The Frontstretch: That Couldn't Have Been Team Orders, Could It? by S.D. Grady -- Sunday September 20, 2009

Go to site navigation Go to article

That Couldn't Have Been Team Orders, Could It?

S.D. Grady · Sunday September 20, 2009


During the closing laps of the Camping World 200, one thing was clear: Harvick and Hornaday were not too happy with each other. Well, yes, they had been trading paint for the last 50 laps; that alone could explain the rubbin’ and bumpin’ during caution laps, especially for these two committed competitors.

But what if it was more?

Turns out it was. Harvick had his crew chief communicate to the No. 33 team that he would like Hornaday to move over so he could pass and have a go at the No. 51 driven by Kyle Busch. Harvick had fresher tires, while by the end of the race Hornaday’s would be nearly 150 laps old, too worn to likely catch the No. 51. And Harvick had made successful runs for the lead earlier in the race, while the No. 33 seemed to be fading during the final 50 miles. It even sounds like a reasonable request, when you look at just those facts.

However, somewhere in the execution of this request, something went awry.

Hornaday said no. He wouldn’t give. He blocked. He raced hard. In doing so, he allowed the No. 51 to widen his lead. Harvick tried rubbing Hornaday to get his way… all for nothing.

After a late-race tangle with points rival Matt Crafton left the No. 33 team on edge entering New Hampshire, Ron Hornaday was constantly looking over his shoulder to protect his championship lead. But who would have guessed the biggest driver to be concerned about was none other than his owner and teammate Kevin Harvick?

So, Harvick reacted as you might expect … he got pissed. So mad, in fact, that as soon as the checkers flew over the No. 51, Harvick parked his truck on pit lane, hopped out of his ride, and rushed to Hornaday’s window to have some words. Words? What kind of words?

Unfortunately, no microphone was there to catch the gist of the suppressed growling. What happened next, though, ignited the conspiracy theorist in me.

With his usual sunny smile, third place Harvick told the media, when asked what all the hoopla was about: “That was a result of poor communication with a crew chief and spotter. I just didn’t want to get loose under him.” (That’s it…throw the staff under the bus.)

Meanwhile, second place Hornaday climbed from his truck and shrugged off the whole thing. “I pinched him down. I didn’t realize he was that loose…it was just racing.”

Ever hear a company line issued by two people at the same time?

Let’s look a second time at the facts. Harvick told his employee to move over so the boss could win. The employee did not honor the “request.” Harvick got angry and proceeded to throw a tantrum on the radio. And then he realized what he just did…he issued team orders. Time for damage control.

So after Kevin and Ron toed the company line for the cameras, a company meeting was called in one of the KHI haulers…and nothing more was heard.

There are no team orders in NASCAR…right?

In this day and age of three and four-car teams, that answer has been becoming more and more uncertain. Almost to a person, all the Chasers admitted that allowing a team member to lead a lap or other “gentlemanly conduct” was expected. How about allowing somebody to win a race? Nobody wanted to really commit to an answer on that one. Sort of a universal, “Please don’t make me answer.”

But those orders, like this one that will be quickly buried under six feet of unified denial, have no place in our sport…I don’t care how much money, prestige or power is on the line.

Now, I can understand why Harvick made the request he did. He wanted to win. It just didn’t cross his mind at that instant that Hornaday was seeking his third victory in a row at New Hampshire or that Hornaday was really rather busy maintaining his lead in the Truck Series championship. Or even that Hornaday had a real chance to win if Kyle Busch ran out of gas in the last few laps…a definite possibility.

Harvick forgot the bigger picture. Harvick thought only of himself.

Yet for all the drama and closed-door discussions this little misplaced communication will result in, we did learn one thing: Maybe team orders are issued, but that doesn’t mean they will be executed.

Thank God!

Ron Hornaday… you rock!

Contact S.D. Grady

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Racing to the Point: NASCAR Has Its Own Heartbreak Kid
Beyond the Cockpit: Brittany Force, the Fastest Force
Voices from the Cheap Seats: Advertising for Dummies
Who’s Hot / Who’s Not in Sprint Cup: Off Week-Richmond Edition
Couch Potato Tuesday: Picking The Best IndyCar On-Air Personalities


©2000 - 2008 S.D. Grady and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

Kevin in SoCal
09/20/2009 03:38 AM

Yes, Kevin Harvick should be ashamed of himself and more power to Ron Hornaday for holding his line. Harvick should have done his best to keep Matt Crafton behind him, and not pass Ron and take away points from him. Ron is running for the championship, and as we saw last year, he lost it by a handful of points due to him moving over for a teammate to win the race at Atlanta. Something the announcers brought up several times, thank you guys! Last year I was rooting for Johnny Benson because he had not won a championship before. This year I am rooting for Ron Hornday.

"The Turnip"
09/20/2009 06:53 AM

Hey, F-1 has nothing on NA$CRAP!

But what do you expect from that non-performer Harvick?

(like my new nic?)


After all, that’s what NA$CRAP thinks of it’s fans!

The Turnip
09/20/2009 06:56 AM

(not quite sure what happened on the previous)

Hey, F-1 has nothing on NA$CRAP!

But what do you expect from that non-performer Harvick?

(like my new nic?)


After all, that’s what NA$CRAP thinks of it’s fans!

09/20/2009 11:29 AM

I think I read quite awhile ago on some NASCAR news site that Jack Roush said his rule is that in most of the race he’s on board with letting someone lead a lap for points or whatever, but in the final laps he said it’s every man for himself and he doesn’t issue team orders or get involved. I hope that is true, it would confirm my respect for Jack and his teams.

09/20/2009 12:38 PM

It’s the fact that it was an ORDER that bothers me. Harvick DID have the faster truck in general for most of the race… But to move OVER? That’s ridiculous. Especially considering he’s part time and Hornaday is racing for a title. If Hornaday had had a poor truck, I could understand him saying “just gimme some room and I’ll go on ahead” … But it was clear in those last few laps that Hornaday’s truck was just about as good as Harvick’s and he really couldn’t pass him anyway.

I expect this bullshit out of F1 but not here—lame.

This is making me more and more of a fan of Thorsport and Crafton/Sauter every day.

09/21/2009 01:42 PM

Team orders only mean something if they’re followed.

All this episode proves is that there’s at least one team out there where team orders are meaningless… if Hornaday moved over, then you’d have a story.

09/21/2009 03:05 PM

What you saw and heard during the truck race was nothing but theater. no way was Harvick going to pass Hornaday. he was there to block, which he did on the restart with 7 to go.

Contact S.D. Grady