The Frontstretch: NASCAR Overtime Running On Empty by Thomas Bowles -- Sunday July 16, 2006

Go to site navigation Go to article

NASCAR Overtime Running On Empty

Bowles - Eye View · Thomas Bowles · Sunday July 16, 2006


On another beautiful Sunday afternoon in New England, the stands at New Hampshire International Speedway were packed with over 100,000 diehard NASCAR fans. With their devotion to the sport unquestioned, men and women of all ages brought their wallets as well as their loyalties to the track, swamping the souvenir stands all day long to buy everything from Ryan Newman pajama pants to Dale Earnhardt, Jr. beer mugs. Just staring out into the crowd, you could see hundreds of items bought in just a matter of a few minutes.

Yet, with all the different things on sale at the track, there was one item in the garage area that teams couldn't find enough of when it counted the most: gasoline.

For the second time in as many races, a Nextel Cup race was decided with a green-white-checkered finish, extending the race past its scheduled distance and, in doing so, robbing several drivers of good finishes by running them out of gas during those extra laps. Last week at Chicagoland, the late race tango between Matt Kenseth and Jeff Gordon made Tony Stewart an innocent victim, with the extra 3 laps that caution added to the race pumping every last drop of fuel out of the Home Depot Chevrolet. Heading towards a near certain Top 5 finish, Stewart instead found himself coasting his way home to 32nd, 100 points flushed down the toilet with the word "overtime" to thank. His ability to defend his championship, in light of a wreck in New Hampshire, is now in serious jeopardy.

Speaking of this weekend, several more NASCAR faithful were faced with more of the same disappointment. After Clint Bowyer and Brian Vickers wrecked with a scant one and a half laps to go Sunday, the yellow flag was waved to clean up the mess, instituting another "overtime" period when several cars on the race track had gambled on strategy in which they would barely make it to lap 300 with the fuel they had in their tanks. Lap 301 and beyond…that would be anther story altogether. After Michael Waltrip and Travis Kvapil collided under that caution, the race found itself extended an extra eight laps - almost nine full miles. That caused teams like Reed Sorenson, Jeremy Mayfield, Denny Hamlin, and Elliott Sadler - all of whom had spent the majority of the final 100 laps in the Top 10 - to spend the final portion of their races running at half speed on the apron, their gas tanks dry and their chances for a good finish thrown up in smoke.

If you're keeping track at home, that's five teams, at least, who had their days ruined on the race track simply because the race went the extra mile - literally.

Of course, when the green-white-checkered finish was brought into Nextel Cup two years ago, this was exactly the disaster scenario envisioned by its critics. Trying to end a race under green, they claimed, would wreak havoc on teams trying to make an honest strategy call by making it to the end of the race on fuel. Certainly, as a crew chief, in today's day and age you have to accept the possibility that gambling on fuel mileage could backfire in the case of a late crash, as it has the last two weeks.

Is that fair?

I'm not so sure. The problem with the green-white-checkered rule when you're dealing with fuel is simple. As the caution laps pile up and the race continues on, the point at which NASCAR finishes cleaning the track and declares it ready for green flag racing is a judgment call.

Which brings us back to our friends on the track buying souvenirs. There is no negotiation…you buy things for the price listed on the trailer. Everything is black and white…there is no gray area. You pay the money listed on the T-Shirt, the diecast car, the bumper sticker, and you get that item. It's a cut and dry transaction…there is no room for interpretation.

Racing to the finish in the biggest racing series in the world should be the same way. NASCAR should never put itself in a position where a judgment call it makes could be interpreted as deciding the outcome of a race. With this weekend's final caution dragging on for eight laps, who's to say NASCAR didn't clean up a little slower and let the cars run one extra lap because they wanted Elliott Sadler to run out of fuel? Now, does that sound ridiculous? Of course. Do I think that happened? No. But has NASCAR opened themselves up to that type of conspiracy theory by the way they decide a green-white-checkered finish? Absolutely. If someone with the fan base of Dale Earnhardt, Jr. was running up front and run out of gas due to the "overtime" period, you can bet this would have been a bigger issue.

How can this problem be solved? Simple. If a yellow flag happens late in the race that will cause a green-white-checkered finish, NASCAR can red flag the event with 3 laps to go until the track is clear, then run one more lap of caution before having their green-white-checkered. If there are less than three laps to go when the caution comes out, NASCAR can bring the field behind the pace car and red flag the event immediately. If they do that, no one can ever say the sport let a caution run a little longer than it should, to let a certain car run out of fuel or to put someone at a disadvantage. All judgments are taken out of the equation, all rules are consistent and fair.

Then again, fairness hasn't always been NASCAR's strong suit, not as long as those souvenirs keep disappearing off those trailers like hotcakes. Yet its overwhelming popularity should be the exact reason NASCAR should take steps to keep tweaking its rules to perfection; you always need to stay one step ahead of the game, or risk having the sport's momentum run itself out of gas. If they don't think that can happen…they need to ask some of their teams on pit road.

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Racing to the Point: NASCAR Has Its Own Heartbreak Kid
Beyond the Cockpit: Brittany Force, the Fastest Force
Voices from the Cheap Seats: Advertising for Dummies
Who’s Hot / Who’s Not in Sprint Cup: Off Week-Richmond Edition
Couch Potato Tuesday: Picking The Best IndyCar On-Air Personalities


©2000 - 2008 Thomas Bowles and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

07/16/2006 11:29 PM

Good article, but did anyone catch the reason for the caution being so long?! Waltrip exacting revenge on Gordon cost Hamlin several positions, and possibly Sadler. Nascar absolutely needs to stand up to Michael, despite his new team and sideline him for a race. They’ve been side stepping the issue for long enough. Get serious about agressive driving. I’m not talking about Jeff getting Kenseth or Newman on Stewart, they are what they are. But Waltrip smashing himself into Gordon to keep the caution going was insane! Maybe he needed some more TV time, as if TNT didn’t show enough?! If Nascar doesn’t sideline him for next week’s race, forget anything they say about aggressive driving.

M. B. Voelker
07/17/2006 07:42 AM

All the crew chiefs know that a GWC could be in the works. They all have an equal chance to plot their strategy taking the possibility of the GWC into account.

Looks to me like the vast majority of the crew chiefs did it right. What would be unfair would be penalizing the crew chiefs who made the right call and the drivers who are skilled at saving gas by giving away their well-deserved positions to less clever crew chiefs and less skillful drivers.

07/17/2006 09:52 AM

Were the Nascar officials finishing ice cream cones or something? It took way too long to get the last restart in order. The general bumbling around reminded me of the Talladega race that the #24 won that resulted in the GWC. Hey, at least they caught it on TV instead of during a commercial. What a joke.

07/17/2006 12:02 PM

So THAT”S where all those empty seats in the stands were from! Fans were shopping instead of watching the race!

07/17/2006 01:35 PM

A wreck under caution should surely grant a red flag. NASCAR knew teams were gambling, and tried to get the caution laps done as quickly as possible… that is until Waltrip had an anger issue. NASCAR needs to step up penalties for those incidents in the coming weeks, especially those that might cost chase hopefulls like Denny Hamlin and Tony Stewart a bid for the “playoffs”.

J. Meyer
07/17/2006 02:25 PM

Conspiracy theory is BS! I get sick of “if it had been Lil E, or Jeffy, they would have red flagged…”
Either you have GWC or you don’t. If you red flag for every caution under 10 laps then you don’t need GWC.
Because the “Chase” makes it so important to get in the top ten, you will see alot more of this going on.
Fans screamed for GWC a couple of years ago and they got it. GWC is a good thing. The teams just need to plan for it, plain and simple.


Contact Tom Bowles

Recent articles from Tom Bowles:

Did You Notice? ... A Return To Richmond, Post-Spingate And Quick Hits
Did You Notice? ... Breaking Down A Sprint Cup Season Eight Races In
Did You Notice? ... Drivers Still Make A Difference... But Silly Cautions Don't
Did You Notice? ... NASCAR's Free Agent Lynchpin, Uncomfortable Reality And Gambling
Did You Notice? ... Toyota Trouble, Limping Into Action And Testing The Waters

If you want to know more about Tom Bowles or to view all of his articles here at the Frontstretch, check out his archive and bio page.

Want even more Tom Bowles? Check out Tom's archive at