The Frontstretch: NASCAR's "Stupidity" Over Middle Finger Is Actually The Right Call by Jeff Meyer -- Thursday November 11, 2010

Go to site navigation Go to article

NASCAR's "Stupidity" Over Middle Finger Is Actually The Right Call

Voices From the Heartland · Jeff Meyer · Thursday November 11, 2010


I have a beloved colleague here at by the name of Mike Neff. You may have heard of him before. He does a lot of great writing for us, and he is almost as popular as me. Mike and I usually agree on most things, right down to political candidates – let alone anything to do with racing – so imagine my surprise over his latest article calling the recently announced fine of Kyle Busch’s unauthorized flight pattern of his middle finger “a new level of stupidity” by NASCAR.

So surprised was I, that my rebuttal to his argument is forced to begin with no less than a variant of the old SNL classic; Mike, you ignorant slut! (Mike knows of course that I say that in good fun. He is anything but ignorant!)

You should, but in case you have no idea what either of us is talking about, here is the rundown. Roughly midway through the race, Kyle Busch got spun. Caution flew and, since the only thing hurt was Kyle’s pride and his Goodyears, Kyle headed for the pits to get new ones. In his effort to stay on the lead lap, Kyle was busted for speeding as he was coming out of the pits. Informed that he must serve a one lap penalty, Kyle obediently conformed to NASCAR’s request and politely parked his No. 18 Toyota in his pit as an official stood in front of it.

During his tenure at the front of the young Busch’s car, the official was greeted by Busch in the form of the universally known, one finger salute which ultimately landed Busch a further penalty of two laps due to “unsportsmanlike conduct”. Unfortunately for Kyle, television producers had also picked that exact moment to get some great ‘in car cam’ footage. That, folks, is where the controversy begins.

Mr. Neff (and his cited source of ex-Frontstretcher, Dennis Michelsen’s racetalkradio Facebook page) contends that the only reason that Busch was penalized and fined is solely because his salute was captured on national television. Both Neff and Michelsen say that this sort of thing happens all the time. Why, it is a natural occurrence to see one finger salutes flying all over the place at any given race, NASCAR or otherwise, all over the country. Most of which, by their own statements, they cite as being executed by and directed amongst the competitors themselves. That fact I do not deny. Been there, seen that.

NASCAR has been accused of making a lot of poor decisions in the past, but its penalty for the “finger heard ‘round the world” was the right one.

But lets look at all this in another light, one which NASCAR itself is so desperately trying to bask in; compared to stick and ball sports!

Anyone who has watched some of the great films from the NFL archives knows, there is a lot of bleeping going on down in the trenches. Tons of it! Same goes for hockey and most other sports. Now I will be the first to admit, watching other sports, it is rare that you see one guy flip another off and the reason for this is simple logistics.

When you are at the bottom of a pile of men, or face to face with them, it is much easier (and more effective) to simply say…FU you MFnCSnSOB! I mean, why bother raising a finger when you can say it to the guy’s face AND with the desired amount of voice inflection! Especially in hockey. Have you ever tried flipping someone off while wearing hockey gloves?!

In racing, you don’t have that luxury of face to face confrontation. In order for a driver to get his point across, the one fingered salute is about the only option. The point is this; to a point, the officials will let the players be rude amongst themselves. It is the nature of the beast. However, there are exceptions. Catch a winning pass in the end zone and then turn to your defender and flip him off…yeah, that’s probably gonna get you 15 yards (assessed on the kickoff) for “taunting”. Stand in the race track and throw your helmet or your booties at another competitor’s car….you’ll probably get a fine or penalty for “actions detrimental…” There are, and always have been limits and one of the limits that you absolutely DO NOT CROSS is covered next!

Anyone who has played in any sport and has any type of proper upbringing at all knows…YOU DO NOT flip off, curse at, spit on, kick dirt at or otherwise call into question the family lineage of, an OFFICIAL!!! How much of that argument don’t you understand? And y’all think I’m the hayseed from Iowa!

Ok, let’s tackle the “they only enforced it because it was on TV argument….

To quote Mr. Michelsen from his Facebook page, (sorry Dennis, but thank Mike for dragging you into this!) “I am not comfortable with NASCAR using television replays to make the call. The Television Director is NOT a NASCAR official but he determines what they hear and could protect certain drivers and search for infractions by others.” And this one… “…they didn’t make the call until television pointed it out. How can I say that with confidence? If the call came because the official saw it they wouldn’t have let him go back on the track and called him back.”

First of all, as you can see from the original television broadcast, thanks to this wonderful YouTube post by skinley218 the in car footage of Kyle Busch starts well before he even starts to raise his finger at around 1:48 into the video. That being a fact, how is it the “television director” is going to determine what the fans (or NASCAR) see or hear? Did he somehow know Kyle was gonna fly the bird in advance? Keep watching the video…

The in-car footage of “the finger” lasts from 1:48 to 1:53 before the “director” cuts away. Ok, maybe in those five seconds, those that make such decisions were busy checking their rum and cokes for floaters and missed it. What you cannot miss is the announcers immediately apologizing on national television for Busch’s gestures! What kind of replay do you need? Do you honestly think anyone from the network had to point out to the officials what millions of people just saw live? I bet it went something like this…

(Ring, Ring!)


“Uh….excuse me, Mr. France?”


“Uhhh…this is Bob down here in the production trailer. After going over our tapes, we uh…we saw Kyle Busch flipping off one of the officials. Just thought you’d like to know.”

“Thanks you, Boob! We be getting on it!”

I ask you. What was NASCAR supposed to do? Busch essentially forced their hand by his immature (by his own admission) actions! NASCAR, for once actually did the right thing. They did what any ref, ump, or official in any stick and ball sport would have done, which is essentially eject him from the game, by holding him for two laps!

As for the fine to come afterward, well there is plenty of previous precedent to justify that too. Remember Shane Hmiel flipping off Dale Jarrett a few years ago at Bristol? NASCAR fined Shane Hmiel $10,000 and docked him 25 driver points for making an obscene gesture that appeared on live television via Hmiel’s in car camera. “I apologize for making the gesture,” Hmiel said. “I never intended for it to end up on television.” And that was during a (then) Busch Series race! And then the infamous fine of 25k of Dale Jr. for bad language during a post race interview. I’m sure a guy could go on and on if a guy (me) had a better memory or felt like doing more research, but I don’t to either!

The point is simple; Kyle Busch, not surprisingly, did the wrong thing. NASCAR, surprisingly, got it right! What is this world coming to?

I salute you, Mr Neff, with a finger. You guess which one! (wink, wink)

Stay off the wall, (and off the in car cam!)

Jeff Meyer

Contact Jeff Meyer

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Jeff Meyer and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

Stephen HOOD
11/11/2010 07:14 AM

I agree with you. Since grade school the officials have been off limits. Kyle released a contrite apology so even the folks at JGR realized he had gone over the line.

11/11/2010 07:36 AM

I don’t dispute that flipping off an official should garner a penalty, but what is $25,000 to Kyle Busch? It is equivalent to you or I being arrested for smoking in a public building (the horror of it all) and then being fined all the lint in our pockets.

11/11/2010 10:38 AM

I remember that Shane Hmiel – Dale Jarrett incident. Shane’s gesture was nothing worse than what Kyle Busch did, so why did he lose 25 points, yet Kyle Busch doesn’t lose points. Oh that’s right, NASCAR and consistency have never mixed.

Don Mei
11/11/2010 12:38 PM

Isn’t flipping the bird being considered for possible inclusion in the olympics? I mean what the hell. I mean heck, sorry!….this is America in the 21st century! Why look for civilized behavior in NASCAR? It doesn’t exist anywhere else.

11/11/2010 12:49 PM

Apparently you are a hayseed from Iowa, get with the times,the penalty was asinine.Just as asinine as these smoking laws,
If any of these drivers had any real balls they would go kick Brainfart right in the nuts.
And a big one finger salute to you.

11/11/2010 10:26 PM

Brooks is correct when he says NA$CAR & consistency have never mixed. Do you all remember a recent truck race when KB flipped the bird I believe at Todd Bodine? The action, although shown on TV resulted in no action against KB. So no wonder he thought he could get away with it again. I know, one was at a fellow driver & the other was at an ‘official’. But they were both viewed by thousands on TV. (I would say millions but in view of the decline in NA$CAR viewers, I wouldn’t want to be accused of providing incorrect information).

11/12/2010 09:35 AM

I still think there was more to it than just the 1 finger salute. After his tirade about Nascar the day before, using explicatives on radio and post race interviews, my feeling is Nascar said enough is enough.


Contact Jeff Meyer

Recent articles from Jeff Meyer:

Voices From The Cheap Seats: The Tale Of Two Tires
BSNews! Bruton’s Plans Extend Beyond Bristol’s Track
Top Ten Reasons Fans Failed To Show Up At Bristol Sunday
BSNews! NASCAR CEO Given "Special" Award Amidst Lavish Fanfare
Fan Coun-ci-What? Just What Is It That NASCAR Wants To Study?

Want to know more about Jeff Meyer or view his complete article archives? Then hop on over to his archive and bio page.