The Frontstretch: Racing To The Point: A Radical Idea For The All-Star Race by Brett Poirier -- Tuesday May 21, 2013

Go to site navigation Go to article

Racing To The Point: A Radical Idea For The All-Star Race

Brett Poirier · Tuesday May 21, 2013


It’s difficult to argue that any sport has mastered the All-Star game. Major League Baseball had to add World Series implications recently because no one was watching. The NBA just has a dunk-fest, where defenses move out of the way until the final three minutes when everyone decides they want to win (sounds like NASCAR at Talladega).

Exciting competition in the All-Star race? Not happening with the current configuration.

The NHL has used East and West, then U.S. and International, and now has captains pick the teams like it is fifth-grade recess (I’m in favor of the last one.) As for the NFL’s Pro Bowl… well, where do I even get started? It features the sixth-best players at each position because the other guys blew it off, and no one wants to actually hit anyone else for fear of injury. It’s hard to blame them, but I’d rather watch Toddlers in Tiaras.

NASCAR’s All-Star version isn’t any better. Who thought it would be exciting to bring fast, aero-dependent cars, put them on a smooth 1.5-mile track, and give them four fresh tires with 10 laps to go? How was that recipe ever going to lead to a good finish? If I were coming up with a formula to create the least amount of passing possible, that would be it. Let’s analyze. The fresh tires make it so everyone sticks to Charlotte’s repaved surface, and 10 laps is too short of a time for the tires to wear and any actually interesting racing to take place. It’s quite possibly the worst idea ever; well, besides the XFL.

Jimmie Johnson’s crew pulled off an 11.8-second final pit stop, seemingly a modern-era record and after a short fight with teammate Kasey Kahne, “Five-Time” drove to the easiest victory of his life on Saturday. He was rewarded with more than $1 million in pocket change, or roughly $11,111 per lap completed. That’s the second biggest payday behind the Daytona 500, and for what? Why do we need to be dishing out seven digits in a race that is supposed to be for the fans?

If there is one thing I wish I could change about the All-Star Race, it’s the money. Not only the money from the purses, but also the profits that somehow keep this event in Charlotte, year after year. If finances weren’t a factor, think of the possibilities.

Here is what I would do. Scrap the entire current format because it isn’t working — that might even include the actual Sprint Cup car. Let’s take the drivers back to their roots and put them all in Late Models at a local short track. Tracks from around the country could bid for the right to host the event, and it could stop somewhere different each season.

The seats may hold only 5,000 spectators compared to Saturday’s All-Star race… actually, I think there were probably like 5,000 fans there, too. But the sport could stop at places it hasn’t been in decades, frontiers such as Thompson Speedway (0.625 miles) in Connecticut. The sport will gain new fans and the local short tracks, which are probably struggling, would be rewarded with a big payday to keep racing going, keeping the next generation coming through the turnstiles.

The oval selected could run single-car qualifying laps to set the order for the heats (and to drag out the event). On race night, a series of heat races could determine which drivers qualify for the feature, with a last-chance qualifier race thrown in at the end for good measure. And then, for the feature, just line them up and let them race. Other than maybe a halftime break, no gimmicks. Who wouldn’t watch that?

As Tom Bowles touched on in his column on Monday, the 2013 All-Star Race was way too predictable. When the word predictable is taken out of the equation in sports, that is when we have our best moments. Those are the ones that get fans on the edge of their seats. Take the stars from the top form of stock car racing, put them where it all started, and it would be anything but predictable. That is, unless Chad Knaus is just as good with a Late Model.

And winning the All-Star Race — if we even still called it that — would be more about pride than money. O. Bruton Smith can keep his $1 million. The winner of my All-Star race would win something like $50,000, and it would go to that driver’s charity — stealing an idea from Tony Stewart’s Prelude to the Dream.

I guarantee that would get higher television ratings and garner more interest into the sport than what we have now. All-Star games should be about putting on a show for the fans, not raking in the cash. We need to think outside of the box to fix it. I guess I’m just dreaming, though. The race will be back in Charlotte next year, probably with some new twist that’ll generate some noise, but won’t fix something that has been broken for more than a decade.

I’d suggest heading to your local short track that night for a better show.

Contact Brett Poirier

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
NASCAR Easter Eggs: A Few Off-Week Nuggets to Chew On
Five Points To Ponder: NASCAR’s Take-A-Breath Moment
Truckin’ Thursdays: Top Five All-Time Truck Series Drivers
Going By the Numbers: A Week Without Racing Can Bring Relief But Kill Momentum


©2000 - 2008 Brett Poirier and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

05/21/2013 01:47 AM

Absolutely my opinion. The All-Star race should be a blast, year for year for year.
You can’t have a good show on a 1.5 miler, you need to go to a Short Track, like the short tracks that you wrote or go to Martinsville!

My All-Star race: – 25 cars – Martinsville – 5 segments
— 4 Segments á 20 Laps, last 5 cars will be eliminated every segment.

- Every Lead lap give the driver 10.000 bucks, the winner after segment 5 get 1 million, the others nothing.

The last segment would be only 10 Laps with 4-5 cars. I think it would be a hell of a show. And next year, you go to a other short track.

Steve K
05/21/2013 02:42 AM

I think I prefer the status quo to this idea. I watch NASCAR Cup racing to watch Cup drivers drive Cup cars. (Let’s have the MLB All-Stars play softball!)

Change the track? I guess you could. How about have Goodyear bring a softer tire? Maybe move the starting order around after each segment and then average their finishes. See how each guy does in the front, back, middle. reorder and do the ten laps on soft tires or even used soft tires.

If nothing else, bring a softer tire Goodyear.

05/21/2013 11:49 AM

I’d love to see the Cup guys run Thompson. Not necessarily for the All-Star race, but just in general, that would be a fantastic track for a Cup race.

05/21/2013 09:49 PM

My thought is to let them run something that is normally illegal. Like letting them all run pressure release valves on their tires or such. Anything to make the racing more interesting.

These cars are still too aero dependent and obviously Johnson had his set up for being in clean air, because he was never a factor until he got clean air, and then he was just gone. Boring as hell.

05/22/2013 12:04 PM

I heard someone mention Bowman Gray stadium. At first I thought it was crazy, but it really isn’t. It’s right in NC. They’ve started 24 K&N cars on that track and the all star race will have less than that. Have 4 40 lap segments and a final 20 lap shootout. The buzz around that event would be unbelievable.