The Frontstretch: Busch & McMurray's Battle of Pretending to Care (Bowles-Eye View) by Thomas Bowles -- Sunday August 14, 2005

Go to site navigation Go to article

Truth be told, this was not the greatest of weeks for the NASCAR faithful. No need to go over Kurt Busch’s shocking announcement to move from Roush to Penske in 2007; it’s been well documented. On the heels of Jamie McMurray’s 2007 departure to Roush, the two signings have started a disturbing trend of drivers attempting to sign with other teams well before their contracts are up. Drivers and owners must now beware, as 2009 or 2010 may no longer mean a thing when a team goes through a bad season in 2006.

But what’s been even more surprising, and borderline immature, is the uncanny ability of grown men to take hurt feelings and hide them behind simple pieces of paper. Suddenly, signatures that took two seconds to sign are being used by hurt owners to pin their drivers in situations they clearly don’t want, when they’ve already asked to leave. It’s almost as if owners are giving their drivers the only punishment they can give for breaking their hearts and tearing their teams in two. Make no mistake, in this age of twentysomething drivers that go a dime a dozen, middle-aged owners are taking their backstabbing “sons” and giving them a harsh lesson in who increased their value from a 10-cent coin to a million-dollar prospect. The question is, whose lives and what teams are they costing with their hurt feelings and broken hearts?

On some level, I’m sure Ganassi himself was a bit surprised some reporters were turning his 2006 driver lineup into some sort of shocking announcement. Ganassi’s been saying for weeks that he was going to pick up Jamie McMurray’s option for next year, and sure enough, he stuck to his word. Jamie’s silent protest was perhaps a futile effort to get Chip to see what he thinks is an awful decision, but those words (or lack of them) fell on deaf ears. The cold reality appeared to have set in by the end of the weekend; it appears more than ever that Mark Martin is resigned to taking over the 6 for one more year, and an emotionally drained Jamie is beginning to wish he looked at those final option years back when he signed that contract as an unknown youngster back in 2002.

And it’s because of who he was when he signed with Ganassi that I understand, on some level, Chip’s resistance to letting Jamie go. Ganassi mortgaged the farm on Jamie when he signed the driver for 2003, turning down experienced veterans like Bobby Hamilton and Ricky Rudd while convincing Texaco a green Busch Series driver with no wins at the time was ready and able to take their Cup program to the next level. Of course, Ganassi was immediately rewarded with that Charlotte victory in October of 2002, with McMurray wheeling Sterling Marlin’s car to the winner’s circle in only his second Cup start. It was Chip who put Jamie on the map, and with his 3 teams struggling all around him, Chip may feel it’s not a wish but an obligation for his best young talent to help him turn things around instead of jumping ship.

And so Roush, on the heels of Chip Ganassi denying him his driver for 2006, has turned around and done the same thing to Roger Penske with Kurt Busch, holding him to his contract for 2007. And on some level, I don’t blame him, either. Roush also takes Busch’s decision as a bit of a slap in the face, and with all the success Busch has enjoyed under the Roush banner, in some sense it certainly is. Roush is the only team Kurt Busch ever drove for in NASCAR’s top three levels, a career that blossomed only half-a-dozen years ago when Jack plucked him from the Southwest and groomed him into a star. Certainly, Jack didn’t create Busch’s talent, but he put up with his at times immature personality, and took great care in putting Kurt with the right people that would ensure the boy would eventually grow into a man, a sometimes reckless racer into an honorable champion. Who knows what would have happened if Roush hadn’t come calling for Busch all those years ago? Chances are both Kurt AND Kyle might still be working to make it big, racing around at local tracks in Vegas.

Still, at some level these owners have to put their egos aside. Yes, Kurt and Jamie shouldn’t be negotiating for 2007 when they should be focusing on 2006. Certainly, what they’ve done can clearly been construed as a backstabbing of the highest order to the teams that made them who they are today. But the bottom line is, keeping them in a “lame duck” situation doesn’t just punish them, it punishes the dozens of cast and crew who work on these cars day in, day out. How can a team rally around a driver they know is leaving for a whole season, especially when the driver’s clearly stated he thinks he can do better somewhere else? How can you put 50 people in a position of catering to a driver when he’s clearly going to be pretending to care? Cause if I was in Jamie or Kurt’s shoes, I wouldn’t give 110%; why should I? Fair or not, I believe I’m being held against my will, and people who are backed into a corner don’t usually perform for those who put them in that position.

I guess part of this whole deal revolves around there being no “stepping stone” teams for young drivers to move through on their way to a top-level team. In the past, there were independent outfits like Junie Donlavey and Bud Moore’s old cars that took young drivers like Schrader, Rudd, Bodine, and others and turned them into contenders worthy for driving for Penske, Hendrick, and Roush. But now we’re in a new age, where the independents are gone and no sponsor can afford to be labeled second-rate. Everyone’s gunning for the top, and as such there is no “stepping stone” for young drivers to get their feet wet in Cup. They’re thrown into the deep end with a top-level team, and if they don’t like it…well they can sign with another “top-level” team, or work their way back into the Busch Series. And because every team has to pretend to be the best nowadays, owners like Ganassi will feel like they’re stabbed in the back by those moves even though their teams have struggled to remain competitive with everyone else’s.

But the battle lines have been drawn, and no compromise appears to be in sight. So what we’re left with is drivers pretending to care. McMurray and Busch spent all weekend trying hard to remind people how much they love their current teams, how much they’re gearing towards future success even though that future is ticking down by the day. But look behind the tired lines on Jamie McMurray’s face and you can clearly see he’s not as motivated. Finally in position to sneak into the Chase, he’s handling it with a subtle type of ho-hum attitude that, to me, states he clearly wants to be somewhere else. And Busch’s first week as a “lame duck” Roush driver ended with a disastrous finish, one that throws him into more of a scramble to make the Chase rather than be comfortably in control of his own destiny. Even Mark Martin, thrown into a position of ultimate loyalty, has begun to spread a reminder of how much he would prefer not to be back full-time, in the face of a cold reality I’m sure on some level he never thought would happen.

No matter what happens the rest of this year and next, it’s certainly a shame it had to come to this with some of NASCAR’s top teams. But hurt feelings and bruised egos shouldn’t put in people in positions where they have to pretend to care. The crews, the media, and most importantly, the fans…will see through it. It’s because of that, most of all, that I hope everyone will come to their senses.

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Championship Caliber? What Does That Even Mean?
Mirror Driving: Winning Vs. Points, Needing a Boost, and The Lady’s Last Dance?
Nuts for Nationwide: The Curious Case of Elliott Sadler
Happiness Is…Arrogance, Less, Next, and the Outdoors
Frontstretch Foto Funnies: It’s Not Gonna Fit…


©2000 - 2008 Thomas Bowles and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

08/15/2005 09:40 AM
I definitely have an opinion about this, and it’s a long one!! I don’t think Ganassi and Roush are being anywhere near immature in keeping their drivers. They are being business men and contracts still mean something to some people. Even if they are doing it to be spiteful, they have the right because they both took big risks signing the relative unknowns and the drivers should be held to the contracts they signed. Particularly Ganassi, who took a Busch Series driver who had never won a race and one that not many cared about, and gave him a chance to be a Cup Series winner and a NASCAR star.
Unlike McMurray, I really believe Kurt Busch when he says he will remain 100% committed to the team if he has to stay. Kurt knows that he can win races and a championship with both teams. He knows he’ll be competitive regardless. I think his team also knows that they have a shot to win back-to-back, and possibly –to back NEXTEL Cup Champions, and that will be enough to keep them strong, motivated and on a winning track. Besides, I don’t think Jimmy Fennig will allow anyone on his team that isn’t 100% committed and 100% ready to win, regardless of whether or not Busch is staying beyond 2006. Busch seems genuinely happy with his team at Roush and I personally don’t think its anything personal. It’s for the money and a change of scenery.
McMurray, on the other hand, is OBVIOUSLY upset and has made no bones about it. He does not want to be there and finds it odd that a team owner would keep a driver that doesn’t want to be there (maybe a hand-in-mouth comment since his future team owner is probably doing the same thing). I think McMurray and team are going to find it harder to remain focused and competitive next season.
And the comment you made about a signature that took two seconds to sign being used to are being used by hurt owners to pin their drivers in situations they clearly don’t want, too bad. They signed a contract. If they aren’t held to their contracts, then pretty soon everybody will be doing it (I guess they are already) and what good is a contract?
Let’s not forget that owners need contracts to secure sponsors. They need to be able to go to a sponsor and say, “So and so is with us until 2007 and will be your man, can you give us millions of dollars?” In Roush’s case, I definitely can understand not wanting to let Kurt go early. He is the 2004 NEXTEL Cup Series Champion and I have to believe a ton of sponsors came on board based on that fact, and they knew he’s be with Roush through the 2006 season. I’m sure Jack made plenty of deals based on that fact. So what, now he’s suppose to call them and say, “Kurt got a better offer, he’s leaving at the end of 2005 and you guys are screwed!”
Busch and McMurray need to suck it up and deal with it. Both drivers are in great equipment with big money teams. Maybe they need to be a little more careful about what they sign this time. What is sad is that this is becoming a trend in NASCAR and in all sports. The days of a driver spending a career with a team is definitely over. Everyone is looking for the next best thing and loyalty is out the door.
08/15/2005 05:50 PM
I am NOT a Jack Rousch fan, but I feel that he has every right to hold Kurt Busch to his 2006 contract, whether Kurt likes it or not. In other pro sports (and college coaching), a contract has become a meaningless scrap of paper that does little more than provide reason for a press conference when signed. Rousch has sponsor committments and contracts that are predicated on the fact that Busch would be the driver through 2006. As expensive as the sport has become, he certainly cannot afford to jeopardize those sponsorship dollars.
On the other hand, Ganassi seemed to be playing it pretty close to the vest in announcing his 2006 drivers lineup. If he wanted McMurray so bad, why not exercise his option sooner? If Jamie didn’t know Ganassi’s plan for him, I don’t blame him for firming up a 2006 deal.
The funniest part of the whole mess, is how “the Cat” has to be feeling. I’m sure that he never imagined in his wildest dreams, that one of his drivers (especially the defending NEXTEL champ), would ever jump ship, putting him in the same position that he put Ganassi in. He may be well served to get some type of extension wrapped up with Kenseth before he loses the whole package (driver, crew chief AND sponsor) the next time!
08/15/2005 09:48 PM
This is a very interesting subject and I can see both sides of that coin. I am sure we have no idea the full story behind all the jossling (sp), and quite frankly it is none of my business. I feel that each side has the right to exercise their options so to speak. Yes the drivers have signed a contract and they should be held to that. I do feel that each driver has the right to seek employment else where keeping in mind their current obligations. Its a messy situation all around and no one will suffer except the fans in this one. Either driver is capable of tanking their responsibilities, but the real question is are they man enough to step up to the plate and full fill their obligations? Being an older adult, I find the younger generations have little or no work ethic and feel that things ought to be handed to them without working for things. They also feel that certain things are entitlements that those of us oldies were brought up seeing as benefits of hard work.
No matter what happens not a dollar of either deal will end up in my pocket so why should I even care? Once again…just my humble opinion.
08/16/2005 09:28 AM
I agree that a deal is a deal. The other teams shouldn’t be allowed to approach a driver unless they are in the final year of their contract. But what really has me scratching my head is what was Roger Penske thinking when he hired Busch to replace Rusty? Sure Kurt is an awesome driver with tons of talent, but he’s no Rusty Wallace. Rusty is a sponsors dream and Kurt is a public relations nightmare. And I really doubt that Newman and Busch will play nicely together either. Both of them have egos the size of all outdoors. I have all the respect in the world for Roger Penske, but this time I just don’t get it.


Contact Tom Bowles

Recent articles from Tom Bowles:

Did You Notice? ... Breaking Down A Sprint Cup Season Eight Races In
Did You Notice? ... Drivers Still Make A Difference... But Silly Cautions Don't
Did You Notice? ... NASCAR's Free Agent Lynchpin, Uncomfortable Reality And Gambling
Did You Notice? ... Toyota Trouble, Limping Into Action And Testing The Waters
Did You Notice? ... Keep On Asking, And You Will Receive A Qualifying Sigh Of Relief

If you want to know more about Tom Bowles or to view all of his articles here at the Frontstretch, check out his archive and bio page.

Want even more Tom Bowles? Check out Tom's archive at