The Frontstretch: Don't Lynch David For Goliath: What Martinsville’s NASCAR Finish Taught Us by Thomas Bowles -- Tuesday April 3, 2012

Go to site navigation Go to article

As the sun rises over NASCAR’s first “off week,” David Reutimann remains shrouded in darkness after Martinsville. The Tommy Baldwin Racing driver, whose broken steering linkage caused a caution with less than three laps to go, committed the “cardinal sin” of any backmarker: changed the course of a race’s outcome. By stopping on the track, after several attempts to continue racing with a clearly crippled Chevrolet, the insistence to “keep going,” trying to limp to the finish caused major consequences. The yellow flag that followed set up a wild restart which robbed the day’s two dominant cars, Jeff Gordon and Jimmie Johnson, of the victory while turning the green-white-checkered finish into a short track Demolition Derby.

David Reutimann, fired from his Aaron’s ride at the end of last season is trying hard to stay afloat in NASCAR with small-time Tommy Baldwin Racing. But did his actions Sunday, all in the name of keeping his car inside the top 35 in owner points cross a line?

After the race, listening to driver quotes you’d think the garage was ready to march on Reutimann’s hauler, brand the poor man with a Scarlet Letter and be done with it. “I just don’t know what the No. 10 was thinking,” said Dale Earnhardt, Jr. “Hell, how many laps down are you? Get out of the race.” Added Brad Keselowski: “I think we’re all really, really frustrated with that guy.” Some have even indicated Baldwin should fire his driver, whose car now sits outside the top 35 in owner points and must qualify on speed at the April 14th race in Texas.

But in the midst of the Reutimann Riot, everyone needs to stop and ask himself or herself a simple question: Why? Why was the No. 10 chugging to the finish line? Simple: because for this car, every lap counted. Every position made a difference due to NASCAR’s top-35 rule, which locks in 35 of 43 spots on the grid prior to each race based on where they are in owner points. If Reutimann had finished the event, he would have vaulted over teammate Dave Blaney and earned one extra point, the difference between 35th and 36th. That would have let the Baldwin/Reutimann pair breathe easy instead of sweating out Texas with one of the larger entry lists expected this season.

Now, Danica Patrick also drives the “No. 10 car,” with her equipment coming from Stewart-Haas Racing as part of a ten-race, limited schedule. Some have blamed Patrick’s presence in the car for the whole mess, “forcing” this team to stay out but the aggression really comes down to Baldwin and Reutimann – nothing more. What, you really think Patrick is ordering from the pit box for this team to keep going so she can be “locked into” the field at Darlington on May 12th? How many cars are attempting that race… 44? People differ on the degree of her talent, but the woman has had no problems running a NASCAR stock car for a lap. I think chances are high, in top-tier equipment she can beat one car to make the field if necessary.

No, the more likely scenario, if this Baldwin/Reutimann pairing continues to struggle is that Stewart-Haas ownership no longer sees the benefit of providing financial support in this “co-op” effort to keep a car number inside the top 35. If Ms. Patrick has to qualify on speed anyways, every time she hops in their car what’s the point? It’s a bad business decision; they’re wasting money. So Stewart could pull the plug, Baldwin would lose cash and then be forced to either scale back to one car or start and park the second team he’s tried for years to fully establish. So yeah, of course Reutimann and Baldwin are going to push it for some extra laps, nearly wrecking the field with a broken steering linkage; they’re fighting for survival. Don’t blame them for that.

The irony of the situation is Reutimann represents the aggression NASCAR wants, in the wrong place. With driver conservatism all the rage this season, most teams recognizing that if they can’t win, “hanging out” inside the top 20 in points is just fine until midsummer processional parades like Fontana are the norm and not the exception. Even at Martinsville, several who attended told me it was good, not great from the stands; by far, Sunday was the “least good” (hard to have a bad race at Martinsville) race they’d seen there until the fateful caution flag. Contact, not to be confused with crashes, was minimized at times because drivers felt no sense of urgency to move through the field. Running 10th? Don’t have a winning car? Alright, it’s lap 200, I’m just going to stay here and ride for 200 laps. And if I finish 10th? Great. That’s plenty of points to propel me into the playoff chase. Turns out “rubbing is racin’” only if drivers are given a reason to turn up the wick.

The late-race caution kept Jeff Gordon and Alan Gustafson winless in 2012, a puzzling slump that’s left the driver of the No. 24 Chevy 21st in driver points.

In fact, only in the case of Jimmie Johnson and Jeff Gordon, whose battle for the victory was shaping up to be a beauty did we have the aggression NASCAR fans craved down the stretch. But there was a sense of urgency in both cases. For Johnson, he’s eager to prove that Daytona pre-race inspection was a fluke, faulty decisions firing up the five-time champ as he searches for a sixth. Meanwhile, Gordon sits 21st in points, his team looking more like the Bad News Bears lately instead of the once-flagship car that captured four championships for HMS. A win, which would also have been Hendrick’s 200th rights the ship and relaxes the DuPont Chevy crew. It also likely earns him a “wild card” if the team can just sneak inside the points top 20 (much easier than climbing all the way up to 10th).

You could argue Dale Earnhardt, Jr., who finished third also had his own incentive: a winless streak approaching four years. But for the rest, points and not pushing it were on the agenda until Reutimann’s caution caused the cocaine-style drug any race car driver, at that level just can’t ignore: a green-white-checkered finish, with the leaders in front of them on old tires. All of a sudden, ten drivers smelled victory and were “woken up” from processional slumber; the aggression that followed was a natural reaction no “race for points” speech could stop. The resulting crash on the restart, which killed Johnson and Gordon’s chances, was only surprising because of the upset winner it produced.

In many ways, NASCAR was dealt a huge favor by the whole Reutimann mess. It got a surprise victor, Ryan Newman, along with a phenomenal finish that will be talked about long into the “off week.” Johnson remains winless, keeping the team actually pushing for a “breathe easy” Chase victory before choosing to enter “regular season testing mode.” Ditto for Gordon, whose problems aren’t as serious as it looks on paper but must push for a win in the next month or two to keep from building stress. Considering how many superstars are kicking back, content to just ride around during races right now the sport needs all the top-level aggression it can get.

It’s funny what a difference a week makes. In many ways, if Reutimann had stopped on Lap 120 of the race at Fontana, just before the rains NASCAR and drivers would have been applauding him; perhaps an actual competition rather than a “let’s just get out of here” mentality would have broken out. Circumstances, in this case dictated the anger; but doesn’t random luck change the course of races all the time? Should people no longer stretch it on fuel mileage because of the fear of running out, then stopping on the track with two laps left to create a green-white-checkered finish? That’s just silly.

No, the real trick for NASCAR is twofold. One: fix the growing financial malfunctioning within its Sprint Cup world so that teams like Baldwin don’t have to play desperate, limping around with a broken car because a partnership with a rich team is the only thing keeping them alive. Two: find a way to filter Reutimann’s spirit, running hard to finish every lap into the rest of the 43-car grid. Maybe it’s a large monetary bonus for halfway. Maybe it’s redistributing the purse so there’s plenty more cash earned for top-5 finishes. Or you could even restructure how points are distributed in-race.

The solution, like many in modern-day NASCAR remains elusive. But I do know this much: David Reutimann shouldn’t be lynched for a problem he didn’t create.

Connect with Tom!

Contact Tom Bowles

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Did You Notice? … A Return To Richmond, Post-Spingate And Quick Hits
NASCAR Mailbox: A ‘Normal’ Saturday And A Valuable Lesson
Beyond the Cockpit: Tony ‘The Sarge’ Schumacher
Open Wheel Wednesday: Controversial Moves, Long Beach Crowds, and Being a Fuddy Duddy
The Frontstretch Five: Pleasant Surprises of 2014 So Far
IndyCar Driver Profile: Takuma Sato
Beyond the Cockpit: Tommy Baldwin on Owning His Team, Hall of Fame and the Number Seven


©2000 - 2008 Thomas Bowles and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

04/03/2012 11:16 AM

I laugh at this whole mess. The top 35 and chase have made once great race tracks boring as drivers ride around for a great points day.

I applaud Bowyer going for the win instead of being “patient” for the benefit of Gordon and Johnson.

It was about the only excitement for the day.

04/03/2012 11:38 AM

You have to remember that there are two races going on at a NASCAR event: the race to win the race and the race to stay in the top 35. The 10 car should have no blame for what he was trying to do.

04/03/2012 12:35 PM

Yup, I don’t blame Reutie in the slightest, it was Baldwin’s call, and you can’t really blame him either, it’s NASCAR’s stupid top 35 rule that’s the reason for crippled cars trying to for every spot they can.

Kevin in SoCal
04/03/2012 12:54 PM

I do blame Reutimann and Baldwin, as I said yesterday in Matt’s column. A broken car, a black flag from NASCAR, and he still passed pit road several times instead of pulling in to fix the problem. Thats what I blame them for. In my opinion, Johnson’s problem at Fontana was different because it was under caution, and he was on the apron, maintaining caution speed. Reutimann was slow for several laps, under green, and other drivers had to swerve around him.

04/03/2012 04:15 PM

Absolutely not the fault of anyone on the TBR team!
This was three of NASCAR’s decisions that created this unholy mess. There was the top 35 rule, then the pampering and protection of the savior princess, then the stupid points selling that NASCAR allows, that all came together with the wrong people catching the blame instead of NASCAR! Had only one of those ingredients been missing this mess would have been avoided.

04/03/2012 04:27 PM

I don’t watch anymore, just read about it a few days later. Real racing has left the building and is not coming back.

04/03/2012 06:00 PM

i think all drivers who run their mouth about reutimann should say sorry he just did what any driver would u should not say anything untill u know hole story and if they had to go through what he is i dout if they would make it it would b a mwr driver who would run his mouth the most

04/03/2012 11:09 PM

nc1fish, I agree with you, I read it on frontstretch. What the heck a Henderick car won. Just not the car that was in front all day. Hendrick has 6 or more cars plus the part time car of Danica Patrick that had points bought for her to give her a free run. NASCAR rules are never fair. Money talks and Rick Hendrick has plenty of it.

bud sudz
04/03/2012 11:12 PM

@Kevin—unless they’ve changed the rule, a team gets 3 laps to adhere to the black flag (then the team’s car is no longer scored) At the end of the race, where every point is critical, facing a timely repair, do you really blame Reutimann for taking full advantage of the rule?

For that matter, I’ve never understood why teams with severely damaged race cars do not continue to work on them during a red flag period. (The NASCAR Short Track rule is a one-lap penalty for violation of this rule). Assuming it is the same for the touring series, a one-lap penalty is often better than the time it will take to repair the car once racing resumes.

04/04/2012 11:56 AM

All kidding aside folks, I hope Jr. Johnson has a speedy recovery.Best wishes Jr.


Contact Tom Bowles

Recent articles from Tom Bowles:

Did You Notice? ... A Return To Richmond, Post-Spingate And Quick Hits
Did You Notice? ... Breaking Down A Sprint Cup Season Eight Races In
Did You Notice? ... Drivers Still Make A Difference... But Silly Cautions Don't
Did You Notice? ... NASCAR's Free Agent Lynchpin, Uncomfortable Reality And Gambling
Did You Notice? ... Toyota Trouble, Limping Into Action And Testing The Waters

If you want to know more about Tom Bowles or to view all of his articles here at the Frontstretch, check out his archive and bio page.

Want even more Tom Bowles? Check out Tom's archive at