The Frontstretch: Toyota Has Been the Victim of Ford's Revival by Garrett Horton -- Friday April 15, 2011

Go to site navigation Go to article

Toyota Has Been the Victim of Ford's Revival

Going Green · Garrett Horton · Friday April 15, 2011


It’s safe to say that Ford Racing is back. Trevor Bayne, Carl Edwards, and most recently Matt Kenseth, each have made a trip to victory lane just seven races into the year. That is three times that Ford has won already, which, believe it or not, is just one victory short of their entire total from last year. Whether a fan of the Blue Oval or not, it is a feel good story to see one of NASCAR’s longtime manufacturers back in contention.

As is usually the case when a driver, or team in this instance, rebounds from tough times, it is at another driver or team’s expense. It is odd saying this now because they were a joke their first year in the Sprint Cup Series, but Toyota has been hurt most by Ford’s resurgence. Sure, Toyota driver Kyle Busch has looked impressive so far and has already won at Bristol. In fact, if you are a firm believer in the laps led category, such as me, Busch has been the most competitive driver this year with 481 circuits led. That, however, has been Toyota’s only bright spot for 2011.

Teammates Denny Hamlin and Joey Logano have been the biggest disappointments out of the Toyota camp. Hamlin, who came so close to winning the title last year after claiming eight wins, is still looking for his first top 5 result. Engines woes and untimely accidents have been a major factor, but it is also obvious at this point he is not running where he should be.

Yes, he got off to a slow start last year as well, but there was potential in 2010 that has not been seen so far this season. Texas and Martinsville, both tracks Hamlin swept last year, were two of his better runs so far, but poor fuel mileage at Martinsville cost him a top 10 and their Texas run demonstrated the No. 11 team is behind the competition.

Joey Logano has had a quiet, unspectacular start to the 2011 season, and is already a longshot at best in terms of Chase contention.

While Hamlin is off to a rough start, it’s been worse for Logano, who has yet to finish in the top 10. Like Hamlin, the 2009 Rookie of the Year has had some tough luck so far, but when he has avoided trouble, Logano hasn’t been competitive. His 13th place finish at Martinsville was his only top 20 of the year. Logano has certainly struggled since becoming a Cup driver, but he looked to have turned things around late last year with five consecutive top 7 finishes. In 2011, all progress has been halted. Sliced Bread sits 27th in the standings and with the way things have been going, any chance at the Chase will have to wait until next year.

Toyota’s problems haven’t been limited to Joe Gibbs Racing either. Red Bull Racing has dealt with its share of mechanical problems and inconsistent runs as well, even though on the surface it looks like RBR has actually improved over last year. When you factor in that Brian Vickers and Kasey Kahne accounted for most of the team’s top 10s in limited races the previous year, however, it is evident their struggles in 2010 were from a driver standpoint. They have shown flashes of potential this year, but nothing consistent enough to be a Chase threat – something both drivers were just two seasons ago (for Vickers, it was in the Red Bull Toyota).

Red Bull still has work to do, and Texas proved it. Both Kahne and Vickers were not even close to being competitive, which is a real concern considering this is the type of track this team used to excel at. The mile and a half tracks are the most common ones the circuit, and if they struggle there, it will be a long season. Between JGR and RBR, Toyota is clearly off the pace.

Yet, it doesn’t end there. Toyota’s startup team, Michael Waltrip Racing, has been the worst of all. The driver who they call the Franchise, David Reutimann, has had anything but a franchise type of year. Last season he got off to a bad start, but he was at least having solid runs before circumstances beyond his control eliminated him from good finishes. So far in 2011 he hasn’t even sniffed the front of the pack. Unlike some of the other Toyota drivers, Reutimann can’t use bad luck as an excuse for some of his finishes – he and the No. 00 team have simply been a middle of the pack group so far.

It’s an unfortunate time for this to happen as he really came on strong the second half of last year – including a victory at Chicago – and looked poised to be a Chase contender for 2011. Teammate Martin Truex Jr. has actually been very strong this year – in the first half of races. For whatever reason, this team has faded big time in the second portion of several events, most notably Bristol and Fontana. Neither of the MWR drivers are off to the start they want, and it doesn’t look like things will improve any time soon either.

Ford is back to the front, and Toyota is back to the rear. Obviously, that may be a bit harsh for the Japanese manufacturer considering Busch’s early season strength. But for other drivers such as Hamlin, Logano, and Reutimann, who were all at their strongest at the end of last year, to be struggling the way they are is definitely a cause for concern for the Toyotas.

Then again, in a way, it might be taken as a good sign. After their first year in 2007, which produced hardly anything, a season like this would be considered pretty good. With the huge leaps they made from 2008-2010 – from JGR switching over from Chevy, to the gains MWR and RBR had made, Toyota had high hopes to be the top manufacturer this season. Unfortunately for them, the Ford renaissance led by Carl Edwards is going to make it much more difficult, as Toyota currently sits third in the manufacturer standings (which might as well be last considering Dodge has only three cars running every race). It’s still early in the year, but Toyota looks to have taken a step back, not forward, much to Ford’s delight.

Contact Garrett Horton

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Beyond the Cockpit: Alexis DeJoria On The 300 mph Women of the NHRA
A Swan’s Broken Wings Equal NASCAR’s Next Concern?
Thinkin’ Out Loud – The Off Week Season Review
Pace Laps: Swan Racing’s Future, Fast Females and Dropping Out
Sprint Cup Series Facilities Can Build Upon Fan Experience by Looking to Their Roots


©2000 - 2008 Garrett Horton and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

04/15/2011 01:45 AM


zhills fan
04/15/2011 06:22 AM

MWR has really disapointed me, especially DR. I am beginning to question his desire to win, seems like anymore all he is, is a stroker.

04/15/2011 09:05 AM

Load that Jap junk up and send them all to the “homeland”!!…..

pat g
04/15/2011 09:56 AM

Reuti in three out of seven races involved in circumstances beyond control……(not sure about how texas pit road incident occurred, if DR’s fault or not) could be very different. He has been running well in a lot of races until those crashes.
Of course “what if” is impossible to predict.

The Mad Man
04/15/2011 10:39 AM

And the problem with Toyota’s decline is?

Every manufacturer goes through highs and lows. Ford put a lot of money and R&D time into the FR-9. TRD and Triad haven’t. It’s as simple as that. Unless Toyota and their engine manufacturers sink some money into their R&D program or pilfer parts from the other brands and incorporate that technology into their engine design, they’ll continue to run where they are.

04/15/2011 12:17 PM

Susan’s comment about not caring about what brand of car her favorite driver is driving is indicative of what’s wrong with NASCAR today. THE SPORT IS SUPPOSED TO BE ABOUT AUTOMOBILE RACING. Susan, how in the world can you diminish the importance of the type of cars raced and call yourself a “FAN” of NASCAR?
Indy and F1 are good examples of how that is NOT the thing to do. Too much celebrity and not enough substance.

04/15/2011 01:08 PM

I find it pretty easy to see where Susan is coming from. I myself am a Chevy fan. As such, I do find it difficult to cheer for drivers that do not drive Chevy’s. That being said, I am a fan of GM because my Dad drives GM products as does my Grandfather, in most cases brand loyalty is passed down generation to generation. Today, often times & especially as the economy dictates, when purchasing a vehicle people choose the best deal that fills their needs. Brand doesn’t matter as much anymore as the quality between makers is pretty much the same. Add that to the generic cars that are out on the track with very little differentiation & brand loyalty becomes a declining factor. In addition, the only thing Chevy, Ford, Dodge or Toyota in these cars for most teams is the engine block itself. The larger teams i.e. Roush, RCR, Hendrick, Gibbs & Penske have their own engine development programs where they build their own stuff & get ‘support’ from their respective manufactures.
I wish that it were not the case, however, I do find it easy to see why Susan has the viewpoint she does. Personally I can’t wait to see what rolls out on the track in 2013. Hopefully the manufacturer’s can inspire the dreams of future fans & eventually their children & bring brand loyalty back to the sport.

04/15/2011 01:08 PM

As long as Toyota is a victim of anything, it’s fine by me.

04/15/2011 05:47 PM

I will go along with Susan, Earnhardt should drive a car from Lybia and move there to drive it. Also take the Waltrip brothers with him. NASCAR would be much better…

04/15/2011 08:30 PM

Dale Jr. could drive a car from Lybia, and STILL be on a 100+ race Losing streak! And Jr.Nation Hypocrites would use the car from Lybia as Dale Jr.‘s latest Excuse.

04/15/2011 08:33 PM

I have always been a Chevy man and a DALE Sr. and RCR fan. While today I’m still a Chevy man and RCR fan. It just so happens that I’m also a Rowdy fan in anything he drives.