The Frontstretch: Fact Or Fiction: Calming Down Montoya, Vickers' Free Pass, And Kyle Busch's Mistake by Thomas Bowles -- Tuesday May 10, 2011

Go to site navigation Go to article

Connect with Tom!

Darlington left us with plenty to chew on during what’s bound to be one of the biggest news weeks of the NASCAR season. What should we make of some of these major storylines going forward? Time to play a little Fact or Fiction and prognosticate…

FACT: Drivers Need To Take Matters With Juan Pablo Montoya Into Their Own Hands

Lost amidst the hubbub of Darlington’s Kyle Busch – Kevin Harvick scuffle was a compelling undercard: Juan Pablo Montoya vs. The World. A mere 24 hours after a supposed scuffle with Ryan Newman as NASCAR met with both to make peace, Montoya “had at it” on the racetrack again, this time spinning Jimmie Johnson after the two made contact inside the tight confines of Darlington’s “Track Too Tough To Tame.” While the No. 42 kept it straight, the No. 48 hit the apron as Johnson went from potential contender to hurting pup the rest of the race.

Juan Pablo Montoya has never once in his stock car career shied away from contact on the track, but unlike many drivers before him he’s gotten a pass for his conduct.

To Montoya’s credit, he tried to at least attempt an “I’m sorry” this time, one that prompted this exchange from crew chief Chad Knaus to Johnson: “I can tell you right now he’s a way better driver than that. There’s no apology there.” However, the Lowe’s Chevrolet chose to use their heads, not the bumper, in keeping clear of the Colombian perpetrator rather than using him as “Target” practice the rest of the night.

While doing so, Mr. Five-Time epitomized the class that’s defined his racing career, as many other Montoya victims have done through the years. But at this point, I have to sit and wonder…is class the right way to handle things? Montoya has ticked off a longer list of people in the garage area than any other driver, from hotheads (Kevin Harvick, Watkins Glen 2007) to young kids (Joey Logano, Homestead 2010) to even his current teammate (Jamie McMurray was a victim while racing for Roush Fenway). For all his NASCAR life, Montoya’s style has been defined as controlled aggression on a good day, catastrophic bulldozer on a bad one, unafraid to wreck friends or enemies all in the name of gaining a position.

During the old days, NASCAR drivers took such matters into their own hands and set someone straight. Anyone else believe that if Dale Earnhardt was still around, this guy would have “had his cage rattled” multiple times in a three-month period oh, about four years ago? Like him or not, it’s not like Montoya’s winning races: the man’s only made the Chase once during four years in the sport. More often than not, he’s simply wrecking someone with little to no reward, tearing up racecars for no other reason than impatience. But like the bully that no one stands up to, other than Newman (and Logano at Homestead) people seem unwilling to provide Montoya with the consequences necessary to stop. And considering NASCAR’s current policy, well; if a guy gets flipped and there’s nothing more than probation, I wouldn’t expect suspensions and fines to set Montoya straight.

So what do you do? I’m not saying spinning someone into the wall is always the answer. I’m just saying nothing else has worked; so perhaps a driver actually needs to pull an eye for an eye more frequently? If I ended up paying the price after I wrecked someone, after awhile I might not wreck people. Perhaps Montoya needs to be treated in similar fashion.

FICTION: Kyle Busch Couldn’t Avoid A Conflict With Kevin Harvick

Let’s not spew our Kevin Harvick – Kyle Busch opinions quite yet; they’re already all over the Internet before penalties have even been announced. But I have to laugh at an explanation Kyle gave after the race, defending his decision to run from Harvick by turning an unmanned No. 29 Budweiser Chevrolet into the pit wall. Here’s a transcript:

“I was just going to sit there, not worry about it and let [Harvick] cool his head for a second,” Busch explained. “Let him figure out that we just need to go back to the garage area. Instead of him doing that, he wanted to get out of his car and wanted to fight. When I saw him getting out of his car, I knew it wasn’t going to be a good situation. My choices were limited: I was either going to get punched in the face and then wait for Harvick to get back in his car, or just drive through his car and push it out of the way so I could get out of there and try not to get hit or anything like that. I made a judgment call there and it wasn’t one of the best choices that I had, but I pushed his car out of the way on pit road and unfortunately there [were] men walking down pit road. I hate it that somebody could have gotten hurt, but I was just trying to get away from it and get back to my hauler and go on with my own business.”

OK, so with that I went back and watched a YouTube clip to see what type of danger, exactly Kyle was in. Here’s what I found: at least 36 seconds of time that elapsed from when both cars stopped on pit road to Harvick getting out. And that’s being generous; in all likelihood, Busch had a full minute to mull over options before his rival came storming towards the window net.

Now, pure common sense tells you the second Harvick’s getting out of the car, he’s making a beeline for the No. 18 Toyota. So it’s not like Busch was “confused” over what would happen, and consider the time that elapsed in between; honestly, in 36 seconds my 85-year-old grandma could get unhooked and exit the car under pressure. If Busch’s transmission was supposedly shot, limiting his options, why didn’t he just shut off the engine, climb out and walk to the hauler, fully avoiding confrontation? In that situation, the worst thing you can do is leave yourself vulnerable; after all, a driver confined to his cockpit is virtually defenseless against a heavyweight punch. Didn’t Kyle learn from older brother Kurt and Jimmy Spencer?
Instead, what Busch chose is to freeze, wait until it was too late to flee, then put others in harm’s way by spinning out Harvick’s car. And that’s why if he gets fined, for that reason alone I do understand. With a crash helmet on, how hard was he going to get hit anyway?

FACT: 2011 For Brian Vickers Should Be A Free Pass

This week marks the one-year anniversary of Vickers’ Sprint Cup leave-of-absence, life-changing blood clots that altered this 27-year-old’s outlook on life. For a time, it looked like he might never return to racing, but heart surgery, blood thinners, and a determined recovery put him back in the car this February at Daytona. Refreshed and ready for a second chance at racing, Vickers has put his heart and soul into making it work.

But while he may be 100 percent focused, inside the car he’s yet to produce top-tier results. At 29th in points, Vickers has yet to lead a lap, has finished on the lead lap only twice and wrecked in half his 10 starts this season. While luck has been a factor, some of the incidents have been self-inflicted – Darlington’s Saturday night sardine-can wreck was the latest example, also caused by Vickers’ car fading to midpack after running as high as fifth early on. Despite three top-10 finishes, the Red Bull No. 83 has yet to flash consistent speed, especially on the intermediates he terrorized in ’09 during a surprise summer run into the Chase.

Surely, the struggles have put the pending free agent’s future in question. But if you’re Red Bull, and if you’re Vickers, how could you not give this partnership another year? Consider the “lame duck” status of Vickers’ teammate, Kasey Kahne, whose arrival and near-immediate departure makes it difficult to build a foundation for long-term success. And while Vickers appears healthier than ever, it takes time to shake off the rust; how would you be after leaving your job for six months due to a life-threatening illness? Athletes with an ACL tear often say the first season back, they’re simply trying to get into a rhythm and don’t feel 100 percent until the 18-24 month point. Why wouldn’t it be the same for Vickers here?

Red Bull has a history of impatience (see Speed, Scott and Allmendinger, A.J.) and with Cole Whitt waiting in the wings, you never know what moves they’ll make. But after all both sides have done together, in this current NASCAR environment it would be silly for either to take a risk and leave before they know what the long-term future really holds for them.

FICTION: Regan Smith Will Make The Chase

Look, as was written yesterday Regan Smith’s victory is a great story for him, for NASCAR, and the underdog team he’s been driving for, Furniture Row Racing. Expect this victory to lift them up a notch, leaving the No. 78 car competing for top-10 finishes each week instead of top-20s.

But the Chase? Let’s not get carried away. Even with the victory, Smith stands 27th in points, 29 behind the 20th-place cutoff of Martin Truex, Jr. to be considered for a wild card slot. And do you really think 20th place with one win is going to get it done? Jeff Gordon, currently a wild card Chaser has a victory in hand and is likely to get one, possibly two more. Drivers like Denny Hamlin (Pocono), Mark Martin (Dover), Greg Biffle (Michigan) and Kasey Kahne (everywhere lately) are outside the top 10 in points and haven’t won yet, putting them in position to snag the wild card with victories in the coming weeks. More than likely, it will take two victories to make a “wild card” happen, and expect those winners to be no lower than 14th or 15th place.

Again, congrats to the No. 78 team; they’ve made great progress in the last three months. But a charge to 15th in the standings? When Smith didn’t even have so much as a top-5 finish until Saturday night? That’s a bit too much of a stretch.

Connect with Tom!

Contact Tom Bowles

Tuesday on the Frontstretch:
Five Points to Ponder: Smaller Crowds, Bigger Fights, Ugly Words Left For NASCAR To Chew On
Who’s Hot / Who’s Not in NASCAR: Darlington-Dover Edition
Who Will Be Sprint Cup’s Next First-Time Winner?
Talking NASCAR TV: Did Darrell Waltrip Go Biased Towards Busch At Darlington?

Southern-Fried Thriller

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Thomas Bowles and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

05/10/2011 06:24 AM

I agree about Kyle’s ‘danger level’. He’s sitting in a car surrounded by his safety seat, wearing a helmet. If he keeps his faceplate down and turns his head, Harvick bruises some knuckles and Kyle’s home free when the officials arrive. Maybe, if he hadn’t pulled up against the bumper of the 29 he wouldn’t have had to push it out of the way. Or, if he hadn’t wrecked a car that only bumped him loose and didn’t wreck him it’s a non issue to begin with.

05/10/2011 08:05 AM

Guess that it all depends on your point of view and who your favorite driver is. This year, Ryan Newman has been hitting everybody on the track. At Talladega, Frontstretch was talking about what a great save Ryan made — well he made that save because he used Montoya’s car to stop his spin, thus ruining Montoya’s race. In previous years, Tony Stewart has hit everybody on the track — Jimmy Johnson has done the same. They all do it. It is ludicrous to say that Montoya does it more than anyone else and that ‘someone needs to take care of him’. Get real, Frontstretch.

05/10/2011 08:06 AM

You call this writing? All you guys have to do be a ‘NASCAR writer’ is praise Jr. or slam the Busch brothers. Not too hard of job other than trying to figure out how to blend the same characters into a new story so it doesn’t seem repetitive.

I disagree with ‘why didn’t he just shut off the engine, climb out and walk to the hauler, fully avoiding confrontation’. Are you stupid? There was no avoiding the confrontation with Harvick sitting in his car waiting to see what was going to happen. Then there was Harvick’s crew members all coming down pit road to just help push the car back, no doubt.

If NASCAR penalizes the drivers, they need to start penalizing the crew members as well.

RCR continues the tradition of hiring drivers that can dish it out but can’t take it. If Harvick is such a bad-a$$, let’s see him go after Newman or Stewart, or someone else that will put his little excrement-eating grin into the asphalt.

05/10/2011 08:42 AM

Here is a novel idea. Busch should have manned up, got out of his car and, if it came to it, fought the battle with his fists. I am so sick of all this “boys have at it” and NASCAR is “going back to its roots”. Back in the day these altercations were settled with fists, threat with tire irons, and man to man confrontation. Al l of this running cars and tearing up equipment is a joke. Busch tried to run like a girl and he is being called “The new intimidator?” What a joke. what a wuss.

05/10/2011 08:43 AM

@RickP- Well said my friend. I don’t think getting out of his car would have been in Kyle’s best interest. Also, if Harvick had driven back to his hauler, none of this would have happened. So, I say it is as much His fault as it is Kyle’s that the two of them had to go to the NASCAR trailer.

05/10/2011 01:36 PM

Kyle could have easily avoided a conflict with Harvick… if you don’t hook a guy’s car in traffic, he won’t want to punch you in the face.

05/10/2011 03:07 PM

Please never compare the no class busch to Earnhardt…& Run away would not have been his solution.. & hooking the guy on purpose after the yellow …hmm Yellow kinda fits this…Both dumber 1 way dumber

05/10/2011 04:19 PM

Where were the nascar officals? If Harvick sit there for 35 seconds before climbing out of his car, where were the nascar officals, they knew something was going to happen and choose to allow it and then dish out penalties.

05/10/2011 05:03 PM

So pit-road during any normal caution is LESS dangerous than what KB did? KB haters will think of anything to get him off the track. I can’t stand these types of stories. KH threw a punch. That is just completely unacceptable! Any other sport and he’d be suspended. Not Nascar though, the beer drinkin’ fans gotta see some action or else!

05/10/2011 11:54 PM

Jimmy Spenser nows pushes the company line so hard, it is painful to watch. Can you really believe that if Kyle had pulled the little hook on Jimmy S., Jimmy would be ok with that? NASCAR wants them to have at it – well don’t be surprised when they actually do. NASCAR will be encouraging more of these scuffles, it makes for good promo footage. Watch how many times they reshow Kyle-Kevin in the coming weeks.

05/11/2011 02:07 PM

JJ pushed up right in front of Montoya then hit the brakes early going into the turn. Montoya locked his brakes trying to stop and you can clearly see that the drivers behind him stacked up. Your calling that purposefully wrecking JJ?

old farmer
05/11/2011 03:10 PM

1. Right on, RickP!

2. Montoya is a bull in a china shop—hit everyone else’s stuff, break it, and make excuses.


Contact Tom Bowles

Recent articles from Tom Bowles:

Did You Notice? ... Breaking Down A Sprint Cup Season Eight Races In
Did You Notice? ... Drivers Still Make A Difference... But Silly Cautions Don't
Did You Notice? ... NASCAR's Free Agent Lynchpin, Uncomfortable Reality And Gambling
Did You Notice? ... Toyota Trouble, Limping Into Action And Testing The Waters
Did You Notice? ... Keep On Asking, And You Will Receive A Qualifying Sigh Of Relief

If you want to know more about Tom Bowles or to view all of his articles here at the Frontstretch, check out his archive and bio page.

Want even more Tom Bowles? Check out Tom's archive at