When The Big BF (Brian France) announced at the beginning of the 2004 season that a new points system would be instituted to determine NASCAR’s Champion, many folks, myself included, were quite skeptical. After riding (quite painfully) on the fence of indecision for most of the year, I finally fell off on the side of reluctant approval. After all, The Chase, as it was dubbed, did make the end of a long and tedious season a bit more exciting. The ‘04 victor wasn’t finally decided until the waning laps of the final race.
We are now nearing the end of the Chase for the second year and it still has some very vociferous opponents that say that is just a stunt to elevate television ratings and does not reflect a true champion’s racing efforts.
While I don’t deny that it was made for (and has) improved late season ratings, I still say that it is really not that far off from the old system. All the new chase has done is shorten the ‘true’ season by ten races. YOU STILL HAVE TO HAVE A GOOD SEASON TO BE IN THE TENTH SPOT! With the chase, you now have ten guys who have a legitimate shot at the championship instead of one guy wrapping it up with a bunch of races remaining.
However, as Samuel Clemens (aka Mark Twain) so eloquently put it, “There are three kinds of lies. Lies, damned lies and statistics!” The Chase is no different. Forget, if you will for a moment, about the Chase and about points and look at the pure racing stats of the top ten and a few selected other drivers.
1. Stewart – 33 starts, 9757 of 9824 laps completed (99.3%), 1830 laps led
Win: 5 ( 15.2%) Average start: 11.7 Total Winnings: $6,347,436 Top 5: 16 ( 48.5%) Average finish: 10.1 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 23 ( 69.7%) DNF: 12. Johnson – 33 starts, 9356 of 9824 laps completed (95.2%), 545 laps led
Win: 4 ( 12.1%) Average start: 12.0 Total Winnings: $6,002,480 Top 5: 12 ( 36.4%) Average finish: 12.3 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 20 ( 60.6%) DNF: 43. Biffle – 33 starts, 9608 of 9824 laps completed (97.8%), 1112 laps led
Win: 5 ( 15.2%) Average start: 13.9 Total Winnings: $4,970,808 Top 5: 13 ( 39.4%) Average finish: 12.3 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 19 ( 57.6%) DNF: 14. Newman – 33 starts, 9484 of 9824 laps completed (96.5%), 358 laps led
Win: 1 ( 3.0%) Average start: 6.4 Total Winnings: $4,801,805 Top 5: 8 ( 24.2%) Average finish: 15.4 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 15 ( 45.5%) DNF: 35. Edwards – 33 starts, 9445 of 9824 laps completed (96.1%), 258 laps led
Win: 3 ( 9.1%) Average start: 19.6 Total Winnings: $4,085,843 Top 5: 11 ( 33.3%) Average finish: 14.9 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 15 ( 45.5%) DNF: 16. Martin – 33 starts, 9393 of 9824 laps completed (95.6%), 280 laps led
Win: 1 ( 3.0%) Average start: 15.7 Total Winnings: $4,169,308 Top 5: 10 ( 30.3%) Average finish: 13.9 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 17 ( 51.5%) DNF: 27. Kenseth – 33 starts, 9272 of 9824 laps completed (94.4%), 852 laps led
Win: 1 ( 3.0%) Average start: 17.5 Total Winnings: $5,051,355 Top 5: 10 ( 30.3%) Average finish: 15.6 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 15 ( 45.5%) DNF: 48. Wallace – 33 starts, 9692 of 9824 laps completed (98.7%), 259 laps led
Win: 0 ( 0.0%) Average start: 18.3 Total Winnings: $4,326,224 Top 5: 8 ( 24.2%) Average finish: 13.1 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 17 ( 51.5%) DNF: 09. Busch – 33 starts, 9027 of 9824 laps completed (91.9%), 957 laps led
Win: 3 ( 9.1%) Average start: 13.5 Total Winnings: $6,157,915 Top 5: 9 ( 27.3%) Average finish: 15.5 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 17 ( 51.5%) DNF: 310. Mayfield – 33 starts, 9676 of 9824 laps completed (98.5%), 151 laps led
Win: 1 ( 3.0%) Average start: 14.9 Total Winnings: $4,110,313 Top 5: 4 ( 12.1%) Average finish: 15.2 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 8 ( 24.2%) DNF: 1Random
11. McMurray – 33 starts, 9494 of 9824 laps completed (96.6%), 39 laps led
Win: 0 ( 0.0%) Average start: 21.1 Total Winnings: $3,601,893 Top 5: 4 ( 12.1%) Average finish: 16.8 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 10 ( 30.3%) DNF: 412. Gordon – 33 starts, 8735 of 9824 laps completed (88.9%), 520 laps led
Win: 4 ( 12.1%) Average start: 11.8 Total Winnings: $6,194,451 Top 5: 7 ( 21.2%) Average finish: 18.6 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 12 ( 36.4%) DNF: 917. Jarrett – 33 starts, 9677 of 9824 laps completed (98.5%), 4 laps led
Win: 1 ( 3.0%) Average start: 20.5 Total Winnings: $4,189,084 Top 5: 4 ( 12.1%) Average finish: 18.8 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 6 ( 18.2%) DNF: 219. Earnhardt Jr – 33 starts, 8896 of 9824 laps completed (90.6%), 169 laps led
Win: 1 ( 3.0%) Average start: 25.1 Total Winnings: $5,190,530 Top 5: 7 ( 21.2%) Average finish: 20.4 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 12 ( 36.4%) DNF: 522. Kasey Kahne – 33 starts, 8793 of 9824 laps completed (89.5%), 430 laps led
Win: 1 ( 3.0%) Average start: 14.9 Total Winnings: $4,307,933 Top 5: 5 ( 15.2%) Average finish: 21.3 (excluding bonuses) Top 10: 8 ( 24.2%) DNF: 8From a statistical point of view, the biggest aberration in this year’s Chase is Jimmy Johnson. Johnson should not be in second place! He should be, at the very least, 3rd. But hey, were talking statistics here! Johnson has the 2nd to lowest percentage of completed laps of any chaser and is tied with Kenseth for the most (4) DNFs. Johnson’s only saving grace is, apparently, his 4 wins. But how does that explain why he is ahead of Biffle? I will tell you in a moment.
When I first glanced at these stats, I also thought that Jeremy Mayfield should not be in the Chase at all, and that either Jeff Gordon or Jamie McMurray should be 10th. However, upon further review, the reason he is became clear.
While Gordon has by far more wins, he also has a glaringly high 9 on the DNF scale. McMurray on the other hand, missed out because of not having a win at all and 3 more DNFs than Mayfield. Jeremy squeaked in the Chase for one reason and one reason only…he recorded his single win in race 23 of the 26 race cutoff.
Now is the moment I will explain why Johnson is ahead of Biffle and the most obvious problem with the Chase format. The Chase unfairly benefits those whose wins come late in the year. Without doing the math on the points as if there were no Chase, (I’m sure some stat guru will let me know for sure…) I believe Jimmie would be at least 3rd, if not 4th, in the standings.
My final analysis is that, other than Johnson being the one aberration, statistically, the Chase is pretty darn close to reality. But then there is that old saying…”Anyone can prove anything with statistics!”
(Statistics are from www.racing-reference.com. A terrific site for those who are number nuts!)
Stay off the wall,
Jeff
Thursday on the Frontstretch:
MPM2Nite: NASCAR’s Summer of Discontent
The Twitter NASCAR Revolution – A Trivial Pursuit?
Truckin’ Thursdays: A Look Back at Five Different Victors
Potts’ Shots: New Car Nuances And Goodbye To An Old Friend
Dollars And Sense: NASCAR Dumps Jump Co. As Ad Agency
FREE NEWSLETTER! CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP
LOOKING FOR THE INFO YOU NEED ABOUT NASCAR THIS SEASON – SENT RIGHT TO YOUR EMAIL INBOX?
Well, you’ve come to the right place. The Frontstretch Newsletter is back in action for 2012, giving you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up and get all the information you need. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!
©2000 - 2008 Jeff Meyer and Frontstetch.com. Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!



























