Welcome to this week’s edition of What’s the Call? Each week, two of your favorite Frontstretch writers will duke it out in a debate concerning one of NASCAR’s big controversies. Don’t let us be the only ones to speak our minds, though…be sure to read both sides and let us know what you think about the situation in the comment section below!
This Week’s Question: After an argument caught on camera between Kurt Busch’s and Greg Biffle’s girlfriends, Nicole Lunders and Eva Braun, NASCAR has issued a reprimand to the two women for their actions. Was that warning justified…or ridiculous?
NASCAR Simply Playing By the Rules
Mike Neff
Nicole Lunders and Eva Braun engaged in an innocent little argument back at Texas that coincidentally made for riveting television on pit road. With that said, was a reprimand issued to the two "combatants" for the incident a bit too harsh? Certainly not.
The pit area of a NASCAR race is a busy place. There are cars, tires, jacks, air guns, car parts, pit boxes, crew chiefs, owners, crew members, television and radio crews, journalists, officials, celebrities, and significant others. Every person who is on pit road during the actual race activities has a NASCAR license of some sort. If they don’t, people have to sign waivers, secure insurance, and basically put their lives at risk to be allowed to take up space next to the wall at a NASCAR race.
Despite the large number of people milling around, generally everyone associated with a team in the pits has a job. The only people who are not specialists of some kind are the significant others. Most of the teams who have a spouse or girlfriend on the box give them something important to do though. They can calculate fuel mileage, track lap times, or keep notes of chassis changes. It may seem like it isn’t much to do, but it is generally very important to a team’s success. These people are usually not just taking up space.
No, significant others are very much a part of a team, and because that team is there to do its job, everyone on a team in the pit area during a race is governed by the NASCAR Rule Book. Specifically, Rule 12-4, Section F, which states the following:
“Any (Team) Member who participates in fights in the pits, on the track or on the race premises (can be penalized with): a fine, and/or disqualification, and/or loss of Championship points, and/or loss of finishing position(s) in the Event, and/or probation, and/or suspension.”
This section of the rules covers the actions of the two young ladies involved in the argument at Texas Motor Speedway. Greg’s girlfriend Nicole simply should not have gone into Kurt’s pit area. She should have waited until after the race and vented her frustration. However, she let her emotions get the better of her. Her man was put in harm’s way by what she felt were the careless actions of another driver. The fact that she had an existing friendship with Kurt’s fiancé Eva probably added to the belief that she could go speak her mind. Unfortunately for her, friendships don’t apply when NASCAR is enforcing its rule book. The rules are the rules. The people who are on pit road have a NASCAR license, and that license comes with a responsibility to act in a certain fashion. Storming into another team’s pit area and unleashing your beliefs on anyone within earshot is not acceptable.
In issuing a reprimand, NASCAR was simply enforcing their rules to maintain order on pit road. There is little doubt that crew members speak their mind to other teams on a weekly basis, but these discussions take place in the motorhome lot or behind closed doors when cooler heads can prevail. NASCAR certainly could have just let it go and probably not received a whole lot of flack over the incident, but that would have opened a Pandora’s box. What happens next week if Todd Berrier storms down to Jimmie Johnson’s pit and gives Chad Knaus an earful> Todd is in the pits on the same license that Greg’s girlfriend is on. If NASCAR doesn’t hold Nicole’s feet to the fire, Todd could claim that he didn’t do anything different, therefore there shouldn’t be any punishment.
Not to mention, if this isn’t nipped in the bud, the same type of fight could happen next time more dire results. What happens if Nicole tries to take a swing at Eva? Someone on Kurt’s crew is now put in the awkward situation of trying to control a member of another team who is in their pit area. For argument’s sake, suppose the jack man tries to grab Nicole while she is on the ladder. She falls backwards and is knocked unconscious when she hits her head on a gas can that happens to be sitting there. Now what do you have? An assault charge? A liability issue for NASCAR, the track, and/or Penske Racing South?
Here’s the bottom line: you simply cannot have people from one team going into another team’s pit area in a hostile frame of mind. NASCAR was definitely within their bounds enforcing their rules and maintaining control over the pit area. The two girls were just lucky they didn’t receive anything worse than a warning.
Reprimand by NASCAR Went Too Far
Tom Bowles
Back one lazy Sunday afternoon at Texas, Nicole Lunders and Eva Braun did something millions of people around the world do once in a blue moon…they argued with each other. One small, short screaming match in which no one was hurt and no punches are thrown, a random display of emotion which occurs frequently in all aspects of human life. Unfortunately, the powers that be at NASCAR don’t believe in anger, issuing the girls a reprimand along with a veiled threat they could be kicked off pit road for future vocal outbursts. It’s a “penalty” that has amounted to one of the more ridiculous things NASCAR’s done in recent memory.
Put yourself in Nicole’s shoes for a second. Kurt Busch had just pushed her boyfriend Greg Biffle into the wall, continuing his season of frustration. Keep in mind the intensity of this sport…for 38 weeks a year, in 50 motorhomes in the infield, not only the drivers but their families experience the roller coasters of a race weekend, the unfathomable highs and devastating lows. That can take its toll during stretches of continued bad luck, which Nicole and the 16 team have been all too familiar with recently…and that’s not to mention Biffle’s bout with the outside wall could also have resulted in a serious injury.
Combine those recent problems with the fact the Biffles knew the Buschs off the track, with Greg and Kurt spending seven years as teammates dating all the way back to the Craftsman Truck Series. Busch may have moved on from Roush to Penske, but old friendships always stay strong, especially with significant others who would have little to nothing to do with the change of scenery. The fact Biffle’s day was ruined by someone he supposedly had a close bond with added insult to injury, and understandably sent Nicole over the top.
So, where did Nicole go with her temper overflowing? Straight to Kurt Busch’s pit box. Keep in mind she didn’t interrupt any of the work going on there…she just went to talk to her friend Eva on that pit box and vent her aggravation about the whole incident. Eva, of course, vented back…Kurt’s car was no longer competitive for the day, either, and of course she had nothing to do with Greg Biffle getting into the wall. The whole argument was kind of silly, but accomplished the necessary goal of both women letting off steam.
Keep in mind that while the argument was going on, no one else was approached, no work was interrupted in the pit box, and no punches were thrown between the two women. The only thing that occurred was pure, raw emotion…the type great TV footage is made of.
In the “Leave it to Beaver” NASCAR Offices, though, raw emotion equals something apart from the norm for significant others, and god forbid anything deviate from the NORM. Apparently, racing wives are only useful when they’re crying / shouting for joy when their significant other wins the race; showing any other emotion would violate NASCAR’s policy of keeping everything else on Earth Rated G.
Too bad, because this whole incident made for riveting television, started up a possible rivalry between Kurt Busch and Greg Biffle, and led to the harming of…well, no one. NASCAR should be embracing a little emotion to pump some energy in the sport, not squelching it every time in the face of the company line. Now, a simple shove by Jeff Gordon can result in a fine and a public apology, and two girls having words on pit road can cause NASCAR to issue a warning for proper behavior. At this point, why should anyone in the sport speak any way other than softly and in a monotone voice? God knows, the championship is at stake.
DON’T FORGET … IT’S WEDNESDAY!! NEW CONTENT ALL OVER THE MAIN PAGE!
Many fans are frequent Frontstretch visitors, but how many actually scroll all the way down to the bottom of our main page? Well, now we’ve given you a reason to give our site a few extra clicks. On the right-hand side of the main page, we’ve brought back our popular Foto Funnies feature poking fun at the pictures of the week, a perfect match for the Top Ten always located in your bottom right-hand corner. Add in a main page poll, a Carey and Coffey blog, and there’s a brand new destination spot for Wednesday content. It’s just the latest way to give you the best NASCAR news, commentary, info, and entertainment anywhere on the web!
©2000 - 2008 Mike Neff and Tom Bowles and Frontstetch.com. Thanks for visiting the Frontstretch!
























