The Frontstretch: Talking NASCAR TV: TNT's Wide Open Coverage Has Some Gaps by Doug Turnbull -- Tuesday July 8, 2008

Go to site navigation Go to article

Talking NASCAR TV: TNT's Wide Open Coverage Has Some Gaps

Doug Turnbull · Tuesday July 8, 2008

 

There is nothing quite like a Saturday night race — especially one presented without commercial interruption. The Coke Zero 400 on TNT was a thrilling broadcast from start to finish, even during some of the long green flag runs, in large part because of the Wide Open Coverage that gave us the ability to watch far more of the race than usual. According to cawsnjaws.com, the network broke away from full race coverage for just 17 minutes all night long. Of course, there were far more times when their sponsors popped up in the video box at the bottom of the screen, but TNT did not do a bad job at all of integrating those mandatory commercial ads during the race broadcast. The extra space created by those special ads was used wisely, with extra information about drivers placed in what would have been a massive HD ribbon of blank space.

But for all the extra racing TNT wound up offering fans, there still remains some problems to be solved after their second attempt at Wide Open Coverage. The ticker for the race ran at the bottom of the screen, instead of at the top; and below the ticker was a blank space that was filled repeatedly with driver stats. The information was good, but the thumbnail pictures of each driver were too big for the blank space, and the top of their headshots obstructed the ticker when displayed. Making the pictures smaller would have been an easy solution to an obvious problem; luckily, the ticker’s information rolled behind the driver’s picture and into a viewable position.

And then, there was the issue of what the network would call “branded content.” Although TNT placed the commercials within the broadcast well, it did seem awkward how Bill Weber would break out into praise for Coors Light in the middle of a Kyle Petty-Wally Dallenbach conversation about the race. You know it’s something that had to be said, but it always came out looking like an interruption more than anything else. The actual commercial ads themselves that popped up during the event did not obstruct the racing action very much, but it would have been a better idea for TNT to make the racing picture smaller and place the ad in the blank space, instead of sometimes blocking views of the race track itself with the sponsor on the screen.

The only commercial breaks in the broadcast were local commercial breaks, which likely will never be avoided. But these were well-placed by the network, and were cleared in plenty of time to capture the entire last segment of the race. In particular, it was great to be able to see every pit stop and restart that we miss so often during the course of a normal broadcast. However, during one of the rejoins to the race coverage from a local break, viewers could still hear what sounded like Dallenbach talking in the background before Weber began the rejoin script. That mistake happens sometimes, but it had to be a relief that Wally was not caught dropping an F-bomb — like Kyle Petty was when he was an in-car reporter for TNT at Sonoma last year. Even with fewer commercials, the audio guy needs to know when to press that mute button!

But even with those minor mistakes, it’s clear the people in FOX, TNT, and ESPN/ABC’s sports advertising departments need to work with the major sponsors of NASCAR races to make the revenue feasible to do this kind of coverage, or other variances, far more often. In an interview with Frontstretch.com’s Matt Taliaferro, Executive Producer of NASCAR on TNT Jeff Behnke said that the reason their network and others cannot do coverage like this is because it is cost-prohibitive. Well, sponsors and marketing masters need to begin devising a plan to work around that; it’d be a big plus for their fans if they can make this coverage happen in as many races as they possibly can. As I said during one of my columns about FOX’s NASCAR coverage, the networks need to keep up with the ever-expanding realms of media that are making television obsolete, and commercial interruption-free broadcasts are a huge step in that direction.

Despite the serviceable execution of the Wide Open coverage, TNT did make a few major errors in its overall race broadcast:

  • At the end of the race, two key pieces to the finish did not make their way home to the viewers. The first involved the major crash on the last lap. TNT’s camera crew and directors solely focused themselves on the big crash and neglected to do any kind of split-screen of the side-by-side battle for the lead, a battle to the checkers that later had to be decided by video. The second foible happened when the boys in the booth were so busy analyzing the big crash that they neglected to show live footage of race winner Kyle Busch’s burnout. Showing the burnout of a race winner should be mandatory for all race broadcasts; and at the very least, the director of the broadcast could have at least thrown up a split-screen of Busch doing his spinout while the boys rambled on about the wreck.

Kyle Busch’s burnout is cool to see on a photograph, but it’d be far more pleasurable if it was captured on live TV by the TNT broadcast.

  • There were also a few mess-ups in the pre-race coverage. When Marc Fein asked Kyle Petty what his tips were for the race, Kyle said his only tip was for drivers and fans to stay hydrated with Coke Zero. Man; that product plug was worse than any Michael Waltrip has ever done.

Lindsay Czarniak has done a splendid job on pit road this year, but a before-the-race mess-up was funny to hear, nonetheless. Czarniak was not quite expecting a toss to her while preparing to interview a driver, and viewers heard her producer quickly telling her a fact about that driver — something which she immediately said on the air. This only goes to show that the pit road reporters do not actually have all of their facts memorized; but still, they still do a great job and should be commended for their work.

  • TNT spends a lot of money trying to look professional during its broadcasts, but no amount of cash can make up for the fact that Kyle Petty’s lips and words were not at all synced up when he was driving the pace car.
  • Can someone explain why the crew had to film several of the Wally’s World segments at Pocono? Why couldn’t he drive the TNT car at New Hampshire and Daytona? Live driving footage is way better than voicing over the NASCAR.com RaceView every week.
  • TNT also needs to check the spelling its crew uses on the rundown ticker. Two-time champion Jimmie Johnson’s name was spelled “Jimmy” on the ticker all race long … and that’s not the first time that’s happened, either. He is not Kirk Shelmerdine, people… spell his name right!
  • ESPN did a good job during its Nationwide Series broadcast Friday night. One of the shining moments of the race was actually the post-race show, when Jamie Little interviewed Mike Wallace after his nephew Steve wrecked him on the last lap. Wallace’s quotes were great, but two thumbs go up for Little, who did not wuss out and asked Wallace the question about how to handle a family member wrecking him.
  • One glaring ESPN mistake occurred away from its improving NASCAR team again. The Sunday morning ticker on SportsCenter read the race results for the Coke Zero 400, followed by a headline that Paul Menard sat on the pole for the race. Obviously, the person who inputs information on the ticker forgot where the “delete” button on the computer was. As we’ve said before in this space, mistakes like that should not happen if you want to be taken seriously as a leader of NASCAR coverage.

TNT’s final race of the season will be at Chicagoland next week, once again held under the bright lights of Saturday night. Check this column next week for analysis of the television coverage, as well as a look at what ESPN will bring to the NASCAR table towards the end of July!

Contact Doug Turnbull

NASCAR NEWS, RIGHT TO YOUR INBOXAND IT’S FREE.
The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Did You Notice? … Breaking Down A Sprint Cup Season Eight Races In
Beyond the Cockpit: Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. on Growing Up Racing and Owner Loyalties
The Frontstretch Five: Flaws Exposed In the New Chase So Far
NASCAR Writer Power Rankings: Top 15 After Darlington
NASCAR Mailbox: Past Winners Aren’t Winning …. Yet
Open Wheel Wednesday: How Can IndyCar Stand Out?
FREE NEWSLETTER! CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP

 

©2000 - 2008 Doug Turnbull and Frontstetch.com. Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

Mark
07/08/2008 07:24 AM
permalink

That was the best broadcast of the year….even with it’s minor flaws and goofs. I’m sure if they continue to do these types of broadcasts, they will get better. I think we all need to drop a note to NA$CAR and tell them what we like….. not that they will listen, but it couldn’t hurt.

Ken Smith
07/08/2008 08:34 AM
permalink

Personally I didn’t miss not seeing Kyle do the burnout at all! I feel those silly burnouts are juvenile at best – and you don’t see the older drivers doing them. Interesting to note that when Ryan Hunter-Reay won the IRL race at Watkins Glen on Sunday and started to do a burnout – a voice came over his radio saying “Win With Class”, “and remember we need to run that engine next week!”

dawg
07/08/2008 08:45 AM
permalink

Personally, It wouldn’t bother me a bit if I NEVER saw another burnout!

Jeff G
07/08/2008 08:55 AM
permalink

I agree with Ken Smith on the burnouts. I wish NASCAR would ban it, and tell the drivers a victory lap with the checkered flag would be allowed. I think the burnout is just plain stupid.

Mike The Insane One
07/08/2008 09:42 AM
permalink

The best thing about the broadcast was we didn’t have to hear that much from Weber and Marry Mac with the way the commercials were handled. The less those two say, the better.

Dennis
07/08/2008 10:02 AM
permalink

Lindsay Czarniak can just read the phone book for all I care. She is the best part of most boring races.

chase
07/08/2008 12:21 PM
permalink

Doug is right on the $ again. The ticker was way too high size-wise, and we all know what the drivers look like so there was no need for driver pics either. Running the ticker on top in ‘NORMAL SIZE AND HEIGHT’ would have given the viewers a much better view.Weber has got to go. Everytime he opens his mouth or else the camera is on him, he sounds and looks condenscending as usual. He’s past it and why he has the position he has is beyond my realm of comprehension.Everyone else did a terrific job & as I said on another post on another site, I actually remember the commercials during the race – it forces you to not only watch the race but also listen and let your eyes check out the commercials as well – to me it’s a no brainer and I don’t know why the networks AND the companies don’t figure this out! Thanks!

Marty C
07/08/2008 12:23 PM
permalink

I agree, do away with the burnouts!

Since this was a TNT broadcast, you’d think they would be able to do their own program promotions on the “wide open coverage” instead of the whole screen “local” breaks. Also I got very annoyed at Bill Weber constantly interrupting saying “This portion of the race brought to you by…” We knew who sponsored that portion of the race. It was right there at the bottom of the screen!

In general though it’s a good idea, just needs some refinement.

Jeff G
07/08/2008 03:53 PM
permalink

chase makes a good point. I also caught myself watching the sponsor commercials at the bottom of the screen as I watched the race at the same time. It was a great way to broadcast the race.
I LIKE doing two things at once…cool

Mike H
07/08/2008 05:00 PM
permalink

If memory serves it was Na$car that would not allow ESPN’s split screen ads? TNT’s is better & the best part is NO DW!! Weber is bad, but at least he doesn’t constantly promote himself or some crap on “his store”. I agree, get rid of burnouts period!! All in all, it’s a good concept, better then others & could be great. It also does get more people to notice the ads.

Aleen
07/08/2008 08:50 PM
permalink

One thing that bothered me was TNT seems to use a long shot for most of the race, like they are trying to show the whole field of cars all of the time. My TV isn’t huge, and I couldn’t tell what car was what for most of the race.

They showed half the infield or stands in every shot.

NASCAR coverage seems to have went to a more “guys sitting around talking” than the traditional ESPN / TNN coverage where they “called” the race.

It’s more like watching a race with Kyle Petty than Kyle Petty calling a race.

I prefer to listen to MRN and mute the TV.