The Frontstretch: The Critics Have Been Silent ... At Least, Until Kansas by Tommy Thompson -- Wednesday September 24, 2008

Go to site navigation Go to article

The Critics Have Been Silent ... At Least, Until Kansas

Thompson in Turn 5 · Tommy Thompson · Wednesday September 24, 2008


As an unabashed supporter of NASCAR’s decision to implement a playoff format that determines the Sprint Cup champion — along with its equally controversial and much-maligned implementation of the race car formerly known as the Car of Tomorrow — I am feeling at least partially vindicated for my opinion following the last three weeks of racing. Granted, no one has approached me to concede that maybe NASCAR isn’t as bad at running a racing series as they, and many racing columnists, had been saying … and I haven’t yet gotten a call to be told that maybe, the Car of Tomorrow isn’t the ruination of the most popular motorsports series in America.

Nonetheless, I hear these men and women’s contritions loud and clear — and so does NASCAR! It is a deafening apologetic silence that is speaking volumes… if one only stops to listen. The Chase will now travel to the flatlands of Kansas for its third event with scarcely a negative word being uttered about the contrived points system, one that has seen the series’ point leader fall from the top spot to twelfth place in the standings in the matter of just eight days.

No doubt, there are still a few stubborn racing purists continuing to maintain the championship should be determined under the former points format, a system that would have only two drivers within 250 points of current leader Carl Edwards. There are supporters — many of which are on this site itself — who believe it just isn’t fair for the points leader to have his lead earned over a course of 26 race weekends be discarded, his points reset so that even the 12th place driver is within striking distance of a championship he might have run away with otherwise.

But whether a “playoff” system is fair or not is an argument that might be appropriate to contemplate in a Philosophy 101 course at the local junior college — not in the Real World. For the bottom line is such a system has consistently been shown to produce positive results in all the major sporting entities in this country. In every league that has adopted some form of a playoff schedule, the final result is always the same: it adds suspense, excitement, and interest to the conclusion of their competitive season.

Keep in mind also that NASCAR is a business, and as such, is always searching for new and innovative means to encourage fans to flop down their hard-earned cash to watch their favorite drivers — and that’s something the Chase can do. Indeed, the resetting of the points system has given fans of the sport’s hottest commodity, Dale Earnhardt, Jr., more incentive to continue to watch the races at home or trackside. Earnhardt Jr., though currently ninth in the standings, is a mere 129 points behind Edwards — even after a lackluster 24th place finish last Sunday at Dover, DE. That means Junior Nation still has reason to tune in for this championship battle, with interest that undoubtedly would not be as strong under the former points system. In that format, Junior would be stuck in fourth place, an almost insurmountable 272 markers behind the leader.

NASCAR’s Chase format has ever-popular Dale Jr. still within striking distance of his first Cup title — even after a lackluster Dover weekend.

But it’s not just the fans of Earnhardt, Jr. that have extra motivation to tune in for the remainder of the Sprint Cup season in favor of college and professional football. Due to the Chase, fans of all twelve playoff-eligible drivers have an additional reason to intently follow their wheelman at even this late stage of the 2008 season, with all of them having a legitimate chance of taking home the Sprint Cup. Two races into the ten-race playoff, there are still nine drivers — Edwards, Jimmie Johnson, Greg Biffle, Jeff Burton, Kevin Harvick, Clint Bowyer, Tony Stewart, Jeff Gordon, and Earnhardt, Jr. — less than 130 points out of first in the standings. Depending on the circumstances, any one of them could leave Kansas with a points lead some would have never dreamed of having otherwise.

Going hand-in-hand with the complaint that the points reset is nothing more than fabricated drama has been the complaint that drivers have been just “points racing” through the Spring and Summer, satisfied to settle for Top 10s only during the first 26 events. Though that’s a claim which has some merit, it has also become evident that with the Chase now in its fifth year, drivers and teams are becoming more cognizant of the need to win and collect valuable bonus points to be carried into the playoffs — ones that can be ultimately become the difference in winning or losing a championship they all still covet.

And while so many have critiqued the Chase, their hatred hasn’t stopped the average fan from continuing to tune in. After a year of decline, TV ratings have held steady throughout the season and have, at numerous events, topped previous tallies. Track attendance, despite the harsh realities that hyper-inflated gasoline prices and a downturn in the overall economy bring, has also not shown any significant decreases, either. This — despite predictions of a sharp decline in both — should lead NASCAR not to do an about-face, one in which they dump both the Chase format and its new generation race car all at once.

No, the sanctioning body is instead treating fans to some of the best racing that the sport has provided in years. The prelude to the Chase at Richmond — won by Jimmie Johnson after a classic battle with Tony Stewart — Greg Biffle’s win at New Hampshire Motor Speedway over Jimmie Johnson, and his second consecutive triumph last Sunday at Dover’s Monster Mile have all been widely recognized as highly entertaining races. And those three events were good not just because of the battles up front… but because of the racing throughout the entire field.

Don’t believe me? Well, I have proof. Who is complaining about the quality of the racing we’ve seen of late?

Answer: No one.

See! There is your proof! In a sport where fans are quick to critique a race and weigh in with even the pettiest of personal pet peeves… they have been left silent. And as a result, NASCAR can correctly interpret that silence as a resounding round of applause for both the Chase format and their new generation race car. Yes, this is the same race car that has also recently contributed to what many consider vastly more enjoyable races to watch at two tracks notorious in years past of putting on some real “snoozers” — California and Michigan.

Oh sure, there will still be some “stinkers” along the way this season. Cookie cutters like Kansas Speedway, where the Sprint Cup series will take their road show to this week, quickly come to mind. There are too many of these multi-purpose racing facilities that are not conducive to exciting, competitive Sprint Cup racing — but it’s a problem that neither a championship point system nor a newly engineered race car can completely resolve.

And until that next “stinker” comes, there’s nothing much to say these days, other than how the racing has been downright enjoyable. In fact — to borrow a phrase from a current hamburger commercial — it’s been nothing less than, “Shut your mouth good!”

And… that’s my view from Turn 5.

Contact Tommy Thompson

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
NASCAR Easter Eggs: A Few Off-Week Nuggets to Chew On
Five Points To Ponder: NASCAR’s Take-A-Breath Moment
Truckin’ Thursdays: Top Five All-Time Truck Series Drivers
Going By the Numbers: A Week Without Racing Can Bring Relief But Kill Momentum


©2000 - 2008 Tommy Thompson and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

09/24/2008 08:12 AM

I wish i could join you in your childlike wonder over the seeming omnipotence of NASCAR and all of it’s brilliant decisions . But like a very large segment of the fans ( all of the ones who you have apparently missed who have complained all year including the last three weeks right here in Fronstretch ) i think the chase idea is a highly manipulated attempt to grab tv ratings . Nothing more . It wasn’t done to increase fan excitement . It wasn’t designed to increase competition . It wasn’t done to improve on stock car racing . But all of the above should have been a major part of the decision . They were NOT . So now we have a watered down , pretty much meaningless sham of a championship just so NASCAR can try to grab tv ratings . I agree thats their business , but they destroyed the franchise so they could pretend to be as important as the NFL .

09/24/2008 08:47 AM

WOW! What have you been smoking?

“ In every league that has adopted some form of a playoff schedule, the final result is always the same: it adds suspense, excitement, and interest to the conclusion of their competitive season.”

My questions are many regarding this statement, such as: “how many sports keep the eliminated teams on the playing field up to, and including the “final” event?

And your: “Don’t believe me? Well, I have proof. Who is complaining about the quality of the racing we’ve seen of late?

Where have you been? As one writer here stated, “some 50 laps of “real racing”, do not a season make”! (out of 28 races to date)!

How sick is that! And you say no one has been complaining? Gee, did you go to Indianapolis or were you on vacation that week?

Cnsider NA$CAR’S

AND!! “Yes, this is the same race car that has also recently contributed to what many consider vastly more enjoyable races to watch at two tracks notorious in years past of putting on some real “snoozers” —California and Michigan.”

Are you really saying the racing was “good” at these two tracks?

My gosh, I am concerned over your state of mind and your memory! Help is on the way!

09/24/2008 09:08 AM

Reading way too much into the “silence.” In fact, you’re probably just not hanging out in the right places. There’s only so many times you can keep saying the same thing before you just get sick of saying it. You think the overall racing this season has improved with COT. I think it still leaves a lot to be desired at way too many of the venues, which is especially frustrating when so much was promised regarding COT and the quality of racing. Nascar needs to be thankful for the last 35 laps of that race. It made a lot of people temporarily forget some of the boring, follow-the-leader racing we’ve seen way too frequently this season. Don’t place too much weight on the “silence.” When you’ve been told repeatedly that COT is here to stay and Nascar doesn’t plan a change, your only real option is to accept or move on. The ratings are making a pretty deafening noise.

Annie Mack
09/24/2008 10:43 AM

I read the Frontstretch just in case I may have been mistaken in my disappointment in NA$CAR. Sometimes I read what the writers have to say and I tune in for 50 laps or so. Nope, it still sucks and I’m still disappointed. For those of you who think the chase is a good idea, then you go for it. I’ll be spending time with my family on Sunday or watching football. So far the sports industry hasn’t found a way to rig a football game and the outcome is sometimes actually exciting and unexpected. Biffle, Johnson, Edwards, and Busch. You can count on one of them every week. Jeff Gordon will be 5th or 6th, and Jr. will be an ‘also ran’.

09/24/2008 11:02 AM

Just in case:

These people sell hearing aids! Might want to visit with them a bit!

And if it is an optician you need, please ask!

09/24/2008 02:14 PM

Boy, am I STUPID!

Now I understand everything clearly! Your writing from “TURN 5”!

No wonder your not cognizant of the facts! Your at the WRONG TRACK!

No wonder you can’t hear anybody complain!

Start viewing from say turns #1 & #2!

09/24/2008 09:28 PM

Wow 40 good laps in a boring season, & you’re falling all over yourself. Usually when that happens to me, I’ve been drinking! Nice to see you’ve not lost your objectivity. This article is pure unadulterated bilge, or a really funny spoof! Which is it?

09/24/2008 10:04 PM

As an unabashed supporter of NA$CAR, you should be working in Daytona. Your opinions would definitely be more popular with BF.
Ditto Annie Mack.

Contact Tommy Thompson