The Frontstretch: Thinkin' Out Loud: NASCAR's Regular Season Finale Race Recap by Mike Neff -- Monday September 9, 2013

Go to site navigation Go to article

Key Moment – The caution flag flew with 55 laps to go, in the middle of green-flag pit stops to trap many of the leaders a lap down. Prior to that, Carl Edwards had been a non-factor, slowly working his way to around fifth place. But with the lucky break, he exited the pits in the top spot and that allowed him to go on and win the race.

In a Nutshell – Brad Keselowski did everything he could to put himself in contention to make the Chase, but came up short at the end. Kurt Busch looked like a strong contender for the win but had to settle for making the Chase. Jeff Gordon looked like he was going to pull off the last-minute Chase save again this year but came up two positions short. Ryan Newman had the playoffs in his grasp, but a spin by Clint Bowyer and a fumble by his pit crew left Newman out of the Chase by virtue of a tiebreaker to Martin Truex, Jr. Carl Edwards put himself in contention on the penultimate pit stop, then jumped the final restart to secure the win and take the meaningless points lead into the Chase.

Dramatic Moment – Ryan Newman raced his way to the lead as the laps were winding down to put himself in position to take one of the two “wild card” slots in the Chase. The battle between him and Edwards was compelling, nullified when Clint Bowyer spun with six laps to go. The resulting stops changed the outcome of the race; Newman’s crew didn’t hold the lead and it ultimately cost their driver a spot in the Chase.

What They’ll be Talking About Around the Water Cooler

Clint Bowyer spun by himself with a handful of laps to go. Conspiracy theorists are trying to spin it that Bowyer fell on his sword to give Truex an opportunity to grab a Chase spot. But the fact is, Bowyer couldn’t have expected Newman’s crew to blow the stop, or Truex to end up just enough spots behind Newman to secure the Chase via tiebreaker. If the Michael Waltrip Racing group took that chance, congratulations on having it work out, but it just seems too much of a crapshoot for Bowyer to have done it on purpose — questionable in-car audio aside.

In April of 2012, Tony Stewart was leading the race at Richmond when Carl Edwards fired early on a late-race restart. Stewart didn’t bite and Edwards was penalized for taking off too early. Fast forward to Saturday night. Paul Menard took two tires on the final pit stop of the night to put himself in the lead with three laps to go. He took off on the restart, Edwards passed him and was completely ahead of Menard by the time the leaders crossed the start/finish line. For whatever reason, NASCAR chose to swallow the whistle and allowed Edwards to drive off and take the win this time. Were they evening things out? A lot of people felt like the No. 99 was unfairly penalized last season.

What’s wrong with Jimmie Johnson? Johnson was so far ahead of the field after Pocono that people were already handing him the championship trophy. In the last four weeks, he’s finished 40th, 36th, 28th, and 40th. Johnson’s lead after Pocono was the biggest since the implementation of the new point system. He left Richmond second in the “old school” standings. With the reset, he now remains second, three behind Matt Kenseth. The No. 48 team has been known to turn on the switch when the Chase starts; they’ve overcome bad summers before. But they’re going to be tested this year, for sure because their momentum is completely non-existent right now.

The amount of hot air that was vented over the last week, and especially Saturday night, about all of the different possibilities and vagaries that could take place at Richmond among the 15 or so drivers who could potentially end up in the Chase would have filled every airship ever flown in the history of mankind. That makes it ironic when the checkered flag flew at the end of the Federated Auto Parts 400, there was exactly zero change in the Chase drivers from the end of the Advocare 500 in Atlanta. Was there some drama? Maybe. Did it really matter? No. At the end of the day, the drivers who are running well when the series heads into Richmond will usually be the drivers who are in contention at Homestead.

Predictions are running rampant and everyone has their own opinion about who is going to win the title. With Kyle Busch and Carl Edwards winning the last two races, they have to be under consideration. Clint Bowyer looked strong early and kept himself near the top of the point standings all season. Matt Kenseth has been strong on intermediate tracks, with three wins out of five races run on 1.5-milers this year. Kasey Kahne has the best average finish among all drivers on 1.5-mile tracks so he has to be considered a threat, too. Jimmie Johnson is always a favorite in the Chase, but the No. 48 team is going to have to do some serious tightening of the screws if they’re going to truly threaten for their sixth title. I think the wheels truly have come off (see above).

Three of the five caution flags the flew on Saturday night were for debris. Once again, we didn’t get to see any of the debris on TV. We only saw one safety truck even on the track to appear to pick anything up. Amazingly, after the third caution of the night, as the field headed off to Turn 1, Jamie McMurray hit a water bottle that was laying in the groove; um, wasn’t that supposed to be cleaned up? Debris cautions have become such a crutch for NASCAR to try and orchestrate the races that they should seriously be outlawed. Unless there is a tire carcass or a bumper cover laying in the primary groove, they need to keep the yellow flag in the back pocket and let the teams settle the races.

Ryan Newman reportedly already has a contract in hand for next season to drive for Richard Childress Racing. That is a good thing, for his sake because the way he threw his pit crew under the bus on Saturday night after coming into the pits with the lead but leaving in fifth position was downright disturbing. It is going to be difficult to put together a pit crew who will want to bust their butt every week for someone who so casually chucks them to the wolves.

There are always ironies that play out during Cup weekends. The incestuous nature of the sport results in former bedfellows finding themselves squared off on opposite sides of competition. In an interesting twist after the race on Saturday night, Dr. Jerry Punch, who was waiting to interview Kurt Busch when he had his famous meltdown that ultimately cost him his job at Penske ended up being the pit road reporter who interviewed Busch about making it to the Chase. It was a very sweet irony, indeed.

The Hindenburg Award for Foul Fortune

Denny Hamlin considers Richmond his home track. Saturday night, it looked like his home had been foreclosed. Hamlin started sixth and stayed in the top 10 early. Unfortunately, he slipped back to the 20s before halfway and spent the rest of the day battling for spots around there before coming home 21st. 2013 has been a throwaway season for Hamlin. Hopefully, his squad will figure out some things that will make 2014 more successful.

Clint Bowyer looked like the car to beat for most of the night. He started in fourth and led 72 laps before he got caught out by a caution on lap 345. Bowyer was buried back in the pack after that, ending the night in 25th position and was accused of spinning on purpose to bring out the last caution of the night.

Defending champ Brad Keselowski, like Bowyer, looked pretty strong early, led the most laps in the race, but also found himself caught out by the debris caution on lap 345. His chances were gone, after that as the loss of track position left him struggling to simply finish 17th. Ironically it was Jimmie Johnson, the five-time series champion who blew a tire that spread the debris on the track, a wreck that ultimately prevented Keselowski from having the opportunity to defend his title.

The “Seven Come for Eleven” Award for Fine Fortune

Many people might think Joey Logano should be in the foul fortune column with his horrible race on Saturday. Logano was fortunate because the late caution allowed him to take a wave around to get to one lap down and on the same lap as several other drivers. One of those drivers was Brian Vickers, who was doing his best to make sure that his teammate Martin Truex, Jr. made the Chase. With Vickers running one of the slowest laps in the history of Richmond, Logano was able to pass him and David Gilliland, putting himself one point ahead of Jeff Gordon and into the Chase.

Carl Edwards was a non-factor for most of the race but was lucky enough to have not pitted when the caution flew for Johnson’s blown tire. His team ripped off a great pit stop and put him out front to contend for the race win. He then jumped the final restart, but was fortunate enough to have NASCAR not penalize him so that he could go on to win the race.

Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. was having a solid run already on Saturday night. But he capitalized on the timing of the Johnson flat and put himself in contention for a top 10. By the time the dust had settled, at the checkered flag Stenhouse quietly found himself with the first top 10 of his Cup Series career. Stenhouse has been knocking on the door of a top 10 all season, and he managed to ride the momentum of his first pole last week to his first top 10 overall this week.

Worth Noting

  • Carl Edwards win at Richmond was the 21st of his Cup career. It took him 327 series starts to reach that total.
  • The win is Edwards second victory of the season. It is also his eighth top 5 finish of the year.
  • This is the first Cup series win for Edwards at Richmond. It is his fourth top 5 in 19 starts at the ¾-mile track.
  • Were it not for the artificial restating of the points, Edwards would have the point lead by one over Johnson after the win at Richmond.
  • Kurt Busch’s second place finish was his third top-2 finish at Richmond in 26 career starts.
  • The runner-up finish for Busch is his first top-2 finish of the season and his eighth top 5 of the year. Busch closed with four top-5 results in the final six regular season races to make the Chase.
  • Ryan Newman’s third-place finish was his second top 3 of the season. He’s ended up in the top 5 six times this year.
  • Newman’s podium finish at Richmond was his fifth top-3 finish at the ¾-mile track. Newman has six top 5 finishes all-time at Richmond.
  • Jeff Gordon won the pole at Richmond for his first pole of the season. That marked the 21st straight year for Gordon winning a pole in Cup competition. That broke the record of 20 years that he shared with David Pearson.
  • Ricky Stenhouse, Jr. won the Rookie of the Race again this weekend.
  • AJ Allmendinger scored a 15th-place finish in the No. 47 on Saturday.
  • Greg Biffle was hardly mentioned during the race on Saturday but he secured a Chase position again, for the fifth time in six years.
  • Top 10 finishes by Manufacturer…

Ford – 2
Chevrolet – 6
Toyota – 2

What’s the Points?

For those of you who like “old school” points, Carl Edwards overtook Jimmie Johnson for the lead Saturday night. Edwards left Richmond one point ahead of Johnson in the now meaningless regular season standings.

As the series heads to the final 10 races, we get the artificially inflated point totals that apparently are supposed to make the battle for the title somehow more important. Matt Kenseth is now the point leader thanks to his five wins during the first 26 races of the year. Jimmie Johnson and Kyle Busch are tied for second, as each of them has four wins on the season. Kenseth has 2,015 points while Johnson and Busch are sitting on 2,012. Kevin Harvick and Carl Edwards both have two victories in the “regular season” so they are sitting with 2,006 points, nine out of the top spot. Joey Logano and Greg Biffle each have one win during the year so they’re holding 2,003 points, 12 behind Kenseth but three ahead of the Wild Cards and non-winners.

Clint Bowyer, Dale Earnhardt Jr. and Kurt Busch all enter the Chase with 2,000 points after not scoring a win in the first 26 races but having the necessary points to end up inside the top 10. Kasey Kahne and Martin Truex Jr. are the two “wild card” entrants. They will have 2,000 points each because Wild Card entrants do not receive bonus points for their wins.

Overall Rating (On a scale of one to six beer cans, with one being a stinker and a six pack an instant classic) – Richmond International Raceway routinely provides the best races on the schedule. The side-by-side competition and the importance of tires keep the fans on the edge of their seats all night. 17 lead changes, a total that included seven of them on-track is the kind of action that fans want to see. The race gets five ice-cold Michelob Amber Bocks. The only thing keeping it from receiving the full six was the lame no-call by NASCAR that allowed Carl Edwards to steal the victory. There is no doubt that the official review by NASCAR will find nothing wrong, but Edwards should have been penalized because that is the precedent that NASCAR has set.

Next Up — The first race of the Chase is next Sunday at Chicagoland Speedway. The folks in Daytona are hoping that the fans will show up in droves. If they don’t, you just might witness the beginning of the end for the intermediate track in Joliet, IL. The race will be aired on ESPN at 2:00 PM ET; it will also be broadcast live on your local MRN affiliate.

Connect with Mike!

Contact Mike Neff

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Mike Neff and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

09/09/2013 02:57 AM

Logano earned his spot a couple of times over this year to make the Chase. So Jeff and Ryan fell short, thats racing. This race had the usual lucky ones and not so lucky ones, again thats racing. Good going Joey, best of luck in the Chase.

Bill B
09/09/2013 07:00 AM

Wrestling on wheels.

09/09/2013 07:53 AM

I understand you feel Bowyers spin had to start “the perfect storm” for it to work in Truex favor… But let’s not forget the 15’s crazy pit stops afterward and the early pitting and slow speed of Vickers. It was a longshot…but at that point the only shot Truex had… And it worked! congrats from this fan!

09/09/2013 08:02 AM

This is the can of worms Nascar opened when they allowed multiple teams and ‘satellite’ teams. Unintended consequences.

09/09/2013 08:12 AM

Chicago? Yawn…..

Thank you Lord, for football season. It’s real. It’s exciting. May have some lousy calls from the officials but there are NO phony debris cautions.

And so now the season is over for all the drivers and teams not in the chase. Too bad. Could have been exciting over the last 10 “races”.

09/09/2013 08:35 AM

There’s not even any room for debate here, Bowyer clearly spun intentionally to alter the results of the race and the chase.

If this type of manipulation were done in a football or basketball game, those involved would face criminal charges.

Here is what NASCAR should do to rectify the situation. Remove Truex from the chase, penalize Bowyer enough points so that he will miss the chase, and fine MWR one million dollars.

On another note, whoever made the decision not to penalize Edwards, should be fired.

09/09/2013 09:02 AM

Hmm a brief glance at the nationwide wide points with several legitimate championship contenders, heck I think even the trucks have more legitimate contenders and a better point race (if that’s really your thing) than cup…. Again.
Joliet… Good riddance. Don’t let the door hit you in the back stretch..

Ghost of Curtis Turner
09/09/2013 09:21 AM

Nothing will happen to anybody, this is the norm now that NASCAR and The WWE have merged into one entity. Just another reason why people are staying away in droves.

09/09/2013 09:32 AM

Talked to a friend of mine the other day on the phone, he asked what I was doing and said “watching the race” to which he replied “Race? They still do that?” And he used to be a race fan. NASCAR’s salad days are over and they need to do something quick before its too late. Now that the NFL is here, it’s only going to get worse. Your average sports pan just doesn’t care anymore. Look at what happened to Speed channel. Fox Sports 1 is a joke.

09/09/2013 11:05 AM

Oh man. That race was rotten on several levels. Just so many things wrong with the way NASCAR handled it:

1. The debris caution around Lap 270. It happened a few laps after Jeff Gordon passed Brian Vickers for the lucky dog spot. I’m a 24 fan, and I was hoping for a caution to get him back on the lead lap. I had a feeling NASCAR might throw the caution for him, and it sure looks like they did. Maybe there WAS actual debris, but the TV crews HAVE to show it, and they didn’t. If NASCAR wants to be rid of this debate, they have to help the TV crews as much as possible.

2. Edwards jumping the restart is the biggest blown call I’ve seen NASCAR make in quite some time. I’m not the biggest fan of the whole leader-leads-at-the-line rule on restarts, because it tends to screw over everyone who’s not in the leader’s lane, but as long as the rule is in place, ENFORCE IT. And in a situation like Saturday’s, the onus is on NASCAR to explain clearly why the heck that was legal. They have a ton of data and telemetry they can show us.

3. I think Bowyer’s spin was intentional. On a day when almost nobody lost control, Bowyer lost control of one of the better-handling cars on the night. The other evidence is also pretty incriminating. Obviously, for an offense this severe you have to be 100% certain that it was deliberate (innocent until proven guilty), so NASCAR may not hand out any punishment—but if they know what’s good for them they’ll give a detailed explanation of why the evidence wasn’t enough to convict. Keeping with that theme, I’m not sure Truex’s team was complicit, so maybe they’ll escape some punishment. If MWR is caught, though, the penalties HAVE to be harsh.

Ugh. This would have been much less of a scandal if NASCAR was a little more honest and a little more transparent.

phil h
09/09/2013 11:11 AM

hhmmmm..even the NFL blew a call yesterday on penalties that should have been nullified. They then played the same down over again and the result was a TD for the team.
Not good NFL…you trying to emulate Nascar!!


phil h
09/09/2013 11:15 AM

so in conclusion

the last restart shows that Nascar definitely knows how to put on a show.gotta give them credit for blowing the plain as the nose on your face(pardon the pun)screw-up that was Carl Edwards a full car length over Menard.
That’s just plain damn funny how they think fans are that damn stupid. Geesh!

09/09/2013 11:16 AM

It’s just like we say at my job all the time: “You can’t make this stuff up!”

09/09/2013 12:08 PM

No congrats to Bowyer for me. MWR blatantly attempted to and succeeded in, manipulating the finish. Yes, calls can be blown in any sport but this was ridiculous. MWR knows they cheated – when does Mikey refuse to speak to the press? The only time that I recall was when his team was caught cheating at Daytona with the fuel and then he refused to talk yesterday at the truck race. This guy runs his mouth for a living.

I won’t be watching this farce of a “championship”. Football will have my attention for the next 10 weeks. NASCAR just became “who cares” as far as I’m concerned.

09/09/2013 12:12 PM

Ever since they started throwing fake debris cautions it has made this more of a show then a race. I’ve really struggled over the years with NASCAR manipulating the races to cover up the piss poor product the cars, tires and tracks have out out there. Restarts don’t excite me when they aren’t genuine. If a race is meant to go the whole way without a caution, let it happen – It’s not fair to the team who gets a big lead because they hit the setup early on to have it erased by a fake caution. If your not happy with your product – FIX IT! – eliminate some aero dependency on the cars, better tires, different tracks.

Friday night watching a cup driver steal a win from a NW regular by jumping a restart left another bad taste in my mouth. Two things that are awful about NASCAR right now – cup drivers dominating NW and horrible officiating – both on display. I didn’t think Saturday could be any worse, but boy was I wrong. When Newman took the lead and was about to race his way into the Chase, it reminded me why I love the sport. 10 minutes later, after an intentional spin and blatant blown restart call, i was reminded why I can no longer get excited about this sport and waste my time.

My driver is in the Chase, but I am done watching races for the year. Hell, I might be done forever unless NASCAR decides to actually let the teams “race” on tracks that put on a good show. I put up with the boring CHASE races on 1.5 milers for so many years, but now that the race to the championship is insincere I see no need to watch. I’m tired of wasting 4-6 hours of my life every weekend only to feel cheated and manipulated.

09/09/2013 12:32 PM

You have to think that Tony, after watching the footage and listening to the radio chatter, is going to wheel his hot-rod wheelchair into Helton’s office and go all AJ on him. I can’t imagine him not being totally steamed at such a blatant manipulation of the chase field. Regardless of Newman’s ultimate destination, Tony was trying hard to get Ryan’s car in the chase, and to have him cheated out of it won’t settle well with Smoke or Zippy. Can’t wait to hear from them!

09/09/2013 01:14 PM

No talk of the debri caution just as Gordon passed Vickers for the Lucky Dog. Looked fishy to me!

09/09/2013 01:30 PM

Having Hendrick drivers, teams, satellite drivers, and teams whining about cheating is about the funniest damn thing I’ve ever heard.

Also odd, I don’t hear anyone mentioning that Menard obviously jumped first on the final restart when Edwards drove around him before the start-finish line. Can you say “tire spin”?

Old Fan Bill
09/09/2013 01:34 PM

Mike,you must be one the writers on this site that drinks the MWR cool ade. You didn’t tell about Vickers being told by Ty Norris to come in for a pit stop because they needed one point. On top of that you are condoing their actions by saying, if they took that chance, congratulations on having it work out.

Jerseygirl you are right about Mikey and the press. He never saw a mike that he didn’t like.

09/09/2013 01:51 PM

Nascar minipulates races every week and you expect them to penalize a team who tried to do the same thing. Personally, I hope Nascar does nothing so it will make them look even more stupid.

Nascar made their bed with this stupid chase and now it is finally catching up with them and I can’t get the smile off my face at how this is going to make Nascar look. This controversy is all over the web and makes Nascar look like a joke and I love it. They are getting what they deserve.

I hope the ratings tank for the Chase too. No Gordon. No Stewart. No defending champ. And the possibility of Johnson winning #6. Sounds like must see tv to me.

With regards to the restart, if the roles were reversed and Menard jumped, you can bet he would have been penalized. After all, it would look pretty stupid if a non Chase driver won the race, wouldn’t it?

09/09/2013 01:58 PM

And oh by the way, the Bears are home this weekend. Having nobody show up for the first race of your precious playoffs doesn’t look so good. Maybe they can give a discount to all Amtrak employees considering the nice long train they will be watching all day long on Sunday.

Dr. Gonzo
09/09/2013 02:01 PM

This race seemed to demonstrate that Henrick is not nearly as good at team orders as most people suspect. At the final caution the #5, #24 and #88 were all on the lead lap. All they needed to do is have the #5 or #88 stay out and Lagano wouldn’t have been able to take the wave around and hence pick up a few positions.

09/09/2013 02:50 PM

Steve’s right with the Bears at home and with a team that actually looks pretty good more folks will be at Soldier Field than Joliet. I was at Joliet last weekend and it was awesome driving 148 mph and my daughter had a great time doing the ride along but as for a Nascar race … YAWN! This weekend I won’t be near that track. Heading north for the Packer game. Bowyer’s intential spin and Edwards jump of the restart with Nascar’s no call shows that Nascar and the Chase is a joke. A bad one. Bowyer should be disqualified from the Chase and MWR fined.

09/09/2013 03:14 PM

with that final jump of restart, that was it for me. then hearing what jr said about they’d be able to download info about the “spin”…

makes me wonder if the 48 will stop having issues next weekend since the “chase” begins. tv won’t focus on any drivers not in the chase.

after seeing childress talking to ryan prior to the race on sat on tv, and the pat on the back childress gave ryan, knew then and there where mr. newman would be headed.

Carl D.
09/09/2013 04:25 PM

The spin by Bowyer was unquestionably deliberate; and I do believe Edwards jumped the restart, but what are you gonna do? I’m just gonna let this one go and hope somebody… anybody… beats Johnson for the title.

09/09/2013 08:47 PM

Good luck on that… Carl D.

09/09/2013 08:48 PM

Wow. Neff’s apologist stance on the Bowyer spin would not have been tolerated under previous authorship. When you can’t count on FS to tell the truth…..

Old Farmer
09/10/2013 12:12 AM


Carl D.
09/10/2013 07:28 AM

Old Farmer… Unbelievable. There’s actually a tiny bit of credibility in Nascar this morning, huh? I’m completely numb.

09/10/2013 08:36 AM

Cheaters never prosper! Way to go NASCAR. It’s about time you got one right.

Wayne V
09/12/2013 12:39 PM

Don’t have to give an opinion as jerseygirl said it all about Mikey the Mouth! I wish at the very LEAST that FOX would take both Waltrips off the air. They are both despised by a very large part of the NASCAR fan base and that number is growing daily!


Contact Mike Neff

Recent articles from Mike Neff:

Special Winter Sprint Car Series set for January debut at Cocopah Speedway
Beyond the Cockpit with Ben Rhodes
Kroger 250 postponed until Sunday afternoon
Denny Hamlin out of the car for the race at Auto Club Speedway
Nationwide Breakdown – Drive to Stop Diabetes 300

Want to find out more about Mike Neff? Maybe see all the articles he's written here at the Frontstetch? Check out his article archive and bio page then!