The Frontstretch: Voices From the Heartland: Finally, NASCAR being sued for violating 12-4-A by Jeff Meyer -- Wednesday December 7, 2005

Go to site navigation Go to article

Originally published July 14, 2005 

If you are reading this far, chances are you already know what 12-4-A is. For those of you who are brand-spanking new fans, or those who have simply stumbled onto this page by doing a web search for 'amazing columnists', I will explain exactly what 12-4-A is.

12-4-A is a much used, and apparently abused, rule in the NASCAR rulebook. More specifically, 12-4-A penalizes those  for "actions detrimental to stock car racing". This rule is a real money maker for NASCAR, as probably not a race has been completed in the last 15 years without someone being found in violation of it! It is a very broad rule which can be violated in such ways as cussing in an interview, having a wrong part on your car (which is also a 12-4-Q), trying to run down officials, flipping someone the bird, and quite possibly by breaking wind during the driver's meeting.

On Wednesday, July 13th, lawyers representing Kentucky Speedway, LLC filed suit against NASCAR and International Speedway Corporation (ISC) alleging "...these defendants have violated federal antitrust laws in that they have illegally restricted the award of NASCAR NEXTEL Cup Series races, and have illegally awarded NASCAR NEXTEL Cup Series races to the International Speedway Corporation." Both NASCAR and ISC are controlled by the France family.

“We have alleged that NASCAR and ISC have violated the federal antitrust laws,” said Stan Chesley, a Cincinnati lawyer representing the speedway. “In my opinion, the facts clearly support a conclusion that NASCAR and ISC have colluded to exclude competition in order to financially benefit themselves. By doing so, they have harmed not only Kentucky Speedway but also all stock car racing fans nationwide. Stock car racing is the most popular spectator sport in the United States and we intend to do our best to see that fair play and fair racing is re-established.”

AMEN BROTHER! It's about time, is what I say.

On the surface, one would assume that officials at Kentucky Speedway must have a compelling argument to have filed the suit in the first place. They already host NASCAR Busch and Craftsman Truck Series races there, and there had to be some concern about losing those, should they miserably fail in this impending court battle. I have said all along that NASCAR and ISC sure appear to be a monopoly, and now we will finally get to hear if the court upholds my theory.

The speedway itself, located in Sparta, KY, does a heck of a lot better at explaining their main (ahem) complaint than I ever could, on their official website. ( Once there, you will notice that they expect alot of questions since they already have a webpage dedicated solely to questions about the lawsuit, which is barely a day old. I urge you to visit it. (

Time will only tell how this all works out. At the very least it will spend an awful lot of someone else's money! In the mean time, I suggest you...

Stay off the wall (but you might want to duck behind it if the fur really starts flying!)


Postscript: As of December, the case is still pending, expected to reach court sometime in 2006.

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
NASCAR Easter Eggs: A Few Off-Week Nuggets to Chew On
Five Points To Ponder: NASCAR’s Take-A-Breath Moment
Truckin’ Thursdays: Top Five All-Time Truck Series Drivers
Going By the Numbers: A Week Without Racing Can Bring Relief But Kill Momentum


©2000 - 2008 Jeff Meyer and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

12/08/2005 02:15 AM

What are the chances of Kentucky winning this lawsuit?

Ever hear of the proverbial snowballs chance in hell?

Don’t take my word for it.

According the the lawyer that represented Texas Motor Speedway in their failed suit over alleged anti-trust violations they have less of a chance than that snowball.

In fact when asked to join the legal team he declined and in so many words told Kentucky they were barking up the wrong judges bench.


Contact Jeff Meyer

Recent articles from Jeff Meyer:

Voices From The Cheap Seats: The Tale Of Two Tires
BSNews! Bruton’s Plans Extend Beyond Bristol’s Track
Top Ten Reasons Fans Failed To Show Up At Bristol Sunday
BSNews! NASCAR CEO Given "Special" Award Amidst Lavish Fanfare
Fan Coun-ci-What? Just What Is It That NASCAR Wants To Study?

Want to know more about Jeff Meyer or view his complete article archives? Then hop on over to his archive and bio page.