempers, and a bump-and-run that decided the outcome. This race even had a “dart without feathers” in Chase Mattioli, who was involved in three unassisted spins over the course of the afternoon.

The answer is yes… there certainly is a problem. What the problem actually is isn’t so certain.

Assuming that it’s an absolute prerequisite to have a race tire that rubbers in the racing surface, yes, there is a problem. Dale Earnhardt, Jr. was blunt by stating, “I don’t know what else you can do. How else do you put a tire on the track and make sure it works?” when asked if he felt testing would be the solution to Goodyear’s ails of the past few weeks.

Goodyear again chose to tweak a tire and bring the compound untested to a race track. They chose not to engage in thorough tire testing even though the Car of Tomorrow evolved in the offseason, with the splitter and front end undergoing a massive revision. A new race car design, a new compound making its debut on the track, and yet no testing to accompany it. If there is a set goal in mind… to have a grippy tire that rubbers in the groove as the race progresses, Goodyear again failed through laziness, be that a lack of financial incentive or complacency as NASCAR’s exclusive tire provider. No matter the rationale, Goodyear failed.

That is, of course, assuming that there’s something inherently wrong with tires that don’t rubber in the track. And while many drivers and the media at large appear to have drawn that conclusion, the facts don’t really bear out that there is a problem at Martinsville. Sure, marbles and a tire that doesn’t rubber in leaves the teams with no notes to pull from, makes handling and trying to setup for variable temperature conditions that are expected to fluctuate by as much as 30 degrees over the course of the weekend extremely difficult. But is it asking too much for the best drivers in the world to adapt, to shut up and learn how to conserve tires instead of moaning that these give up too quickly?

Frankly, the larger issue coming to the surface this weekend is that the vast majority of today’s competitors seem genuinely worried over the prospect of having to tackle the unknown with their setups, to have to actually adjust their driving styles to fit their equipment instead of counting on modern technology to simply not break. Because the truth is, the on-track product at Martinsville for 250 laps on Saturday didn’t change. It was exactly what fans have come to expect… and at Martinsville that’s a very, very good thing.

What’s more, there was at least one driver in southern Virginia readily willing to sing the praises of this weekend’s tires. That was none other than Truck winner Johnny Sauter, who spent time both in Victory Lane and in post-race remarks singing Goodyear’s praises for bringing a tire that actually wears out, that lends the field to having comers and goers.

Good old Martinsville, taking it to the modernity of today’s NASCAR. Beating, banging, tires that wear out and the only driver in the field that seemed happy was the race winner.

Doesn’t sound like there’s any problem here at all.

Connect with Bryan!

Contact Bryan Davis Keith

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Bryan Davis Keith and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

04/03/2011 07:54 AM

The issue I have with the tire is that often it’s not the best driver that wins, but the crew chief that makes the right call in the set up. Look at Harvick in the truck race, He could barely hold on to his truck untill the crew chief changed the whole front setup. Harvick would make up two laps and finish fourth, but was it his driving or the crew chief that gets credit?
No driver is fast in an illhandling car and all are fast in a well handling one. Often the difference between winning and losing in NASCAR is the guy on the top of the pit box more then the driver. I wish Goodyear would come out with a more consistant tire that is not so sensitive to changes in setup. This way the racing will be about the best driver, not the best crew chief.
Dario won three titles in INDYCAR, but I bet you can’t name his race engineer. In NASCAR everybody knows Chad. I wonder how many titles Jimmy wins without that guy on top of the box? The tire shouldn’t make a hero out of the crew chief which is what happens too much in NASCAR.

04/03/2011 08:36 AM

Tell ya what Bad Boy Bryan, since you think driving these tires will produce such a great race, perhaps you’ll convince one of the drivers to let you take their place. Then after the race come back and tell us what a great tire that was. It’s a funny thing that people who don’t have a clue are always the ones who tell us everything’s just fine. Walk in the moccasins first. Then express an opinion.

04/03/2011 08:41 AM

Sounds like old Darlington to me. After a few laps you hang on for dear life.

04/03/2011 09:57 AM

Sounding like Darlington (or Rockingham) of old isn’t bad. But sounding like The Brickyard of 2008, will kill the race, the track, and NASCAR.

04/03/2011 02:25 PM

Pepper and Susan, I don’t get that if you have such a disliking for Bryan, or anyone else who writes a column on this website, why are you reading it? I get so tired of people like you running down the columnists. For the record, I think Frontstretch is one of the better sites for their articles and opinions. And since you both are obviously such experts, why don’t you write your own columns, and leave this one for people who might just enjoy reading what is written here.

04/03/2011 03:05 PM

It seems like in the last 5 years we have more drivers crying about the tires. While I do not want to see anyone get hurt, part of the job of these “great” drivers is to manage tire wear and the drivers who do this are the ones in the front. all of the drivers are using the same tire and it is funny how some drivers have no problem, while others can only run 20 laps without problem.

All of these drivers are not equal in talent and it is times like this that we can see the difference.