Race Weekend Central

The Frontstretch 5: Changes That Could Make NASCAR’s All-Star Race More Relevant

1. The venue

The All-Star Race has been held at Charlotte Motor Speedway for many years, and quite a few fans feel that it’s time for a change. Is it?

From the fans’ point of view, sure. Charlotte doesn’t produce a lot of door-to-door racing anymore, and moving the race around would give more fans an opportunity to see an All-Star event in person.

On the other hand, Charlotte is home base to most of the teams; all but Furniture Row Racing are based in the region. That means the teams, who this race is really about, get to spend the weekend at home with their families.  Crew members’ families are often in attendance for this event, with its more relaxed atmosphere, and would not get to be there otherwise.

This race is about those people and showcasing the best among them. They should have the final say in this one, whether that’s to stay in Charlotte or move the race to another venue. Perhaps Bristol or Martinsville, both of which are within about a three-hour drive from the Charlotte area and have lights for a nighttime show, would be a good option. And if the teams don’t want the race moved? It shouldn’t be. Again, it’s about them for this one week.

2. The cars

While fans cringe at the mere mention of restrictor plates (and they’re not necessarily wrong), the All-Star event is the perfect time to try something different that might improve the racing. If it doesn’t, no harm, no foul. If it does, NASCAR has something it knows works under race conditions which can maybe be used going forward to improve the racing for the fans every week. That’s never a bad thing.

On the other hand, there’s something about making the All-Star Race a “run what you brung” deal, where if the engine is legal, the tires and safety features are unaltered and the body fits the templates, teams are free to do whatever they can to find speed. From gears to suspensions, leave it all on the table and see who can really build the fastest car and who can drive it. A free-for-all might open a few eyes, and it would keep the teams from being too conservative in order to test for the following week’s Coca-Cola 600, also run at Charlotte Motor Speedway.

3. The format

This year’s format is basically a regular race with shorter stages. It’s easy to understand, but were NASCAR and Charlotte Motor Speedway even trying? What happened to the mandatory pit stops, which allowed strategy to come into play?  What happened to things like inverting the field randomly, or eliminating the cars at the back, or other such things. This race is the one where the gimmicks fit. I hate the gimmicks for the points races, but here? Bring ‘em.

While the pit stops during qualifying are a great addition, there needs to be a green-flag stop during the race. Then, invert a certain number of cars for the final restart, make the drivers race to the portapotty during the segment break, eliminate the 12th-place car in every segment. Do something to make the race different and fun.  There are 36 points-paying events to be serious, after all….

The other rule that needs to change is that only winning drivers get in, meaning if they change teams in the offseason, too bad for the team that got them there if the new driver didn’t win last year. The race used to include both the driver’s current team and the one that got him there. Under that rule, the No. 20 team, which won at Phoenix last fall, would be eligible this year, along with former driver Matt Kenseth, who is eligible and will race.

It’s not the team’s fault Erik Jones hasn’t won a race yet. That needs to come back. The teams are as much a part of the All-Star designation as the drivers.

4. The pit crews

Adding a pit stop to qualifying has made that part of the weekend more about the teams, and it’s certainly entertaining to watch.  However, it’s still about the driver, and you won’t hear those crews’ names mentioned on the broadcast. The old Pit Crew Challenge was a lot of fun; teams were in the spotlight, and half the time, the driver wasn’t in the car.

Nothing against the drivers; they’re great, and they are who the fans pull for. But the more the sport is humanized, the better off it is.

This area is another one that could perhaps be up to the crews. If they’d rather skip the challenge for a night off, that’s understandable, but if they want to resurrect it, do so. Perhaps don’t tie the challenge into pit stall selection, either. Instead, keep the current qualifying format, but give the winning team a big fat check and let them have at it.

5. The last-chance race

Aside from the fan vote, which rightfully gives fans a say in this event, three drivers will race their way into the big show this year in a three-stage Open race with the winner of each segment making the big show. Is that too many?

Well, yeah. It is.  Letting one driver race his way in? Absolutely! It gives fans a chance to see their driver race on All-Star weekend even if they’re not in the big event. That’s a good thing; it entices more fans to come if they know they’ll see their guy. But three? That’s just too many. If they didn’t win a race, it’s unlikely they’ll be competitive in the All-Star Race. It’s possible, of course; just not terribly likely. Take this one back to one 25-lap race and the winner transfers. Easy and makes sense.

About the author

Amy is an 18-year veteran NASCAR writer and a five-time National Motorsports Press Association (NMPA) writing award winner, including first place awards for both columns and race coverage. As well as serving as Photo Editor, Amy writes The Big 6 (Mondays) after every NASCAR Cup Series race. She can also be found filling in from time to time on The Frontstretch 5 (Wednesdays) and her monthly commentary Holding A Pretty Wheel (Thursdays). A New Hampshire native living in North Carolina, Amy’s work credits have extended everywhere from driver Kenny Wallace’s website to Athlon Sports. She can also be heard weekly as a panelist on the Hard Left Turn podcast that can be found on AccessWDUN.com's Around the Track page.

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Share this article

Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Bill B

The all-star race in NASCAR is pointless. The whole attraction of the all-star concept is to see all the best in the sport on the field at the same time because there is no other way a fan could see that. In NASCAR the same 35 guys race against each other every week for 36 weeks, so there is nothing that makes it special and it is therefore pointless (except for whatever revenue it can generate).


90 minutes northwest of Charlotte: North Wilkesboro.

90 minutes southeast of Charlotte: Rockingham.

90-ish minutes southwest of Charlotte: Greenville-Pickens.

90 minutes northeast of Charlotte: Caraway.

Sure as hell would be more interesting than Charlotte. Oh well.


Put them in dirt cars and race at the Charlotte Dirt Track. It’s pretty close.

Or on the big track, treat it like a Saturday short track night. Heat races and last chances and a feature. Anybody can enter and race if the car passes inspection. 24 cars run the feature. Heat races are based on the handicap system based on points per event run. Driver with the highest total starts last in the third heat with the next nine highest average . The lowest average starts first in first heat and so on. Take four from the first heat, five from the second and six from the third. They start at the front of the feature in that order. Last chances have the non-qualified cars in the order they finished their heat races and take four from each and they start behind the other sixteen. If a car doesn’t qualify they don’t race in the feature. There should be lots of “attempting” to pass other cars. Make the heats and last chances 15 laps and the feature 35 or 40.

Put the drivers in Modifieds at Richmond.


And if an car fails post-race inspection it is disqualified and no money.

Racing in Mississauga

There is nothing “All-Star” about this race…it is the same drivers as every other week going through the motions in a sport that desperately needs a new, shorter schedule amongst a host of other significant changes. I would bet the first thing that the new owner of NASCAR does is to can this exhibition “race”.


I think making it a minimum rules run what ya brung 40 lap shootout would be fun and relevant. I agree that heat races and A and B mains would be good. I would open it up to championship winners in other NASCAR series too. If a NASCAR modified champion can get a Cup car for the weekend, let him run.


I would LOVE to see one surprise at the All-Star race. Chase Elliott wins the fan vote (of course) and then announces that he is giving up his spot in favor of a past Cup race winner, like Paul Menard. Of course, I’d rather see him win his way in, but with plates on the cars, we’ll probably see one of Amy’s stray dogs win.


And exactly WHY should the fans have a say in who gets into the event? That has given us Danica Patrick and Cole Whitt in the past. And Whitt cheated his way in. Why not let the fan vote determine who gets into the Final Four at Homestead? Or who wins the championship? It is pure delusion to believe NASCAR is a legitimate sport anymore. Let’s just toss out ALL the rules and give the fans whatever the hell they want. Based on FS feedback, they want 1960’s car models, fat smoking alcoholics as drivers and the resurrection of Dale Earnhardt. And a point system that considers first place just another finishing position with no more significance over second than 30th has over 31st.

Or hold a race in Iowa or at Road America this weekend and do away with this whole circus.


if its a run what u brung race the only rules should be tires and safety equipment and its the fans whoshould have say in where the all star race should be I think it should be rotated between the 3 tracks mentioned and not announce which 1 till 3 days before the race


If they took some of the seats from the other speedways they could put them around the Iowa track and have enough seating for a Cup race but then there is the problem of getting to the track and parking.

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com