The Frontstretch: Oh, Canada : To Sing or Not to Sing? by Jeff Meyer -- Wednesday June 21, 2006

Go to site navigation Go to article

Oh, Canada : To Sing or Not to Sing?

Voices From the Heartland · Jeff Meyer · Wednesday June 21, 2006

 

Last Sunday, as I sat on my couch waiting for the race to begin, I did as instructed by the track announcer and removed my hat for the singing of…The National Anthem of Canada!?

Now, I must point out, for those of you that don't already know, my couch, at this point in my life, is located in East Central Iowa. I have watched many a race from my Iowa couch and even more from a barstool located just six blocks east of my couch, but this was the first time I'd ever been asked to stand and remove my cap for the singing of another country's national anthem. I was a bit stunned, to say the least…in fact, I put my hat back on.

Even my wife, who is NOT a NASCAR fan but loves me anyway, noticed my state of bewilderment and feigned her interest with the question: "Where is this race at?"

"Michigan. Near where your brother used to live," I replied.

"Why are they singing the Canadian National Anthem?" She continued feigning interest, probably because it was Father's Day. "Beats the Halifax outta me," I quite cleverly quipped in response.

Sensing she was at her limit of feigned interest of anything NASCAR, my wife became distracted by a piece of dust, and our conversation ended. I, however, was not ready to let it die.

After dutifully standing and removing my hat for OUR national anthem, I went straight to my computer and posted my opinion of disbelief on the Frontstretch.com message board to see if anyone else thought the same as I did. (If you are not a member of our message board, I encourage you to join as we have some very engaging and insightful conversations way more in depth than what you see in the “comments” section at the bottom of each article.)

My opinion was (and is), while I mean no disrespect for our great neighbors to the north, the televised singing of their national anthem was out of place. Simply put, _the race wasn’t in Canada. Why was the anthem sung? Was it done simply because there were a lot of Canadians at the event?

Now I personally have never been to a race at MIS, but members of our message board community who have been going there for years said that the practice of singing the Canadian Anthem is done regularly, BUT…this was the first time they remember it being televised. I have discovered it is, in fact, done to welcome/honor our guests from north of the border.

Now, I have no problem with welcoming or honoring fans who come to our country to attend an event, but is their national anthem really necessary? What is wrong with a big "Welcome! Glad you are here. Enjoy our hospitality!"

NASCAR, in an effort purely based on market demographics, now holds two races a year at California Speedway in Fontana, CA. The dates awarded to Fontana were solely intended to bring more dollars and more ethnic diversity into the NASCAR fan base, as fans and competitors alike have long been opposed to the schedule changes it caused.

Fontana, as a city alone (not counting the surrounding area) has a total population of about 130,000, of which almost 75,000 claim to be of Hispanic origin. To dive deeper into the city of Fontana, of the 75,000 listed as Hispanic, almost 30,000 are listed as being foreign born, meaning they are (also) citizens of whatever country they were born in. With using the actual city of Fontana as that base, it is just common sense that the surrounding area in general reflects the same proportional numbers.

Now, do not misrepresent this diatribe to be racist against any group from any country. My point or question here is, why isn't any other country's national anthem sung at any other NASCAR events that are close to our southern border? What about the vast Cuban population that may attend a race in southern Florida? Can’t we sing the Cuban anthem for them? What is it about Canadians that make them special? Is it because, for the most part, “Canadians” look more like “Americans” and you can't tell them apart until they speak to you, so they’re “cool” enough to get their anthem sung?

Some folks on our message board have suggested that to worry about such seemly trivial things in NASCAR is a waste of time considering pressing issues in the sport such as the Car of Tomorrow, etc. They may very well be right. All I know is that the whole thing caught me off guard and left me with a lot of questions.

Politically and socially, our country is in the midst of a great debate regarding immigration and the use of English as our “official” language. Since no one that I have spoken to can remember the singing of another country's anthem actually being televised, I am left with the feeling that NASCAR and FOX just kind of “threw it out there” to see how it would go over.

With me, it didn't go over too well.

Stay off the wall (but get up on it and let me know how you feel!),

Jeff

NEW YEAR? NEW NEWSLETTER. LOOKING FOR THE INFO YOU NEED ABOUT NASCAR IN 2013 – SENT RIGHT TO YOUR EMAIL INBOX?
Well, you’ve come to the right place. The Frontstretch Newsletter gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up and get all the information you need. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

 

©2000 - 2008 Jeff Meyer and Frontstetch.com. Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

Walt
06/21/2006 11:24 PM
permalink

Jeff,
I understand your bewilderment in response to the singing of the National Anthem of Canada. In all fairness the same is done nearly every year at Loudon and if I remember correctly they used to do it at Pocono as well. It doesn’t always make it to the broadcast. Heck, OUR national anthem didn’t used to get broadcast at every race not so long ago. It has been considered a courtesy to present both anthems as through the years we have had many competitors, not so many drivers but crewmembers, who are of Canadian descent that regularly participate at these venues. You will find that the same courtesy is extended at many of the local short tracks in New England and reciprocated by short tracks in Canada. Try not to be too upset. It is just a courtesy.

Ron St John
06/22/2006 04:53 AM
permalink

Jeff I like you were caught when then they played dual anthems,but it has been done many times in baseball at the allstar games,and at hockey games.And if you drew a circle of 600 miles around the Pocono,NHIS,MIS you would include aprox anywhere from 25 to 60 % of the population of Canada.If you are still bothered about it call MIS and ask what percentage of tickets sold were sent to Canada

Colin Baird
06/22/2006 05:13 AM
permalink

Jeff;

What the hell ya’ bitchin’ about? Just about anything is better than listening to the cornpone clattertrap of Darrell Waltrip. If I hear one more boogity, I’m gonna puke.
Larry Owens
06/22/2006 05:16 AM
permalink

I’m OK with singing another countrys anthem if the country is in close proximity to a track, however, our anthem should be sung first.

Jan
06/22/2006 05:19 AM
permalink

Haven’t you ever noticed the proximity of the Michigan track to the Canadian border crossing at Windsor? This is a REAL no brainer!

At Syracuse NY’s Super DIRT Week for the modifieds, much better racing than NASCAR presents anywhere BTW, the Canadian National Anthem is always played after ours. Why? Because quite a few drivers, crewmembers and fans of the Big Block Modifieds hail from our friend to the North.

celeste
06/22/2006 05:45 AM
permalink

Driving through the infield at MIS, there were a ton of Canadian license plates. We’ve always done the Can. anthem (just acknowledging our neighbors). There’s also a Canadian flag flying on the frontstretch. The USA anthem goes last if you are in the USA, ie. NHL games.

Mindy
06/22/2006 05:58 AM
permalink

Larry, in the USA, when then US Natioanl anthem and another country’s national anthem are both played, it is considered proper ettiquette to play the US National Anthem last.

I have no problem with the Canadian National Anthem being played before the Michigan race. What is shocking to me is that the vast number of people that have an ‘issue’ with this on the racing message boards. I guess that there are more bigoted people out there that have an ‘only America matters’ mentality. No wonder foreigners refer to us an ‘ugly Americans’. (It will not be long before we will be called “ugly, bigoted, & ignorant Americans”)

M. B. Voelker
06/22/2006 06:40 AM
permalink

Why do people care about this simple coutesy toward Canadien fans and team members? Do you believe that only the Mexican anthem should have been sung at the Mexico City race?

BTW—Hispanics are NOT a monolithic block. If you call my Puerto Rican stepmother a Mexican she will let you know how wrong you are with a vehement intensity only seen in the Nascar world during Gordon vs. Earnhardt feuds.

JGR Fan
06/22/2006 06:42 AM
permalink

I am a frequent ticket holder at MIS, and also Canadian. I believe I heard the stat that about 40-45% of the crowd at both MIS Nextel Cup races are from Canada (that’s a lot of fans!). MIS also has “Canada Day” for the August race. It sure is nice to feel welcomed at the track.

Tammi
06/22/2006 07:03 AM
permalink

Singing the Canadian Anthem at MIS is showing the proper respect that is also shown in all the major sporting events held in Michigan. If you watch NHL and the Wings are playing at home, the Canadian Anthem is always sung first and televised. Nothing wrong with it so why all the complaining ?

Dawn Johnson
06/22/2006 07:19 AM
permalink

Jeff,
Wow, I’m surprised by all the people in support of the Canadien anthem. My husband and I were as confused as you when they aired the singing of the other anthem. Like you, we don’t have a problem with it being sang, we are torn on whether it was appropriate. At a time when our country is struggling with our values and traditions, we don’t need to add more to the mix of “honoring” other countries. Especially since our values are being challenged by those that live on this soil.

Mad Mikie
06/22/2006 08:06 AM
permalink

While I can’t say why they played the Canadian National Anthem at the northern tier tracks, I can tell you something about rendering respect to the flag of a foreign nation during a military formation.

Having been involved in a few of these ceremonies during my military career, it doesn’t matter if it’s an ally or an enemy, you alway render respect to the flag and national anthem. Which in my case was saluting the foreign flag. As much as I wanted to not salute the flag of one of our adversaries back during the days of the cold war, it took some professionalism to overcome the dislike of that country, what they stood for, and their oppression of millions of people.

So while we may not have liked it, we did it out of professional courtesy and respect.

Susan
06/22/2006 08:19 AM
permalink

I don’t know the specifics of how the tradition of playing the Canadian National Anthem started, but to suddenly STOP playing it after however many years would be a rude slap to our Canadian friends.

Nikki
06/22/2006 08:41 AM
permalink

I was a bit surprised by the televised singing of the Canadian anthem, but mainly because I dont remember them televising it before. Have they not always done it right after the invocation? With a track that close, with that many Canadian fans, I have no problem with it. And while this isn’t very important to the subject, I must disagree with you, Tammi. My husband is a HUGE Red Wings fan. We have to buy the NHL package from DirecTV just so he can see every game. You stated that the Canadian anthem is sung and televised before every Wings homegame. The only time we have ever seen them perform the Canadian anthem is when the Wings are playing a Canadian team. If they do it during other games, it is not televised.

Rick aka GreenGriffen
06/22/2006 09:33 AM
permalink

RE: Dual Anthems at MIS
As GreenGriffen I haven’t posted much lately on FS message board. Good thing too because if I saw these dumb issues I would post something like this!
-I was born in Windsor (Motown.ca -geographically south of Detroit)
-in the 1950’s I lived in Michigan (even had a green Alien status card)
-I made an issue one day in Gr 4 of not standing up in music class for the Star Spangled Banner – if I had of been in different circumstances ie: Mc Carthy Red Scare crazed era teachers or if I was an adult I would have been wrong.
-My uncle the late John Marsh helped start MIS
He was ex WW2 RAF and was a prime mover in putting the Lancaster Bomber in Jackson Park, Windsor as member of Confederate Air Force too
-Myself like I said in 1957-58 had “patriotic-USA teachers. Fact is they would say ie: oh children the Commies couldn’t have launched a man into space before us, it must be a trick, a tape recorder.
-fact is for saying ” teacher if they could launch a tape recorder and dogs, why not people?
-Gr 5 and I was forced to change to Mr Nugents class (non political Irish Hills Man)
-I stand up for both inspite of having experienced 1968 when Linda from Riverside High
and John Tuz of Essex Scotish went to the fresh grave site with me, Canadian volunteer returns from Nam. Just a couple months before this they had been on the front page of the Windsor Star behind sand bags with the New Canadian flag (imagine the government in USA changing the flag!)We are very different countries…by politics
and the definition of “IS”
-Myself in 1968 saw RFK & MLK as an effect! I was in Chicago that fall and the election of Nixon that year and then him picking Ford is far more extreme than a mere flag from Canada.

ie Forget Sgt York can a “Christian” (see IS) under any circumstance , even war kill? Were J Witness’s unpatriotic in 1939 Germany? I stand up for everything but only the Unhypocritical Good IS Part. In fact many in Canada find me too American.
Believing in Soverign State as Principle even Qubec. And unlike many would vote our province to be soverign too. But not any closer to the USA except I believe the 30+ million Canadian voters might pull down the next USA Presidential Canidate that had a foolish type of world patriotism I think I should be allowed to vote for who becomes President. It concerns me more than who is Prime Minister! GreenGriffen69
Laura
06/22/2006 10:05 AM
permalink

If they sang it anyway, what difference did it make if the televised it? I don’t get why it’s such a big deal. The way NASCAR is changing nothing surprises me. It’s all about the money now.
I will be right beside you raising hell the day they DON”T sing our anthem. THAT would be the last day I watch a race. Don’t scoff,they have taken everything out of the schools (prayers and saluting the flag)........... will NASCAR be next?

J. Meyer
06/22/2006 10:27 AM
permalink

For the record. I DO NOT have a problem with them singing Oh Canada at the track! It is a nice, polite gesture. But, if this instance wasn’t some sort of social experiment by NASCAR and Fox, WHY is it the first time anyone seems to remember it being TELEVISED to the rest of the country? I watch more races than I attend and this is the FIRST time I have ever seen it, whether they were racing at MIS, Pocono or Louden.
As for you GreenGriffen! This article was solely intended to flush you out and it worked! We’ve been missing you on the board! Don’t be a stranger!

C88WIN
06/22/2006 10:38 AM
permalink

As so astutely pointed out by a previous post,no need to call the MIS ticket office to find out how many tickets go to Canadians,although having gone to MIS annually since ‘90,I can tell you with great accuracy the figure is closer to 50-55%.The Canadian anthem has been sung at every event in that time,it’s just the myopic suits at the networks have never bothered to show it before now.This was long overdue.Never mind the vast majority of fans being Canadian at MIS,Pocono,NHIS,etc,how about Daytona and Bristol which are fully 40% or more Canadian?It’s about damn time the network twerps and the braintrust(?) at NASCAR recognized the fact that Canada is equally as responsible for the growth and prosperity of our sport as the good ol’ USA.

Steve Cosentino
06/22/2006 11:18 AM
permalink

You say your from Iowa? Sounds more like San Jose. What I can’t believe is that you would be linked from such a quality sight as Jaski to your worthless opion. You say your not bigoted, BUT THEN YOUR WRITE $%^%& LIKE THIS? If you watched any of the Stanley Cup you would know how wonderful the fans of Canada, and specifically Edmonton, is towards the USA. They didn’t just reluctantly stand up, they belted out the words and cheered OUR anthem. NASCAR wants to broaden their fan base. I don’t think they have people like you in mind. Go back to minor league baseball in Iowa and you will not have to hear the Canadian anthem again

Tammi
06/22/2006 11:31 AM
permalink

Nikki,
I am aslo a HUGE Wings fan and I am sorry that I didn’t mention that the Canadian Anthem is only sung when they are playing a Canadian team. There is still no reason why they can’t sing Canada’s Anthem before a NASCAR race.

nancy
06/22/2006 11:37 AM
permalink

You can’t be much of a NASCAR fan if you’ve never noticed this before about the Canadian National anthem. It’s been done for years. Maybe the beer at the bar clouded your eyes and plugged up your ears

VirginiaGal
06/22/2006 01:03 PM
permalink

Most of the “issues” raised by this could have been easily avoided if the folks in the broadcast booth had simply explained why that was being sung. Most people (there are always exceptions) were asking questions about the singing because they didn’t expect it or understand why it was done.
There is nothing bigoted about asking why something was done!

KWGray
06/22/2006 01:47 PM
permalink

The thing i think is terrible are the number of folks spectators and Drivers/Crew members that disrespect our (US)
anthem by not placing their hands/hats over their hearts while it is being played. It doesn’t matter who’s in the White House – it is still the greatest country on the planet and they should feel damn lucky to be here!!!

MikeCanuck
06/22/2006 02:15 PM
permalink

From what I have been told by an MIS Sales rep, Canadians account for nearly 40% of tickets sales for the races there. The Canadian Anthem has been sung for as long as I have been going (Since ‘88) and they used to do it at Pocono as well. This is the first time I have seen it televised (which as a CDN was kinda nice!). The reason they would have sung it first is a) because of the flyover and b) by singing the US anthem afterward, it sets it up as “the main event” of the two anthems.

Hockey arenas do this all the time to get the crowd cheering louder: visting anthem first.. now let’s show ‘em how it’s done!

Rob
06/22/2006 03:40 PM
permalink

I am a NASCAR fan ( big Mark Martin fan too ) and I am proudly Canadian. I was at this particular race and i always go to Walkins Glen and useually Ricmond, Bristol and Charlotte Motorspeed ( oh I wish they’d bring back Rockingham ). Anyway…it is a nice touch that tyhey play our anthem in Walkins Glen and Michigan. I proudly wear my hat that my brother in law bought for me in Afganistan. Taskfocr Rakasan….it is a joint taskforce of Canadian and American soldiers based in Kandahar…he served there for 18 months…..the hat has both the Canadian Flag and US flag on it and I proudly wear it t support both of our countries….we are a lot closer than you think! God Bless Canada and The United States!

Nikki
06/22/2006 04:37 PM
permalink

I agree, Tammi. If they are racing at a place like MIS where that many fans are from Canada, there is no reason not to play it. Out of respect, it should be played. And Go Wings :)
In response to Steve Consentino, I didn’t notice any disrespect during the playoffs this year. However, lets not forget a few years ago, I believe I specifically remember it was Vancouver, where they played the US National Anthem and the entire crowd booed. It wasn’t just that one game, either. I remember hearing it several times that season. And maybe I’m reading a different article, but I dont really see where he is being bigoted or racist. I know several people wondered the same thing, so it’s not just his “worthless opinion.” I didn't see him say the anthem should not be played, just wondering why Fontana and other tracks like that don't do the same. For me, it’s not the fact that they did it that threw me off, its the fact that its the first time I’ve ever seen them do it and didn’t realize they do it every year.

Bonkrr
06/22/2006 05:07 PM
permalink

Nikki, in this years NHL playoffs, the fans in San Jose roundly booed the Canadian anthem when the Edmonton Oilers were in town. The fans in Edmonton responded when the series returned north by loudly and rambunctiously singing the American anthem followed by a rousing standing ovation afterward. Then they sang the Canadian anthem even louder. If you watched the whole playoffs, you no doubt saw the fans in Carolina grasp this and competitive anthem singing (at least in the NHL) was launched.

Oh, and Jeff Meyer, if this is the best you can come up with to write about, you’re just not trying hard enough. No controversy here, just respect for neighbours, given and returned.

celeste
06/22/2006 05:21 PM
permalink

“Oh, and Jeff Meyer, if this is the best you can come up with to write about, you’re just not trying hard enough. No controversy here, just respect for neighbours, given and returned.”

Amen!

rick
06/22/2006 06:12 PM
permalink

you think that singing oh canada at mis is strange,just “wait”.busch is going to race in montreal and there they will sing it in french.

Ron St John
06/22/2006 07:11 PM
permalink

WOW JEFF
lots of voices being heard
but to-day thurs 6-22 they on SPEED TV as usual re-broadcast the race
and lol and behold they didn’t show any of the opening but a voice over stating that the people in the stands came from over 12 diferent countrie’s and many states then went into Adam’s “GETTLEMAN START YOUR ENGINES”
somebody musta complained…but they did do it right last sunday

John F.
06/22/2006 07:50 PM
permalink

You ignorant *#@$&@%. I suppose you didn’t see the hockey game last week where, in Edmonton, Alberta, you could barely hear the guy singing the Star Spangled Banner because the crowd was singing it too loudly. Out of respect for the U.S. (and I was proud of them for doing it)

Sorry if the 3 minutes of class and respect shown by MIS was so damned hard for you to take. Obviously your time is much too valuable. You make me sick

Musicman
06/22/2006 09:31 PM
permalink

You put your hat back on? While an anthem was being sung, you put your hat on? That is an affront to any country! It is mandatory for all men (and women wearing unisex style hats) to remove their hats during the singing of an anthem, regardless of the country.

cathy
06/23/2006 08:59 PM
permalink

I find it hard to believe that this is even a article. If you don’t like it don’t watch the race. I go up to MIS every year and camp I talk to just as many people from Canada as i do from the U.S. Also there are a lot of track workers that are from Canada. So I look as it as a thank you to all of those guys for keeping the drivers safe.

Mark 42
06/25/2006 10:19 AM
permalink

I was born in Canada, and retain dual citizenship.
I was perplexed, and initially a bit unhappy about the singing of Oh Canada at a NATIONAL (as in U.S.) stock car event. I think if they would have explained why as part of the songs intro, and said “Please stand for the singing of Oh Canada and The Star Spangled Banner” it would have helped a lot.
To put it into perspective…
Both anthems are sung at Hockey games whn teams are from both countries.
Both anthems are sung at all star games when players are from teams originating in both countries.
There aren’t any Canadian based NASCAR teams (unless CASCAR is part of NASCAR)

BOB
06/29/2006 10:54 AM
permalink

Why all the crying over our anthem?..

pjl_u2
07/02/2006 08:19 AM
permalink

ignorance is bliss they say…... wishing i could be mentally challenged or an american so i could be ignorant of the world around me too !

TC
07/04/2006 02:23 PM
permalink

I don’t have a problem with them singing the Canadian National Anthem, but I believe the reason it was televised for the first time is Nascar’s continuing greed.They’re marketing to the Canadians. It’s never enough. There is a Busch race scheduled for Canada next year and I would bet Cup will follow in years to come and they are trying to show how nice they will be and how much they want them to be part of their sport. Good business and marketing, maybe but they show no loyalty to the fans they already have who have supported their sport for years. I wonder which track will lose a race when they star racing in Canada

 

Contact Jeff Meyer

Recent articles from Jeff Meyer:

BSNews! Bruton’s Plans Extend Beyond Bristol’s Track
Top Ten Reasons Fans Failed To Show Up At Bristol Sunday
BSNews! NASCAR CEO Given "Special" Award Amidst Lavish Fanfare
Fan Coun-ci-What? Just What Is It That NASCAR Wants To Study?
Top Ten Reasons People With No Sense of Humor Write In And Complain About These Lists

Want to know more about Jeff Meyer or view his complete article archives? Then hop on over to his archive and bio page.