The Frontstretch: If NASCAR Drivers Were Movie Stars, Who Would Be On The A-List? by Danny Peters -- Tuesday July 1, 2008

Go to site navigation Go to article

With the sultry heat of the summer melting the tarmac of the New York City sidewalks, the ads promoting new movies are out in force. Whether they come from the sides of city buses, giant store display windows that burst out of the glass, or a plethora of ads on any channel you care to watch, the message is hard to miss — summer is the season of the movie blockbuster.

I’m not talking nourishing cinematic fare here, either, with exquisitely scripted prose and Oscar potential. I’m talking about the empty-calorie laden goodness of a full-on action movie. You know, the sort of flick where the hero defeats the bad guy, saves the world against innumerable odds, gets the hot girl, and still has time for a ton of pithy quips — all in a nice hour and a half package. For those sorts of summer hits, it’s all about the final box office numbers and that critical opening weekend. And to be the next summertime hit, nothing brings the dollars pouring into the movie house coffers like a top notch A-list star. The bigger the actor or actress, the more popular the movie is likely to be; and the more top names you can put on the poster or in your trailer, the better off you’ll be.

So, in the spirit of the mindless but oh-so-enjoyable summer movies, if our favorite NASCAR stars were to replace the ones on the silver screen, who’d be on the A-list? Who would sell out movie houses in every state? Who would win Oscars, and who’d win the decidedly less glamorous Emmies? Who would be the rising stars, the break out names, and who would be the fading icons in need of a hit? And — in pseudo-honor of Kathy Griffin and her excruciatingly painful “Life on the D-list” show — who’d prop up the pile?

As always, here’s a few ground rules to begin with. I’ve considered only the Top 50 drivers in the current Sprint Cup Standings and — although in some cases past performance is taken into account — I’m basing these grades more on recent history. Popularity is, of course, a critical factor, as is marketability and perhaps just a smidgen of author bias. After all, in a list such as this it would be hard to not be just a little less objective than on other more weighty issues in the NASCAR world these days…

THE A-LIST

The Oscar Winner: Dale Earnhardt, Jr.
There can really be only one name in this category, and that’s Dale Jr. He’s the biggest crossover star in the sport today, and if you ask the average person who doesn’t have any interest in NASCAR to name one driver, even money says it’s the kid from Kannapolis they name. In box office terms, crowds would be waiting on line around the block the length and breadth of this fine country to watch a movie with the No. 88 taking center stage.

The Oscar Nominated Superstars: Tony Stewart, Jeff Gordon, Jimmie Johnson
With eight championships between them, Gordon, Smoke, and Jimmie J are deservedly in an elite category. After Junior, you’d have to say this list would see the punters pack movie houses everywhere.

The Bona Fide Box Office Luminaries: Mark Martin, Kasey Kahne, Kyle Busch
Some might raise eyebrows at Kyle Busch’s inclusion over other names, but in a decade, we might just be looking back at 2008 as the first of his multiple championship campaigns. He’s scary good, and what’s more, he’s with one of the best teams in the business: so it’s only gonna to get better. Kahne is in based on his immense popularity and good looks, while Mark Martin makes this category because a superstar is exactly what he is.

The Established “Big” Names: The Biff (Greg Biffle), Matt Kenseth, Kevin Harvick, Jeff Burton
Four more solid names in today’s NASCAR world would be hard to find. For the most part, this quartet are a threat wherever they run; and in the NASCAR stratosphere, they’re right at the top of all the director (owner) wanted lists.

The Break Out Stars: Clint Bowyer, Denny Hamlin, Carl Edwards
So far, Hamlin and Edwards have multiple wins and multiple Chase appearances in their relatively short careers, and both have the potential to become a Sprint Cup champion in short order. But remember, potential is one thing – delivering on it’s a whole other issue altogether. Time will tell if these budding stars can make it stick, or if they simply fade slowly into obscurity. Bowyer is a step behind in terms of success, but the same tenet applies to the amiable Kansas native.

The Aspiring A-listers: Martin Truex, Jr., David Ragan, Ryan Newman, Juan Pablo Montoya, Brian Vickers
The five drivers on the Aspiring A-list represent an interesting mix. Montoya, you sense, could go A-list with the right role (read: equipment) — and to a certain extent, so could Newman. Ragan and Vickers are improving fast, and so is Truex; but for DEI, despite its history, the road to success proves a whole different matter altogether. Depending on where he lands — whether it’s Hendrick, Childress, or back at DEI — that will determine whether this is a list that Truex could be even higher on next year.

THE B-LISTERS

The Fading Former Stars: Kurt Busch, Bobby Labonte, Elliott Sadler
This is not a category you want to be in — and it’s a tad harsh, perhaps. But for Kurt Busch, when you’re not even remotely the most famous sibling in your family, you’re no longer in the A-list category. Labonte may be on the verge of better times with Petty Enterprises, but it’s been a long time since he’s had any at all. However, it’s E-Sad who’s faded further than most these past couple of years. Five Top 10s in fifty races is not the stuff of racing legend. The amiable Virginian better be hoping some of his teammate Kahne’s recent magic rubs off.

The Matinee Idols: Casey Mears, Jamie McMurray, Reed Sorenson
Mears and McMurray are the very definition of Matinee Idols, who are traditionally adored in far greater levels than their talent necessarily deserves. With Roush needing to contract a team, McMurray is most under threat, but Mears cannot afford to continue to sit 30th in the standings given his equipment and his newly acquired free agent status.

Fans and media alike routinely chase after the opinionated Robby Gordon, possessing an off-track persona and an on-track aggression all his own. So, where’s the movie contract?

The Independent Film Actors: Robby Gordon
As always, the lone wolf is in a category all of his, well, lonesome. Gordon’s not A-list, and — based on his stats — probably not really B-list; but given the rest of his racing resume, the driver of the No. 7 car is a big name regardless of team and manufacturer affiliation.

The Classic Movie Stars: Bill Elliott, Kyle Petty, Ken Schrader
The three names on the list make this category based on years of accumulated experience and success. While they don’t win like they used to and often don’t run even remotely close to how they once did, these three all still have plenty of loyal fans, and even they know there’s still plenty of cachet in the “power of a big name.”

THE C-LISTERS

The Sequel Actors: Dave Blaney, Joe Nemechek, Michael Waltrip
Front Row Joe is a superb nickname, but Finish Line Joe would be better (if not quite as snappy). Blaney’s never had the luck while Waltrip — perhaps he deserves his own category — is here because he’s more often C-list than A-list (and that’s especially so if you’re a regular watcher of This Week in NASCAR).

The “Foreign Film” Stars: Patrick Carpentier, A.J. Allmendinger, Dario Franchitti, Sam Hornish, Jr.
A diverse list, including a Scot with a movie star wife, a French Canadian, and an A.J. Allmendinger. This group resides on the C-list for good reason: they’ve got no track record of success yet, but the operative word in that sentence — of course — is yet.

THE D-LISTERS

The Straight-to-DVDers: Michael McDowell, Paul Menard, David Gilliland, Travis Kvapil, David Reutimann
Urgh — the worst category based on this article, as the five drivers named above finish up the bottom of this pile. What you can say, however, is that there are only two ways to go from here: up or out. However, for all of them time is still on their side…

The Lifetime Movie (ahem) stars: J.J. Yeley, Regan Smith, Scott Riggs, Aric Almirola
When your level is Lifetime, well, that says something, doesn’t it? (P.S.: Before I enrage some of you, hi Shereen! I know … Lifetime produces gripping drama and fine movie programming).

The Long-Time Achievement Award: Dale Jarrett
DJ is in a class of his own: a top of the list star. After a disappointing season, the transition to the booth will ease the pain of not mashing the gas week in and week out.

Not ranked: Mike Skinner, John Andretti, Jeremy Mayfield, Sterling Marlin.

Contact Danny Peters

NASCAR NEWS, RIGHT TO YOUR INBOXAND IT’S FREE.
The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…
FREE NEWSLETTER! CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP

 

©2000 - 2008 Danny Peters and Frontstetch.com. Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

allen
07/01/2008 04:58 AM
permalink

It’s this kind of top notch reporting that keeps this site from being what it could/should be.

Kyle petty has won EIGHT races in 823. He’s our classic movie star? If the dude wasn’t RP’s kid he would be working at the beer stand. But here he’s staring in our classic movie.

If it wasn’t for Matt, I think this site would probably get about 5 hits a day.

hank lee
07/01/2008 11:07 AM
permalink

Surely you aren’t talking about the same Matt who has absolutely nothing good to say about racing? All he does is complain, with the exception of last week’s column about loud, fast cars I usually read matt’s article just to see the bashing.

True Fan
07/01/2008 11:28 AM
permalink

At least Danny can take his “medicine” like a trooper and allow commentary from people who don’t always agree with him ; to say the least , unlike some of the other columnist on this site and futhermore is sometimes unconventional approach to topics is refreshing instead of playing follow the leader with you “regional fans” who lack the ability to separate emotions from what’s really happening in Nascar. Go Danny P. Frontstretch’s rookie of the year!

Steve Cloyd
07/01/2008 01:03 PM
permalink

David Reutimann straight to DVD? I think he’s done pretty well given the crappy circumstances his team puts him in every week.

Other than that, I’d say it’s pretty good.

As far as Matt, he’s the main reason I come here. He tells it like it is, warts and all; and there are a ton of warts these days, sadly.

Battiman
07/01/2008 06:13 PM
permalink

Dale Jr. is a Box Office Megastar…not an Oscar (aka title) winner. The oscars are for current Drivers with titles…Dale Sr. qualified not Jr. Jr. is pure box office…“Rocky” of his day.

Marc
07/01/2008 11:08 PM
permalink

This has to be the stupidest, most asanine column I have ever read. If a frog had wings he wouldn’t bump his butt, and if Brian France were a real CEO, we would not be reduced to such dribble as this.

Hollis
07/02/2008 06:58 AM
permalink

Asinine, not asanine old chap.

Now come on all, where’s your sense of fun ? The article is just a tongue in cheek look at the season and players so far….

Did Villeneuve just get cut to the floor ?

Contact Danny Peters