The Frontstretch: Bowles-Eye View: Does Safety Have Its Limits? by Thomas Bowles -- Monday March 13, 2006

Go to site navigation Go to article

Bowles-Eye View: Does Safety Have Its Limits?

Thomas Bowles · Monday March 13, 2006

 

For the third straight race this season, a Nextel Cup event went beyond its scheduled distance on Sunday, as the race in Vegas produced another green-white-checkered finish. Certainly, no one would argue with the outcome"¦those last two laps were easily the most exciting of what had been a mediocre race at best to that point, as Jimmie Johnson initiated and ultimately won a thrilling duel to the finish with Matt Kenseth.

However, for the second straight week, the caution to set up the race to the finish came out of a judgment call from NASCAR’s race control. Two weeks ago at California, Scott Wimmer’s blown engine on the front straightaway caused the yellow flag to fly with just a handful of laps remaining; this week, it was debris from Kenny Wallace’s car that landed towards the end of the back straightaway that caused a late yellow flag to fly (this appeared to cause the final caution, NOT Tony Stewart’s flat tire).

Now, the point of a yellow flag, at least to me, is to protect the drivers from a hazard on the track that could ultimately interfere with the safety of not only themselves, but the other drivers and fans surrounding them. Certainly, in the case of a crash on the track or an incident where a car is stopped in the racing groove, unable to get to pit road, these types of situations are no-brainers to throw the yellow. But in the last two situations we’ve seen, it’s a much tougher situation to call"¦certainly, NASCAR doesn’t want to appear weak on safety. But is a blown engine out of the groove and a small piece of metal on the backstretch with four laps left really interfering with the safety of its drivers?

In both cases, the risk to drivers and fans alike was minimal. Certainly, you never want the risk for injury to be raised in ANY case. But if that risk is indeed minimal"¦where do you draw the line on throwing that flag?

The thing is, when you look long and hard enough at any 1.5-mile piece of pavement, you’re going to find debris on the race track. Tires get cut on the track all the time because of debris NASCAR never sees, unforeseen obstacles race drivers can’t predict. With all the beating and banging that goes on with race cars during a typical 400-mile race, it would be a bad thing NOT to end up with debris all over the place. It’s what comes of racing hard, side-by-side, for position.

With that said, certainly everything NASCAR does in the interests of safety should be applauded. No one wants to see anyone get hurt. But cautions in the last 10 laps can completely change the outcome of a race, and, if not called correctly, unfairly hand a win to someone that never would have had a chance at Victory Lane in the first place.

If you feel that piece of debris on the track wasn’t big enough to call out the dogs yesterday, well, then we’ve got a perfect example of yellow flag gone wrong. Sure, Jimmie Johnson beat Matt Kenseth fair and square to the finish line"¦but he would never have gotten his chance to be successful without that final caution for debris on the track. If that race goes green all the way, Kenseth wins easily, and Scott Riggs and Dale Earnhardt, Jr., who got hit with pit road speed penalties while pitting for new tires for the green-white-checkered finish, would instead be credited with the Top 15 finishes they deserved for their strong runs all day.

Of course, there’s never a thing as too much safety when drivers are involved. But doesn’t every driver accept the fact that racing is inherently unsafe when they step in that race car every Sunday? And doesn’t bunching up 30-40 hungry drivers for a green-white-checkered finish put everyone in greater danger for a bad ending than a small piece of debris sitting on the back straightaway?

Debate on that question is certainly gaining steam"¦and with all the debris and oil cautions popping up the last couple of years that were never seen before in an era where NASCAR was a little more lax on safety, to say the least, it’s about time the sport’s officiating body began figuring out when and where such a line with safety needs to be drawn. For as we’ve all learned, the last thing a sport with fledgling credibility needs is weekly controversy surrounding a common but necessary officiating call.

NEW YEAR? NEW NEWSLETTER. LOOKING FOR THE INFO YOU NEED ABOUT NASCAR IN 2013 – SENT RIGHT TO YOUR EMAIL INBOX?
Well, you’ve come to the right place. The Frontstretch Newsletter gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up and get all the information you need. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

 

©2000 - 2008 Thomas Bowles and Frontstetch.com. Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

George
03/13/2006 07:54 AM
permalink

NASCAR is affecting the outcome of races on purpose! They are the NEW WWF! I can’t believe you writers will ignore these signs. NASCAR is only about the money of sponsors now….The open wheel cars are starting to look pretty good!

M. B. Voelker
03/13/2006 08:36 AM
permalink

Oil on the track is no minor issue—Remember Kasey Kahne at Dover in what ought to have been his first win taking a hard hit from those unforgiving, steel walls due to a slow yellow after an engine failure?

Calling a caution for big pieces of sheet metal flying off a car is also a no-brainer.

IMO, it doesn’t matter what lap of the race it is—if you’d call a caution for that sort of debris on lap 20, call it on lap 495 as well.

Remember, these cars are fragile and even a spring rubber can punch a hole in their thin skins when kicked up and thrown by another car.

al
03/13/2006 12:23 PM
permalink

The size of the metal from the left front fender of Kenny’s car was not small from the angles I saw. About a third of the fender was ripped off. NASCAR’s call was appropriate for the circumstance. Try hitting that piece of metal at 150 mph and you will definitely have a bad scene happen.

Donald R Anderson
03/13/2006 05:47 PM
permalink

Everyone, do this for me in the future. As the race is winding down, check to see what time the race is scheduled to end. If the race is running “ahead of schedule”, count on a yellow for green/white finish. If the race is running late, you won`t see a yellow unless it is catastopic incident. Then you decide.

Marc
03/13/2006 09:19 PM
permalink

”... and a small piece of metal on the backstretch with four laps left really interfering with the safety of its drivers?”

A piece of sheet metal the size of the computer table you wrote this piece on isn’t large enough?

Just what size in your mind would be appropriate?

Geesh, gimme a break!

 

Contact Tom Bowles

Recent articles from Tom Bowles:

Did You Notice? ... NASCAR's Gamble, New Talent And Drivers To Watch
Did You Notice? ... The Land Of The Same Opportunities
Did You Notice? ... The Underdogs Deserve A Shot, Too
Did You Notice? ... 2013 Driver Report Cards
Did You Notice? ... The Evolution Of An Ending, Double Duty's Drought And Charlotte Controversy

If you want to know more about Tom Bowles or to view all of his articles here at the Frontstretch, check out his archive and bio page.

Want even more Tom Bowles? Check out Tom's archive at SI.com.