The Frontstretch: NASCAR Turns To Mario Kart To Determine Sprint Cup Champion by Vito Pugliese -- Wednesday February 9, 2011

Go to site navigation Go to article

NASCAR Turns To Mario Kart To Determine Sprint Cup Champion

Voice of Vito · Vito Pugliese · Wednesday February 9, 2011


With the dawn of the 2011 NASCAR Sprint Cup Season just a few weeks away, NASCAR decided to change the rules – yet again – at the very last minute.

For the fourth time in less than ten seasons, the format used to decide the champion has changed once more. There were rumblings of something happening regarding the ranking system used throughout last year, expanding the Chase field to 15, more points for winning, a wild card entry (just like the NFL!), among a myriad of other subtle tweaks and changes. So at the 11th hour, in the midst of NASCAR Pre-Season Thunder media tour, NASCAR unveiled their new points system.

Would be it be a return the Latford system that worked so well for 23 years and helped spur the sport on to unfathomable levels? Did the Chase finally go the way of “The Wing” and “The Splitter” and every other ill-conceived idea of the past eight years?

Oh no. The new points system to determine who is the champion of the most prestigious racing series in the Western Hemisphere will be the same one used to determine the winner in Nintendo’s Mario Kart.

What, RC Pro-Am, Rad Racer and Ivan Stewart’s Off-Road Challenge didn’t want any of that?

Under the “new and improved system” the winner will receive 43 points, 42 for second, and on down to 1 point for finishing dead last in 43rd. The winner receives a three-point bonus for winning, and an additional point for leading a lap and another for the most laps lead. In Mario Kart, the winner gets 10 points, second receives 8, third receives 6, followed by 4, 3, 2, and 0. If you figure there are four times as many cars in the race, it evens out close enough.

For NASCAR as a whole to have made so many positive changes last season – from ditching the wing, to the second coming of the muscle car to Nationwide and starting the races at a reasonable hour – this has completely spent all of the goodwill capital that had been built up in the eyes of many long time fans who may have been starting to been drawn back in – even if the same guy who had won the title for the last four years was on his way to a fifth title less than 20 laps into the season finale.

All one needs to do is read the reactions to the story on any number of racing websites, blogs, sports pages, you name it. From the sounds of things, this latest attempt to gain legitimacy in the eyes of the beatified “casual fan” has all the redeeming qualities of a case of genital herpes, but at least does not require a prescription – it only requires 36 weekends of your life.

At least the National Guard pays and gives you an M-16 and a Beretta M9 for your troubles of such a commitment.

While I never thought the traditional Latford system needed revising, the reasons being given for the change are weak at best. The common thread that shows up in nearly all of the responses and comments to the new system is, “it is easier to understand!” Really? That’s funny because I never found the old one too difficult, even when I really started paying attention to NASCAR, the points and the championship when I was ten years old thumbing through the weekly racing issue, Southern MotoRacing.

NASCAR claims the changes made will make it easier to understand for the fans, but was it really that complicated before?

Pretty simple from what I could see: 175 points for a win, 5 bonus points for leading a lap, 5 more for leading the most laps. The points decreased five points through sixth, four points through 11th place and by three down to 43rd. That worked fine even through the first few years of the Chase, where five points for winning was tacked on a couple of times, to where 195 became the maximum points scored. Fair enough, and a boon to those who had wished that winning would mean more – yet still maintained the key being consistency.

The Chase itself is the real culprit here. It has been roundly rejected by die-hards and channel flippers alike. Resetting the points mid-season apparently isn’t a problem, so naturally, scrapping the system every few years when the ratings level out or don’t beat the NFL in the fall has become the knee-jerk reaction.

Why this is, I have no clue. Might there be something the network or Sprint contracts that demands some sort of a playoff format be used to try and go up against the National Football League (which by the way produced eight of the top 10 highest rated prime-time television shows in 2010)?

While that part of it is uncertain, what is without question is changing your method of determining a champion is not what engenders respect among the stick-and-ball sports fans that seem to be the constant target of the NASCAR brain trust. Never mind that “our” way of doing things is what converted so many to begin with during the 1990s and early 2000s. With all due respect to Dale Earnhardt, Sr., the sport continued to grow after his passing, and did not really level out and decline until after the Chase become a part of the racing landscape and lexicon.

I guess if there is any consolation, it is that after 26 weeks, the points get reset and the championship Chase begins for the top 10 – with two more thrown in for good measure that won the most races, but didn’t make it past 11th in points and finished at least in the top 20.

The top 10 will be seeded by wins, with each win worth three points, except for the 11th and 12th place wild card drivers, who will not receive bonus points. Those in contention for the championship will be reset to 2000 points and given three bonus points for winning. Why? Because it’s easier to understand, follow and figure out, particularly for fans flipping over from an NFL game on a Sunday afternoon.

To quote YouTube hero Antoine Dodson, “Waaelll, obviously….”

Contact Vito Pugliese

The Frontstretch Newsletter, back in 2014 gives you more of the daily news, commentary, and racing features from your favorite writers you know and love. Don’t waste another minute – click here to sign up now. We’re here to make sure you stay informed … so make sure you jump on for the ride!

Today on the Frontstretch:
Swan Racing Announces Restructuring, No. 26 & No. 30 ‘Sold’ Off
Tech Talk with Tony Gibson: Taking Stock Of Danica Patrick In Year Two
Vexing Vito: Three Drivers In Need of a Role Reversal
Going By the Numbers: Top-10 NASCAR Variety Hard To Come By In…
Truckin’ Thursdays: Lessons Learned Just Two Races In
Fantasy Insider: Team Revelations For NASCAR’s Short Tracks



©2000 - 2008 Vito Pugliese and Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!

02/09/2011 08:17 AM

That was a pretty funny read, Vito. I get the sarcasm of using Mario Kart, but Mario Kart was just using the F1 points system in place at the time. That was a tried and true points system in it’s own right.
Unlike Genital Herpes, NA$CAR doesn’t seem to be a lifelong “affliction” anymore. It seems to be more like Gonorrhea, one dose of brian france, and the fans are “cured” of ever wanting to watch another race!!!

02/09/2011 09:22 AM

Well if there going to go Mario Kart, then add the banana peels and other cool weapons. Of course Dale Jr. would be running 25th and get the lightning bolt. NASCAR would make sure he gets all the cool powerups.

Sherri T
02/09/2011 10:07 AM

I never thought about a contractual agreement with Sprint – boy if that were the case it explains the beating of the dead horse. But then it begs the question, would Sprint not see the writing on the wall? If fans decline because of something contracted around a Chase format, they lose too??

02/09/2011 12:24 PM

Quick everyone, without pencil & paper, How many points does 25th place get. I have asked quite a few fans and off the top of their head they can not get the right answer. So, how is this any easier?

Don Mei
02/09/2011 02:34 PM

Um…I duz like dat new point system fo Nasca!! I in calculate what place Dale and de boys are in widout takin my shoes off.Shoor is mighty fine fo we us racin fans so now wees gonna be goin to lotsa races cause we kin calumlate de points! Tanks Cousin Brian! You did good for us!!

Contact Vito Pugliese