The Frontstretch: Full Throttle: Is SPEED Speeding Away With Jimmy Spencer's Freedom Of Speech? by Mike Neff -- Monday April 16, 2007

Go to site navigation Go to article

SPEED Channel has always offered us various forms of entertainment through a typical weekend of NASCAR activity : Tradin’ Paint, Trackside, and NASCAR Live! are just some of the many options a fan can choose from. Nothing, however, seems to compare with the strength of the audience that tunes in for NASCAR RaceDay. The centerpiece of the various pre-race festivities that occur throughout the weekend has grown largely due to the uncensored, honest opinions expressed by the show’s analysts, Kenny Wallace and Jimmy Spencer. Spencer in particular has always been exceptionally opinionated, unafraid to ruffle the feathers of the higher-ups in Daytona about things that he feels are wrong with the sport or how something is being handled.

Until this weekend, that criticism has been met with mild resistance; now, that unadulterated attitude finds itself threatened on the heels of comments that may have finally gone a little too far over the line for someone’s taste.

The controversy centers around the way Spencer handled his opinions on the Dale Earnhardt, Jr. contract negotiations; specifically, his opinion of Earnhardt’s sister Kelley Earnhardt Elledge. During the pre-race show for the race in Texas this weekend, Spencer made the comment that Kelley should no longer be involved in negotiating her brother’s contract, having become a hindrance to the process because of her reliance on the family name. Going one step further, Spencer clearly stated that if Elledge worked for anyone else, she'd be fired due to the way she was handling the situation. He even commented on her personal preference to retain the Earnhardt family name, saying she should have dropped it like most women do after marriage.

Such strong opinions are nothing new for neither the show nor Spencer, but after the race was over, there was a new, unprecedented twist for the post-race telecast. As the show went to air, Spencer wasted no time to quickly stand up and apologize to Kelley. He claimed that he took things personally, admitting in public that it was not appropriate for him to make the comments he did during the pre-race telecast. Showing humility and remorse for his actions, it was the most glaring retraction of an opinion Spencer’s had since he’d been hired as a part of the show.

Now, whether his comments were accurate or not is not the piece that is up for debate here. The opinions expressed were those of Jimmy Spencer, and the reason networks want to have him on their broadcasts is that he speaks his mind and that strikes a legitimate chord with the fans. It’s his unfiltered opinion that’s largely responsible for drawing viewers to RaceDay, a unique personality that ultimately serves to drive up their ratings. For Spencer to speak his mind against popular opinion was nothing new; what was new was an apology. Based on patterns established through years of being on the broadcast, it certainly appeared that someone felt that those comments were out of line enough to have taken the time to speak to Spencer, clearly emphasizing in no uncertain terms that he should retract his thoughts as quickly as possible in order to avoid any possible backlash.

If that indeed turns out to be the case, then Spencer's whole appeal to the fan base has now been compromised. If he is going to let himself and his positions be influenced by what others think and feel, ultimately changing what he can say on each broadcast, then he is no longer going to have the appeal to the fans that brings so many of them to the couch each Sunday to watch his shows. If Spencer didn't realize his comments were out of line by himself, making the retraction on his own, then he is no longer the uninfluenced voice that everyone loves. One of the few unique voices in the NASCAR community might as well be permanently silenced, it’s ability to tell the truth permanently compromised by public opinion…or private dissatisfaction by the powers that be.

Today's attitudes of political correctness in the sterilized sports environment, where everyone is afraid of stepping on someone else’s toes, has made it nearly impossible to find unabashed opinions on a broadcast television program as it is. Nowadays, it seems any special interest group or corporate behemoth can easily reel a show in due to their power and influence. A classic example of this phenomenon was SPEED Channel’s Pit Bulls program, a show where journalists were able to voice their opinions without fear of retribution. Debuting a couple of years ago to strong initial ratings, the program continually allowed for insider points of view, showcasing to fans a wide range of opinions they were previously unaware of in the sport, many of which weren’t all that positive towards NASCAR. It didn't take long for the sanctioning body to react, reportedly putting excessive pressure on SPEED to pull the show from the very beginning. Eventually, they succeeded; the program only lasted one season before being pulled.

Hopefully, this situation proves to be an isolated incident where Jimmy realized he had simply allowed his own personal opinions to come into play while speaking about a private issue with which he was not familiar. If he is able to move on and continue to have the kind of attitude that brings people to listen to his shows, giving the fans an untainted view of how he views the sport and its problems, then the popularity of his programs should remain at a high level. If not, he will be just another emasculated mouthpiece for NASCAR that spews the same company line drivel that fans have grown so accustomed to. With one politically motivated decision, NASCAR RaceDay now could find itself heading towards an irreversible downward slide.

Hey race fans, are you looking for more exclusive Frontstretch content emailed right to your inbox every day? Then don’t miss the our brand new Frontstretch newsletter, currently in its first week of production! For more information on how to sign up, click on “newsletter” at the top of our home page, or check out this link. Jump on board with FS today!

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Mike Neff and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

04/17/2007 06:46 AM

Mikie, read the instructions that are printed below your own column on this very site: “The only comments that will not be published are comments that serve only to personally attack another commenter or the article writer…”

Now, if Frontstretch realizes that attacking people is a bad idea, don’t you think a personal attack on someone, broadcast on national TV, is a bad idea, too?

Free speech has limits. Jimmy’s learning that the hard way.

04/17/2007 06:50 AM

Seems to me that the issue isn’t so much what Spencer said as it’s about the fact he said it about Kelley Earnhardt.

Kevin Harvick’s comment about Teresa Earnhardt, that she was basically leeching off her dead husband and stepson, was just as sexist and outrageous as anything Jimmy said.

Yet, the only negative reaction Harvick got from most people was that he was sticking his nose in where it didn’t belong.


04/17/2007 08:09 AM

You have missed the point completely. If Jimmy had said something negative about a driver, owner, crew member, or Nascar, it would have been acceptable. To attack the family member of one of these is totally out of bounds, and apparently Jimmy is not smart enough to know this.

Please don’t assume that everyone who watches Raceday likes Jimmy Spencer or his opinions. Actually a lot of us watch it despite Jimmy’s opinions.

04/17/2007 10:00 AM

Jr. did take exception to Harvicks comment about Teresa so it wasn’t just blown over. This being live TV and watching Spencer go on and on was what I thought got people steamed. Can you imagine if Jr. had won the race and had to go to the desk in Victory Lane and sit with Spencer? I’d have paid to see that.

M. B. Voelker
04/17/2007 11:16 AM

Strangely for a Kurt Busch fan I like Jimmy Spencer, but the way he went off on Kelly was rude, unproffesional, and uncalled-for.

Unfortunately, the lack of wisdom in his phrasing obscured his core-point — that taking the contract negotiations to the media and the fans is unprofessional and inappropriate.

I hope that Jimmy realized, as a good, Christian man, that he’d been mean-spirited and rude in the way he’d presented his opinion and offered his appology sincerely.

04/17/2007 12:40 PM

Do you think that maybe Jimmy just realized that he had behaved like a jackass, and rightly concluded that a retraction and an apology were the only appropriate actions for a reasonable person to take?

04/17/2007 10:03 PM

I know I’ve said things I wish I could have taken back…not on national t.v., but just as embarrassing.

04/19/2007 06:16 PM

The remarks made by Jimmy Spencer were sexist. Therfore going on the assumptions listed in the article, we are to assume that Mr. Spencer is sexist as he was just conveying his true feelings. I am a female, a wife(40yrs), mother of a daughter, and grandmother of granddaughters. Not all Nascar enthusiasts are ignorant bigoted men like Mr. Spencer. An apology is not enough…it is his attitude that needs to be removed.


Contact Mike Neff

Recent articles from Mike Neff:

Special Winter Sprint Car Series set for January debut at Cocopah Speedway
Beyond the Cockpit with Ben Rhodes
Kroger 250 postponed until Sunday afternoon
Denny Hamlin out of the car for the race at Auto Club Speedway
Nationwide Breakdown – Drive to Stop Diabetes 300

Want to find out more about Mike Neff? Maybe see all the articles he's written here at the Frontstetch? Check out his article archive and bio page then!