The Frontstretch: Finally ... We Are In Store For An Excellent Chase by Garrett Horton -- Tuesday September 21, 2010

Go to site navigation Go to article

Finally ... We Are In Store For An Excellent Chase

Garrett Horton · Tuesday September 21, 2010


When Brian France introduced the Chase for the 2004 season, it was meant to create more excitement in NASCAR. Well, excluding its inaugural year, it is safe to say the playoff format has been nothing but a major bust. Besides the fact that Jimmie Johnson has run away with the last four championships, it has also changed the way each driver has competed going into the final ten races. For the Chase drivers, it is too risky to be making aggressive moves, and conservative racing has become the norm. For guys on the outside looking in, they also have to become aware of whom they are racing against; no driver outside the Chase wants to dictate the outcome of the championship. This approach has disgruntled many fans who decide to switch over to the NFL this time of year, a long line of disgruntled departures whose numbers have continually increased.

But is this the year the mass exodus comes to an end? If this past Sunday’s race is any sign, we should be in for the Chase that France envisioned all those years ago.

Hey! The Chasers certainly look like they’re having fun… and so did race fans with the running of the Sylvania 300.

Despite the fact that the Chase does seem more wide open in 2010 – that could just be ESPN brainwashing us – many fans were simply apathetic heading into Loudon. However, as soon as the green flag waved at New Hampshire, something interesting happened; both Chase and non-Chase drivers were racing, and racing hard. Just laps in, we witnessed championship favorites Denny Hamlin and Jimmie Johnson run three-wide for several laps. We even watched Hamlin nudge Johnson out of the way, which for a second looked as if the four-time champ might end up in the wall. Like most races, things cooled off for the middle portion of the event until a caution came out for Mark Martin’s blown tire on lap 208. It was at this point that the Chasers again got aggressive.

Over the next 50 laps, Denny Hamlin, Carl Edwards, Kurt Busch, Kyle Busch, Jimmie Johnson, and Matt Kenseth all were involved in accidents. Three others: Jeff Burton, Clint Bowyer, and Tony Stewart gambled on fuel, choosing to run the final 92 laps on one tank of gas. Add all this up and we got a very exciting show, along with a first round that left us all ready for race number two at Dover.

The two burned most by this chaotic mess were Stewart, who ended up running out of gas, and Johnson. Stewart went from 1st to 24th in a matter of one lap, losing 94 valuable points in the process. No driver has been hotter over the past three months than Stewart, so it will certainly be interesting to see if he can make his way back up into contention. As for Johnson, any time he has a bad finish in the Chase, it always makes the next week intriguing. In three of Johnson’s four championships, he has finished inside the top 10 with the first Chase race. The only time he didn’t was back in 2006, when a crash relegated him to a 39th-place finish. Johnson was able to come back to win that year with the help of five consecutive top-2 performances – something that seems unlikely to happen in today’s NASCAR, with more elements such as double-file restarts and multiple green-white-checkered finishes in play.

Even the guys who aren’t gunning for the championship ran their own race. Pole sitter Brad Keselowski didn’t change his driving style at all, even taking out Chaser Matt Kenseth on lap 235. Perhaps most impressive was Jamie McMurray, who continued his Cinderella season with a third-place finish. McMurray, who ran with the Chasers almost the entire event, had some exciting battles with Bowyer and Stewart for the lead. He didn’t wreck either guy, but he raced them hard and was certainly not making it easy for both just because they were championship contenders.

As a matter of fact, McMurray admitted that he and other non-Chasers can actually turn up the heat this time of year. “Yeah, honestly you probably can be more aggressive around the Chase guys,” he claimed Sunday, “Because they are thinking differently than what the guys are that are not in the Chase.”

McMurray also went on to say that who he is racing against doesn’t really come to mind until the final few races. “There’s a ton of racing left,” he continued. “There’s only [nine] left, but a lot can happen, even in two or three races. So really, until it gets down until the last couple of races, I don’t pay a tremendous amount of attention to that.”

And I would be completely remiss not to mention the fine run for fan favorite Dale Earnhardt, Jr. The success of NASCAR arguably depends on how Junior runs. With his first non-restrictor plate top 5 in over a year, Earnhardt gave Junior Nation reason for optimism heading forward. While not in the Chase, if Earnhardt can manage some more top-5 finishes like he did at Loudon, it will encourage many back to their television sets on Sunday afternoons.

So Chase Race #1 proved that drivers are willing to take risks under this playoff format after all. We saw fuel strategy, last-lap drama, a long green-flag run, and the championship favorite all have a setback. It satisfied the needs of all NASCAR fans as it had a little bit of everything for everyone. For the next nine races, we will find out if Denny Hamlin can continue to get the consistent finishes that have plagued him most of this season. For the regular season champion Kevin Harvick, we will see whether top-10 finishes will be enough for his first Sprint Cup title. Carl Edwards and Jeff Gordon, neither of whom have a win, are looking to become winless champions which would really create some controversy. Of course, we can’t forget about Johnson. Will he and the No. 48 team be able to get out of this small hole they have dug already? If he makes it five in a row this year, he is going to have to do it in come-from-behind fashion.

Don’t expect every race in the final months to have what we saw at Loudon, but considering what we did see in the first Chase race, know that we are going to see 12 drivers do everything they possibly can do to win the championship. One race in already tells me this may be the best Chase we have seen since 2004.

Tuesday on the Frontstretch:
Five Points to Ponder: Labonte Parks Again, Hornish vs. Allgaier, And Bowyer’s Meaningless Win
Who’s Hot / Who’s Not In NASCAR: New Hampshire – Dover Edition
Gambling Now or Later? Chase Strategy Ignites in Empty Fuel Tanks
Talking NASCAR TV: The Script Hurts ESPN at Loudon

Contact Garrett Horton

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Garrett Horton and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

Bill B
09/21/2010 08:41 AM

This being “an excellent chase” is certainly possible, but given the fact that there are still 9 races left and looking at the previous chases and how they actually went down by Homestead, how much of your own money would you be willing to bet that this year will have at least 3 guys within 50 points of the lead by Homestead?

The best Jerry, the best.

Carl D.
09/21/2010 09:41 AM

The best chase ever will be the last one.

Bill B
09/21/2010 10:33 AM

Amen Carl!!!!!!!!!!!!

I won’t be happy until all these chase years have asterisks by them in the history books.

09/21/2010 10:50 AM

Another import from

09/21/2010 10:56 AM

It’ll come down to two drivers “battling” for the chumpionship for the last race. AGAIN. Just like each point system. The last race might decide it but I doubt it. Please let a driver with no wins win it.

09/21/2010 11:15 AM

It could be a excellent chase if anyone was actually interested the chase.

Michael in SoCal
09/21/2010 11:51 AM

I personally like the Chase. I think Nascar came up with a way to have a championship battle between the top 10 – 12 drivers, while still having the other 31 drivers still on the track.

That said, I think there are some flaws to the Chase. The tracks need to be switched up, and maybe the Chase drivers should have their own points system.

I understand why some people don’t like how someone 300, 400, 500 points back after Richmond is now in the running for the championship, but any playoff system sets all the contenders level-set at the beginning. The bonus points for wins gives potential contenders a reason to go for the win.

I know I’m in the minority here, but to me, the Chase adds some excitement to the Cup series.

I also know that a Chase isn’t always necessary for that excitement – see Ron Hornaday & Johnny Benson in the Truck Series in 2008. But personally, I think the Chase works pretty well as a Championship format.

09/21/2010 12:14 PM

Drop the chase,Let them ALL run for the Championship.

Stephen HOOD
09/21/2010 02:51 PM

Drop the Chase and only give drivers points for those finishing 1-10. No extra points for lap leading or most laps led. Continue using the owner points for top 35. This would tighten things up, allow a few mulligans, and people would be racing their butts off to be in the top 10. No more “good points” days on the driver side of the aisle.

Kevin in SoCal
09/21/2010 04:09 PM

I see you finally found someone to write something good about the Chase for Welcome Garret, and I hope Tom provided you with a firesuit for all the flaming comments and emails you’ll get. :)

Don Mei
09/21/2010 04:43 PM

“Excellent chase” is an oxymoron.

09/21/2010 05:18 PM

So the race was exciting. Think how exciting it could have been without The Chase hanging over every driver’s head.

Kevin in SoCal
09/21/2010 05:39 PM

Without the Chase, we could just engrave Kevin Harvick’s name on the trophy and everyone can go home now. How exciting would that be?

09/22/2010 11:10 AM

Kevin, sometimes there are seasons where a driver will dominate and win the championship by 200-300 points. Real fans would find nothing wrong with that. Kevin Harvick has been consistent throughout the season and has EARNED the right to have such a big lead and to have it taken away from him without any award or money bonus is not right. Might as well spin the wheel on wheel of fortune to determine the champion these days.

09/23/2010 11:54 AM

I don’t like the CHASE and never have. For over 50 years we didn’t need it and we don’t now.