The Frontstretch: The Chase Comes Full Circle by Bryan Davis Keith -- Tuesday October 25, 2011

Go to site navigation Go to article

The Chase Comes Full Circle

The Yellow Stripe · Bryan Davis Keith · Tuesday October 25, 2011


Short of moving the Southern 500 to Fontana, there’s perhaps been nothing more maligned during Brian France’s reign at the top of stock car racing than the Chase.

Back in 2004, when that faithful move was made to put the Southern 500 on the outskirts of Los Angeles, the intent was clear; a more modern facility in a larger TV market would result in bigger money for all involved. And the result? One of NASCAR’s crown jewels died, Fontana found itself back to one Cup race within seven seasons, and the Auto Club Speedway had to cut its race length down to 400 miles as the few fans that actually showed up to the track screamed “Mercy” at the top of their lungs.

Will Edwards have “earned” a Cup with only one win? Will the NASCAR fans care?

Funny…this whole Chase thing is working just as well as did replacing the Southern 500 with the Pop Secret 500 and various other incarnations, depending on who was stupid enough to sponsor a Fontana race. After all, the Chase was created because back in 2003, a Roush Racing driver by the name of Matt Kenseth won only one race all year at Las Vegas. But by scoring more top-10 finishes than anyone else, Kenseth weathered a string of disappointing results late in the season at Talladega and Kansas and scored the championship, even as a red-hot Ryan Newman won 11 poles, eight races and won the Driver of the Year crown.

That just didn’t sit well with Sir Brian. Kenseth clinched the title a whole race early, robbing stock car racing of a playoff moment—of a four-wide, last lap session of trading paint that would crown a champion. So 30 years of precedent out the window, and a playoff structure that would work about as well as having NFL playoff teams play non-playoff teams starting at week 12 was put in place.

Fast forward to 2011, and the Chase is about to do just what it was created to prevent; crown a one-win champion that rides consistency en route to the crown. Because now, with the five-time champion eliminated in every means but mathematics from this year’s hunt, the leader is now a Roush Fenway Racing driver. A driver who has only won one race…at Las Vegas…this season and who’s leading the points not on the strength of wins, but a series-leading 22 top-10 finishes. And go figure, it’s a driver in Carl Edwards who knows just how it feels to lead the series in wins but still lose the crown (see 2008).

This isn’t rocket science. It doesn’t matter if the points get reset, or if a new points system gets put in place. Fact is, the old point system didn’t reward winning enough to create an incentive for drivers to race like Ryan Newman did in 2003, or Edwards did in 2008, to go for the win—top 10 be damned. And while the new points system certainly managed to up the penalty for a bad finish, the proportion of points to be won for finishing first instead of second went down, not up.

A system meant to ensure that winning meant more, and that the Matt Kenseths of the world didn’t stink up the show has done just that. Stink up the show, mind you, not ensure that winning actually means more than a beer shower before going home.

It was the Chase, or rather the build-up to it, that effectively castrated the Bristol night race. And it doesn’t even matter the track configuration. Who can forget the 2004 yawner on the old surface that featured a 200+ lap green flag run? Or the recent string of underwhelming events under the lights? Sure, the Carl Edwards / Kyle Busch tussle of 2008 was one for the ages, but the attendance says it all…ever since the Chase, tickets for the Bristol night race are available and advertised on TV. The guys that have to race their way in are being cautious, and the ones out of the running fear being the guy that knocks someone out of the playoffs. Not the best ingredients for compelling short-track racing.

It is the Chase that has made the intermediate oval the end-all, be-all determinant of just who can win a Cup championship. Sure, before this “playoff” gimmick those venues already accounted for 13 of 36 races on the schedule (36.1%). But now, with only the final 10 events actually counting, that number’s up to 50%. Find a multitude of fans happy about that mess.

Now, fortunately for NASCAR, should Edwards end up winning the title, Kenseth-style, it’ll be a fan favorite. It’ll be someone other than Jimmie Johnson! And it will be something to have men named France, Helton and Pemberton exclaiming that NASCAR’s 2011 champion is someone the sport should be proud to have wearing its crown.

Maybe all of that talk will be enough to mask the lack of emphasis on winning and the fact that the Chase is failing to prevent the circumstance it was created to stop. That playoffs don’t work in a 43 car field where everyone competes against each other every weekend.

Then again, why expect anything else in this era?

Contact Bryan David Keith

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Bryan Davis Keith and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

10/25/2011 10:22 AM

It will be interesting to see what changes the overlords make for next year.

Carl? A Ford? This just can’t be!

10/25/2011 11:42 AM

I really, really really hope Carl wins the title with only one win now. I’m not even a huge fan of his, I just want to see what happens amongst the NASCAR “braintrust” when it happens. Remember a couple of years ago when Montoya had like four straight top 5s in the Chase and it looked like he might win the title with NO race wins? That would’ve been even sweeter.

10/25/2011 12:21 PM

Don’t worry everyone! Neither Carl or Kenseth will win the Championship. First of all, both Jeff Gordon, and Tony Stewart have vowed revenge on Jack Roush for his alleged edict about who to draft with at Talladega. I will even bet that The Felon has already quietly issued the order to both! I can see it happening this weekend, where Gordon will put Kenseth into the wall by lap 2, and Stewart will do the same to Edwards. And it won’t be gently either! (Will Amy Henderson Cheer?) I know that’s a strong accusation, but I wouldn’t put it passed Ol’ Slicky Ricky. This title will come down between Stewart and Keselowski. Bet on it!

10/25/2011 03:50 PM

@ Rufus—link to Gordon and Stewart vowing revenge please.

Don Mei
10/25/2011 04:48 PM

Good column, Brian. Its why I dont waste more than 15 minutes every week watching the last few laps of any race. Its become boring. Winning a championship with one win is absurd and creating something like the Chase is even more absurd. A stupid reaction to a ridiculous point system.

10/25/2011 08:56 PM

What NASCAR needs is a TROPHY for the most wins in a season (the Richard Petty Trophy?). Maybe then people will stop crying about who wins the POINTS championship.

10/26/2011 07:34 AM

24Crazy, go read Richard Allan’s website, “Racing With Rich”. He had an articlle on there on Monday about Jeff and Tony vowing revenge against Roush, Ford, Edwards, and Kenseth.

10/26/2011 11:41 AM

Rufus, I think Jeff has too much class to wreck a Chase contender just because of decisions made by their bosses at Ford.

Don Mei
10/26/2011 02:25 PM

Give it a rest Rufus. The “revenge” Stewart promised involves no more co-operating with any Ford teams. Heres the quote from the column; “Apparently, the implication is that Edwards and Kenseth may receive very little cooperation from those who drive other brands as the NASCAR playoff winds down.” I dont see anything in there about anyone being driven into a wall. What utter nonsense.