The Frontstretch: Frontstretch Fan Q&A: NASCAR Mulligans And Night Racing by Summer Bedgood -- Thursday November 1, 2012

Go to site navigation Go to article

Frontstretch Fan Q&A: NASCAR Mulligans And Night Racing

Summer Bedgood · Thursday November 1, 2012


As a writer, I do my best to stay objective and look at the broad picture when it comes to these championship runs. But I have to admit, I was disappointed when I saw Denny Hamlin come to a dead stop on the frontstretch because of a mechanical failure at Martinsville. It wasn’t because I wanted him to win the championship or even the race for that matter. Rather, I was hoping for a three-man joust for the title at Homestead to one-up the riveting battle between Tony Stewart and Carl Edwards last season.

Mathematically, we could still have that. Brad Keselowski and Jimmie Johnson are neck and neck and Clint Bowyer’s deficit certainly isn’t insurmountable. However, I just don’t think Bowyer will give the same fight to this championship that Hamlin would have. I don’t mean he wouldn’t have tried as hard, but Hamlin has been there before. He’s been a serious title contender. Bowyer really hasn’t yet, at least not to the same extent.

My hopes are still up for a competitive championship fight. While I’ve said I think Keselowski will have a similar result as Denny Hamlin did in 2010, I still think this ending will be a fun one to watch. But when it comes to racing, three-wide is always more exciting than two. Right?

What a tough break for Hamlin. Now, on to the questions:

Would fans be happy with a Chase format where the Chase drivers would have their best and worst finishes thrown out? Personally, I would like to see every driver have a mulligan.


Fans won’t be happy with any Chase format, period. They already lambast this system for being too gimmicky. Adding in a mulligan system would cause blood to shoot from their eyes and steam to come out of their ears. You may even see some pitchforks and torches make an appearance at your nearest track.

While I personally like the Chase format, I’m not big on a mulligan system. Hamlin’s Martinsville finish shouldn’t just be “thrown out.” It needs to count, especially with so few races left. Can you imagine leaving Talladega and everyone decides to throw out their finishes? Why even race there at all?!

I know some fans say the same thing about the Chase system: “Why even run the first 26? They don’t count!” Well, they do count but only the victories really mean something. You can disagree as to whether or not that that should be the case (I agree), but they do certainly count. Put in a mulligan system and all of a sudden certain races become irrelevant. I just don’t see that as being a good thing, and I would imagine most fans would agree with me on that.

If all Chase tracks are required to have lighting and run on a Saturday night, that would open the door for one of the original Chase tracks to get a date back…

NASCAR needs to consider making all the Chase races to run on Saturday night – tracks without lighting in the Chase will have the choice of adding lights or moving their date. Trying to go against the NFL in the ratings war is not going to happen on Sunday afternoon. Though there is college football on Saturday nights, it is not as formidable as the NFL. Plus it gives NASCAR a legitimate reason to reorganize the tracks in the Chase. What are your thoughts?


I so agree with you, Dale! The biggest problem with that would be the weather. In some of the remaining races, it would be much too cold for fans to have an incentive to come out. However, I do wish we had more Saturday night races where it would be doable. The upsides outweigh the downsides. More fans can travel because they have Sunday to get back for work. If Saturday night gets rained out, they have Sunday to make it up. And, like you said, you have less competition with the NFL.

The other obstacle would be that four of the ten Chase tracks don’t have lights, and they probably wouldn’t want to invest. I would be perfectly fine with having the other six run at night, though that’s not going to happen anytime soon. Tradition is hard to break, and Sunday afternoons has been NASCAR’s forte for years.

I’m sure it’s something that has been discussed, but it appears that those of you who watch NFL and NASCAR will have to continue channel surfing, for the most part.

I’ve been very impressed by MWR’s turnaround this season! It’s been interesting to see that team go from zero to hero in a matter of months. How soon before they are championship contenders with the likes of Hendrick and Roush?


You could argue that they are already there! Bowyer is outrunning three of HMS’s four cars and all three of Roush Fenway Racing’s teams. In fact, Truex is also outrunning the three RFR teams, too.

If we’re being realistic, they’re still not in the discussions for championship contenders every season but they’re getting there. In fact, if RFR and JGR keep running like they have been since the Chase started, MWR will be second only to Hendrick Motorsports in terms of competition.

I think it will be at least two more seasons before Truex, Bowyer, and Vickers/Martin are actually the team to beat on a weekly basis, but the fact that they are even contention at all is a miracle. This will be a story that will continue to be fun to watch over the next few years. They have nowhere near reached their peak. When they do, that’s when the competition really needs to worry.

Connect with Summer!

Contact Summer Bedgood

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Did You Notice? … A Return To Richmond, Post-Spingate And Quick Hits
NASCAR Mailbox: A ‘Normal’ Saturday And A Valuable Lesson
Beyond the Cockpit: Tony ‘The Sarge’ Schumacher
Open Wheel Wednesday: Controversial Moves, Long Beach Crowds, and Being a Fuddy Duddy
The Frontstretch Five: Pleasant Surprises of 2014 So Far
IndyCar Driver Profile: Takuma Sato
Beyond the Cockpit: Tommy Baldwin on Owning His Team, Hall of Fame and the Number Seven


©2000 - 2008 Summer Bedgood and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

Jacklegged Nascar Expert
11/01/2012 10:42 AM

Its not when they race, its what, who, where and how they race.

11/01/2012 01:25 PM

Hate the chase. Always have, always will. Its such a phony deal and has resulted in boring boring boring races for most of the season. Races should be to win, not this constant points racing crap.

If NASCAR is going to keep the farce, then the racers in the chase need their own points system. Of course, if they do that, why should anyone other than the 12 teams in the chase bother to show up since they won’t get any air time.

I don’t want any more night races. It was too darn cold at Charlotte in October to be sitting there for hours. If they do that, I won’t be buying tickets. I’m not sure I am renewing the ones for Charlotte for next year. It was a boring race on top of my freezing so I was numb for several reasons.

11/01/2012 01:31 PM

Hey Summer, I wasn’t on Twitter Sunday (BIG mistake on my part). Was Denny your pick? ;)

Shortening the season and getting rid of one of the two races at MI, PA, etc might help the ratings and attendance.

A suggestion for the chase. Eliminate one driver each week who finishes the lowest. Let them become an Odd Wad who doesn’t get TV coverage. And, get rid of the 12, make it 10. As it is now, those in 11th & 12th don’t have to go to the banquet anyway.

Summer Bedgood
11/01/2012 01:34 PM

I don’t think I ever made an “official” pick. We usually do that in Mirror Driving and I wasn’t able to participate in that.

So if any Hamlin fans are wanting to place blame, it certainly won’t be on me. ;-)

11/01/2012 02:35 PM

Maybe this mulligan system has some merit. Dropping a bad race would maybe, just maybe allow these guys to take a risk or 2 to get a win and liven up some of these borefests. There are cons to this idea too but its an interesting thought.

Nascar doesn’t need to change where they race, (when Nascar was at its peak they did just fine on Sundays) they need to change the product on the track and how it is presented. Boring, single file parades every week won’t matter whether its Saturday, Sunday or even Wednesday night. People won’t watch anyway, especially when there are only 5 cars are talked about the entire race. Does anyone down in the offices of Daytona see that their product on the track is not good right now.

I sure hope they are addressing this with the new car.

11/01/2012 03:05 PM

Sorry, Bowyer is not outrunning Kahne … look at the two’s chase average as Kasey has caught him by 7 points