The Frontstretch: Nice Guys Don't Finish First Too Often by Kurt Smith -- Thursday July 15, 2010

Go to site navigation Go to article

Nice Guys Don't Finish First Too Often

Happy Hour · Kurt Smith · Thursday July 15, 2010


When Leo Durocher said “nice guys finish last,” his point wasn’t that a competitor needs to trample on his opponents to win. What he was saying was that no one hates a loser.

It’s amusing to watch the tributes to George Steinbrenner from a sports media that absolutely despised the man while he was alive. A tyrant, a dictator, Big George was very often made to seem inhuman by the press. Once death made him a loser in the game of life, suddenly we’re hearing about how much he cared about his players, how charitable he was, how dedicated to the Yankees and New York he was.

Steinbrenner’s crime as owner of the Yankees was winning, and doing it a lot. Now that he isn’t doing it anymore, his heavy-handed ownership style doesn’t seem so bad. So there you go. When they’re all kicking you, you must be doing something right.

In a world dominated by television, few sports fans know their heroes personally. Often times their public persona is very different from the person one sees with the cameras off. You really can’t judge a person’s character by an occasional soundbite, and you definitely can’t do it based on a reporter’s opinion.

So we tend to fill in the blanks based on what we do know. Most NASCAR fans have their favorite and least favorite driver, and rarely is that least favorite driver someone that runs 25th every week.

Whatever Kyle Busch’s character flaws, he wouldn’t likely gall too many people if he was fighting to qualify for races on Fridays. Fans would probably be a lot more understanding of his refusal to answer inane questions if he wrecked out of the top 35. Some time ago I wrote an article quoting members of the motorsports press writing about Kyle Busch and how all of them were littered with “buts”. He annoys the crap out of so many people, mostly because he doesn’t apologize for offending people by winning.

Fans don’t dislike Kyle Busch solely for his abrasive personality…but moreso because he wins too much.

For years, I, like many NASCAR commentators, pondered the irrational hatred for Jeff Gordon. I’ve never seen so many middle fingers in one place as I did at my first trip to Martinsville.

Forget the wins and championships and Gordon’s personality is similar to Casey Mears’s. Nobody hates Casey Mears. There might be some people that resent that other drivers were passed over to give him a ride when he hadn’t proven himself, but there isn’t a loud roar from the grandstand whenever he crashes.

But beat Dale Earnhardt and Rusty Wallace and Bill Elliott, and people will cheer when you crash, call you names, throw cans at your car, and give all kinds of grief to people who root for you. And truthfully, in the end it’s just because a driver wins, not that he married Miss Winston or because he’s from Indiana instead of Alabama. When did Jeff Gordon start to become less despised by NASCAR fans? When he went into a winless skid in 2002. He was still hated, but the vitriol did seem to die off somewhat then.

Most everyone thinks highly of Mark Martin and rightly so. He is among the most gentlemanly racers and men who have graced this sport. But the most powerful emotion that grips NASCAR fans regarding Mark Martin is sympathy—that the man has come within inches of a Cup so many times and fallen just short every time. What if the penalty at Richmond had been reversed and Martin won the Cup in 1990? He may not have been so revered in the garage and in the press. He would likely be seen more like Matt Kenseth is seen—as an even-tempered, clean racing champion, still well-liked and respected, but rarely if ever associated with the words “sentimental favorite” the way Martin is.

Meanwhile, sometimes even Jeff Gordon isn’t a big fan of Jimmie Johnson these days. Gordon always had kind things to say about his protégé, even as the student overtook the master in success. But once Johnson reached four titles, a mini-feud started to grow between the two, starting with bumping into one another in Texas followed by Jimmie cutting Jeff off at Talladega and Gordon spouting some not so kind words about a champion who has made him a nice chunk of money.

Jimmie’s as nice a guy as a driver can be, but that doesn’t matter, man. He’s beating Jeff Gordon.

David Reutimann and Jamie McMurray are two sentimental favorites in the victory column this year, largely because they don’t often stand in the way of fan favorites winning races. They’re both gentlemen, but it’s not likely they would be so highly spoken of by NASCAR fans if they were laying the competition to waste.

Running mid-pack consistently without offending anyone will sometimes pay off in spades for a driver. McMurray and Ryan Newman are well-liked in the garage and in the press. Part of it is that no one is jealous of either of them winning every other week. Both drivers earned Daytona 500 wins with some help from a teammate or a former teammate.

Would those 500 wins have happened if either of those two were racking up wins the way Jimmie Johnson does? Maybe, but I doubt it. It’s not that Newman or McMurray didn’t earn their 500 victories by any stretch of the imagination. But I do suspect there might have been some wrecks if Jeff Gordon or Jimmie Johnson were the ones up front on the final lap. If Tony Stewart was a backmarker, I doubt Kurt Busch would have been motivated solely to deny the No. 20 car a win.

Most everyone in and around NASCAR, including yours truly, was very happy to see David Reutimann grab a “legitimate” win. Reutimann truly is, after all, a decent guy. And I was as happy as anyone to see Jamie McMurray win the Daytona 500. He’s a good guy too.

But if either of those guys were whooping on my favorite drivers all the time, I probably wouldn’t be calling them nice guys. Even though they are.

Contact Kurt Smith

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Racing to the Point: NASCAR Has Its Own Heartbreak Kid
Beyond the Cockpit: Brittany Force, the Fastest Force
Voices from the Cheap Seats: Advertising for Dummies
Who’s Hot / Who’s Not in Sprint Cup: Off Week-Richmond Edition
Couch Potato Tuesday: Picking The Best IndyCar On-Air Personalities


©2000 - 2008 Kurt Smith and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

07/15/2010 10:28 AM

The comments on George remind me of the words of the song “Nashville is rough on the living but she really speaks well of the dead.”

07/15/2010 10:56 AM

Caught the end of CSI-New York last night and could swear I saw Danica. Tell me it was a nightmare. Tell me it’s about the racing. Maybe that’s why she can’t run any more Nationwide races. Busy Schedule.

Carl D.
07/15/2010 11:30 AM

I don’t think it’s just the winning that makes drivers despised by Nascar fans. A lot of people didn’t like Jeff Gordon because he seemed so bland and so “corporate” when he first came into Cup. Plus he tended to whine a lot when things didn’t go his way. Illegal wheels and racecars that were banned after one race didn’t help Jeff’s image either. Now that Gordon’s personality shows the fire and passion that was undoubtedly there all along, and the seasoning and maturity that comes with age and experience, even many fans like me who once pulled against him would like to see him end his current winless streak.

Oh, and some fans just don’t like Rick Hendrick drivers no matter who they are.

DoninAjax… Stick with CSI: The Original. No Danica sightings there that I know of.

07/15/2010 01:46 PM

I’ve been a fan of Jamie McMurray since he was running in the Busch series and get extremely frustrated when he runs well early and then either has a mechanical issue or gets caught up in somebody else’s mess. I cheered so loudly at home when he won at Daytona.

07/15/2010 02:58 PM

I think people disliked Jeff at the beginning because of his moustache.
Another article on DANICA:
She really does need to spend more time in stock cars.

Contact Kurt Smith