The Frontstretch: Should NASCAR Race Outside the US? by Danny Peters -- Friday April 18, 2008

Go to site navigation Go to article

Should NASCAR Race Outside the US?

Nuts for Nationwide · Danny Peters · Friday April 18, 2008

 

The first commercial produced by Nextel to mark their arrival into NASCAR at the beginning of the 2004 season was a one minute long spot called "Anthem" featuring a rousing soundtrack and clips of racing action from the early days of racing on Daytona Beach right through to the then-present day. The ad was Nextel's way of honoring the history and tradition of the Cup Series, as well as showing NASCAR fans they understood what they were taking on. Here's an excerpt from the end of the voiceover that accompanies the ad:

You want to know about America?

It's in the squeal of rubber, the scream of the engine and the roar of humanity…seeing one of its own triumph against the odds. It's there in a last lap duel. Joyous as Victory Lane, devastating as hitting the rail. Here, life lessons are learnt and man it's as obvious as the number of the car in pole position.

It's simple – NASCAR born in America.

Juan Pablo Montoya won in Mexico last season, but the question remains, should NASCAR venture outside the US?

The sentiment expressed is two-fold in that it pays homage to the competitiveness of the sport as well as honoring and celebrating the roots and tradition of the greatest racing series in the world. But since 2004, the All-American sport has become increasingly international. Toyota's arrival in Truck then Cup and Nationwide, the first foreign manufacturer in the sport in 40 years, and a driver pool at Cup level that now includes a Colombian, a Scot and a French Canadian are some of the changes. This weekend, the expansion continues as the Nationwide Series returns to Mexico for a fourth straight year. With the Cup Series enjoying a rare weekend off, the eyes of the racing public will be on the Autodromo Hermanos Rodriguez - a storied road course in Mexico City. So it's as appropriate a time as any to consider whether or not the quintessentially American sport should continue to sanction races outside of the US?

As is often the case, it's best to start with the echoes of the past. Go all the way back to 1952, to the 18th race, and you'll see it was held on the Canadian side of Niagara Falls at a track called Stamford Park in Ontario - the first time NASCAR had ever raced in another country. The flat half-mile dirt horse track hosted just the one Cup race and Buddy Shuman won. It was the only victory in a 29-race, 4-year Cup level career for Shuman who perished tragically in a hotel fire in November 1955. It was another six years before NASCAR made a second sojourn north off the border. This time the race was held at the Canada Exposition Stadium, a third of a mile oval. The 100-lap race was won by Lee Petty but it's also notable for being the first start for none other than Richard Petty just 16 days after his 21st birthday. The King finished 17th out of a field of 19 - his day ended by a crash after 55 laps.

It would be another 47 years before NASCAR ventured outside the borders of the United States. This time the focus was south rather than north with the Autodromo Hermanos Rodriguez picking up a slot on the Nationwide Schedule. The famed 2.518-mile road course has played host to a number of racing events including 15 Formula One races. In many ways it was a logical move. As then CoO of NASCAR, George Pyne, noted: “[This] is a long-term commitment to embrace Mexican fans throughout Mexico and the U.S….This is a great opportunity for NASCAR to connect with Mexican Motorsports fans as well as Mexican-Americans, who represent nearly 60% of an integral part of the U.S. Hispanic demographic.” Over the last ten years NASCAR has grown exponentially and it is now broadcast in more than 150 countries and 23 different languages. Embracing this global audience is a given of modern business and Mexico was a great place to start.

In 2007, NASCAR added another "foreign" race to the schedule. Once again, they chose a famed Formula One track – the Circuit Gilles Villeneuve in picturesque Montreal. Located on Ile Notre-Dame, a man-made island in the St. Lawrence River, the 2.71 mile road course was named after the late Gilles Villeneuve (Jacques' father) who died as a result of injuries sustained in a qualifying crash at the 1982 Belgian Grand Prix.

It was another "safe" choice, in expansion terms, as Canada already had a strong base of public support as evidenced by those who travel to races in the Northern United States, not to mention a history of support for racing (CASCAR). As Brian France noted: “We know that this event is going to expand the footprint of NASCAR." Expand the footprint it certainly has.

The question remains, however, as to whether or not it's a good thing for the sport. Well, from what we’ve seen so far in terms of attendance, quality of racing, media coverage and general interest levels, you'd have to say the four events have been a rousing success. In many ways, NASCAR made the softest of choices in taking races outside of the States. Mexico and Canada are relatively easy geographically and do not present the sort of logistical challenges racing in Europe or Asia would present. Two races on a 35 race schedule in countries that immediately border the US is hardly an outlandish "foreign" schedule and it's certainly not a betrayal of NASCAR's past.

There's no doubt it's more of a logistical challenge for the cash-strapped Nationwide teams, not least in terms of paperwork, general immigration procedures and simply transporting all the equipment over the border. Mexico City is a long drive for the trusty hauler drivers, but at a shade under 2000 miles from Charlotte, North Carolina, it's still 400 miles less than the hike to California. Plus the purses compensate—the 2007 Mexico race had a total purse of 2.179 million, second only to Daytona at 2.258 million. The third best purse was Montreal at 1.758 million. The next closest was Vegas at 1.35 million. The trips might be arduous, but the rewards can more than make up for it.
The real issue, though, is whether or not the expansion is at the expense of the roots of the sport. Are there tracks in the US that are more deserving of a race date? Isn't giving back to a domestic community a better option than expanding your borders internationally? Shouldn't the race dates in Mexico and Canada go to stimulating the economy in the US rather than promoting the sport overseas? Tough questions that can be answered on many levels and in multiple different ways and frankly I'm not sure I'm qualified.

Ultimately, the keys with any future expansion will be frequency and location. A gentle introduction of two foreign tracks in four years is not a sign that NASCAR is about to go F1 and race all over the world. While you never know what will happen in life and indeed in NASCAR, I think it's fairly safe to say it will be a long time before we see a points paying Sprint Cup race held away from the States. And I think it's a cast iron certainty that you'll never see NASCAR open up in Japan as the Boston Red Sox and the Oakland A's did this year for Major League Baseball. There are no immediately obvious locations for NASCAR to stage another foreign race - no other markets crying out for a date. With the two races entrenched on the schedule, NASCAR can afford to play a waiting game and see what develops over the next few years. So should NASCAR race outside the US? I'd say yes, but it's a cautious one. There's no sense trampling on tradition and rushing the situation. At the end of the day, NASCAR is and will always be "Born in America."

NASCAR NEWS, RIGHT TO YOUR INBOXAND IT’S FREE.
The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…
FREE NEWSLETTER! CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP

 

©2000 - 2008 Danny Peters and Frontstetch.com. Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

mark
04/18/2008 07:47 AM
permalink

Nice article, well thought out, lots of good facts. But! You asked a question, “Should NA$CAR race outside the United States?” For NA$CAR the answer is simple. Yes, there is money there and we’re going to get it, to hell with anyone else or what they think or how it impacts them. That’s 99 % of NA$CAR’s problem, I truly believe all they really care about is their business, their bottom line, their profits….and no one else’s. Enough said!

wendel wilson
04/18/2008 08:07 AM
permalink

Nice article… too bad you don’t knpow your NASCAR or what your talking about, the Busch race at Mexico City was not the “nsxt time in 47 years.”
You forgot that Nascar packed all thier bags and cars and Raced in Japan from 1996 to 1998!!!!!….. another reporter with no clue…

Check your facts next time your write something…

FS_Danny
04/18/2008 08:58 AM
permalink

Wendel – thanks for the back handed complement. It amuses me that you suggest I don’t know what I am talking and yet at the same time tell me it was a nice article. No matter though, and to answer your issue; I deliberately didn’t mention the Japan races. In fact I had the information in the article as an author’s note but took it out because I felt it wasn’t relevant and the article was long enough already. The other reason why I removed the section on Japan was that as you know doubt know 3 of the 4 races staged in Japan were exhibition races with only the 1999 Coca-Cola 500 in the NASCAR West Series at the Twin Ring Motegi was a full points-paying race.

Johnboy60
04/18/2008 09:19 AM
permalink

Well Danny for various reasons that all are aware of the answer to your question is: NO!!!

Marty C
04/18/2008 12:01 PM
permalink

You’re right about the races in Japan being exibition races and thus do not belong in the story, but since Wendel seems to think he is the NASCAR expert, HE should have included the race in Australia that NASCAR sent several cars and drivers to before any of the Japanese races. NeilBonnet won that in the Valvoline Pontiac. Maybe HE should check his facts!

As to should NASCAR run outside of the US, the answer is NO! For the life of me, I can’t understand why NASCAR fells they must be an international sport. What’s wrong with being an American Sport. Don’t get me wrong, I love the road courses, but we hve plenty of road courses here in the US for American fans to attend races. Road Atlanta is a great track in the heart of old time NASCAR country. The Busch series use to race there. There are great road courses in many areas of the US where NASCAR doesn’t race now that would love to have a NASCAR race. Keep NASCAR here.

mmack
04/18/2008 12:45 PM
permalink

If Toyota has the “pull” everyone credits them having, expect a race at Twin-Ring Motegi in Japan in the foreseeable future, even if the teams or the US fan base doesn’t want it. Honda and Toyota brought CART, and later the IRL, to run a race there (The IRL is running there this weekend, while Champ Car’s swan song is in Long Beach, CA Sunday). It was sort of a “quid pro quo” for supplying engines to CART and the IRL. So I wouldn’t be surprised as Toyota grows in prominence to see them try the same “power-play” on NASCAR.

Rick
04/18/2008 02:07 PM
permalink

Yeah, NASCAR was born in America… and hockey was born in Canada… you want to shut down all the American teams in the NHL? Give me a break. Racing is racing. Why wouldn’t you want to race someplace where the fans wanted you? Guaranteed, you build a new track in the Niagara Falls region and you’d sell 200,000 tickets twice a year. California can’t even fill the seats and there’s more people in California than in all of Canada.
Just let em race. up here in Canada, we know damn well NASCAR is an American sport and we appreciate where it came from and we love the history of NASCAR. That doesn’t mean NASCAR can’t come to visit once a year.
Like Kyle Petty said, Juan Pablo Montoya has the most southern accent of anyone in Cup.
Let em race.

Mark
04/18/2008 02:37 PM
permalink

“I meant to leave out Japan because the article was getting too long “ ? Sure . NASCAR is not going to be doing a lot more outside the US because as you mentioned , there is absolutly no demand for NASCAR racing outside of our country . Just as the NFL is an American only obsession , so it is with NASCAR . Race fans on other continents much prefer F1 , the worlwide attendance leader , over stock car racing . They have their own versions of stock car racing of course , mostly on road courses , they just aren’t as popular as F1 .

Hollis
04/23/2008 05:59 AM
permalink

Most people in the US don’t have passports though……

Contact Danny Peters