Home / Amy Henderson / The Big 6: Questions Answered After the 2019 Bluegreen Vacations 500
(Photo: Nigel Kinrade Photography)

The Big 6: Questions Answered After the 2019 Bluegreen Vacations 500

Who… should you be talking about after the race?

Back Denny Hamlin into a corner, and he’ll roll right over. Before now, that was a common assessment of the veteran driver and not entirely unfounded. In 2010, Hamlin finished a career-high second in points, but he entered the last race of that year with the point lead. All he had to do was keep Jimmie Johnson at a reasonable distance and he’d win. Under the playoff rules of the time and the Latford point system that was then in play, Hamlin could have finished a spot or two behind Johnson and come away with the title. He ended up 39 points in the hole and hasn’t been able to make a serious title run since. In other words, he choked, and closing the deal has been a serious issue for him.

But that changed Sunday. Hamlin was backed firmly into a corner, entering the week 20 points below the cut after a crash last week at Texas Motor Speedway. Instead of tucking his tail and taking his lumps this week, Hamlin came roaring back with a convincing win, handily beating a teammate with the reputation for taking races like this one. That makes Hamlin, who has six wins on the year, look like a closer, and he’ll need to close like never before next week.  Hamlin will turn 39 the day after the final race and doesn’t have forever to win one anymore.  He should be a Hall of Fame lock on wins alone, but a title would seal him as a first-ballot entry.

Erik Jones made an early exit from this year’s playoffs, but Sunday, he was the best finisher outside the Round of 8, securing a quiet but menacing seventh after procuring a top-10 start as well. It’s his fourth top 10 in seven races at ISM Raceway.  Jones won twice in Phoenix in a truck as well. He’s become a more consistent driver this year with experience and will enter 2020 on solid footing as a playoff contender if he plays his cards right.

What… is the takeaway from this race?

Is ISM Raceway the right call for the title race next year? While there were some compelling moments in this weekend’s races, including a knock-down-drag-out battle for second-place stage points between Hamlin and Chase Elliott before a later cut tire ended Elliott’s day and playoffs. Restarts produced five- and six-wide racing, but it didn’t last more than a lap or two.

Was it better than what we’ve seen at Homestead-Miami Speedway? Certainly not consistently enough to make it a clear choice. Now, with the title on the line, there will be four drivers going at it tooth and nail next year, and that will make a difference. But a big difference? That’s hard to say.

The problem is, with the length of NASCAR’s season, there are few tracks where the weather is conducive to fans sitting in the stands for hours in November. In a perfect world, the last four races would be at the Charlotte ROVAL, Bristol Motor Speedway, Richmond Raceway and Martinsville Speedway in about any order. But temperatures in those areas can be very cold in November.

Where… were the other key players at the end?

Polesitter and spring ISM winner Kyle Busch was looking to snap a now-21-race winless streak Sunday, and he certainly looked like he could end the drought early on, showing speed in practices and winning the pole. Busch led the first 69 laps Sunday in convincing fashion, but he would not see the lead again after that. A four-tire call with only a handful of laps left put Hamlin square in his sights, but Busch couldn’t get close enough to his teammate to make a move in the final laps, even with twice the fresh rubber.  Busch finished second and will move on to Homestead, which would be quite a place to snap the streak.

All-time Phoenix win leader Kevin Harvick entered the weekend with momentum after winning in Texas last week, but this week was uncharacteristic for Harvick. While he hasn’t finished outside the top 10 at ISM since 2013, his last win came four races ago, in the spring of 2018. And Harvick hasn’t led a lap at ISM this season. His fifth-place finish is nothing to sneeze at, but is his dominance a thing of the past?

Defending Cup champion Joey Logano did a lot of things right on Sunday, and under most scenarios, his ninth-place finish would have been plenty to ensure him a shot being the first repeat champion in almost a decade.  He led 93 laps on the day and won stage two and all the points that came with it, but Hamlin’s win left him outside of the title race by seven points to Kyle Busch, who took the last spot on points.

When… was the moment of truth?

Hamlin’s heart must have dropped to his feet when the caution flew for John Hunter Nemechek’s incident with just eight laps to go, erasing what likely would have been an insurmountable lead for Hamlin. Restarts at ISM are wild, and while Hamlin avoided one bullet when all the leaders pitted for tires, he couldn’t avoid Ryan Blaney to his inside on the restart, also in a must-win situation, or a hungry Kyle Busch on four fresh tires to Hamlin’s two in third, anxious to break what is, for Busch, a long winless streak.

Sure enough, Blaney, Busch and a slew of others dove to the inside to try and make something happen. Any miscue by Hamlin would likely have ended his playoffs.

It’s certainly happened before: the caution flies late and the leader sees his race slip away. It happened at Homestead last year, giving Logano one last chance at the title. This time, though, Hamlin’s team made exactly the right call and Hamlin made exactly the right moves. Logano ended up being the one stung this time.

Why… should you be paying attention this week?

In a matter of days, it’ll all be over, the engines quiet for the long winter ahead. That means the focus is on the title. Fans are guaranteed that there will not be a repeat champion with Logano’s elimination in Phoenix. The last time a driver went back-to-back was 2009-10, when Johnson took the last two of his remarkable five-year title run.

Should Hamlin win, he’d be the sixth different driver to win a title in the last six years. He’d also put an exclamation point on Johnson’s career.  Since Johnson won his first of seven championships in 2006, no other driver has won more than a single title. Of course, that also means that Martin Truex Jr., Harvick and Kyle Busch would love to end that.

The final shakedown also means that Harvick, Truex and Busch all make an appearance in the Championship 4 for the third year in a row. That’s not much variety. But before anyone complains about lack of unpredictability, if you take points at face value, they were also the three best drivers the least three years on season points. That’s how the final race should turn out, frankly, and the three best drivers for the last three years are in it, so the cream rose to the top in this case. Interestingly enough, the just-eliminated Logano holds the point lead under the full-season model, with Hamlin in fifth, a healthy 31 markers back. It’s hard to put much stock in this because teams strategize with the system they’re given, but it’s worth at least looking at the rundown.

How… does the Championship 4 break down?

Hamlin, Harvick, Truex and Kyle Busch enter the final race on remarkably even ground. Truex has the most wins at seven, with Hamlin next with six and Harvick and Busch with four apiece. Hamlin’s 19 top fives are the most among the group, with Busch having the edge in top 10s. All four have an average finish of 10th or better. In other words, there is no favorite.

Hamlin and Harvick may have momentum on their sides with the most recent wins. Truex won the race before that.  Busch hasn’t won since June, but his hunger makes him dangerous.

So far under the elimination playoff format, the champion has won at Homestead to take the title, and any of these four could well do that. Hamlin leads active drivers with two wins in Miami. Busch, Truex and Harvick all have one. But a win is not guaranteed. the whole rest of the field will be gunning to steal the thunder.

Sit back and enjoy the show, race fans. How it’ll turn out is anyone’s guess.

Support Frontstretch on Patreon

About Amy Henderson

Amy Henderson
Amy is a 15-year veteran writer and a five-time National Motorsports Press Association (NMPA) writing award winner, including first place awards for both columns and race coverage. Amy pens The Big 6 (Mondays) Frontstretch 5 (Wednesdays) and Holding A Pretty Wheel (monthly - Fridays). A New Hampshire native living in North Carolina, Amy’s work credits extend everywhere from driver Kenny Wallace’s website to Athlon Sports.

Check Also

2019 NASCAR Driver Reviews: Ryan Blaney

Almost everyone has a different definition of success, but it’s easy to believe that Ryan …

8 comments

  1. Avatar

    I am not a Hamlin or Busch fan but I seriously think there’s no way in hell Busch could’ve passed him if he wanted to. There was no passing all day! That track should produce awesome racing with the layout it offers but instead we are subject to this awful rules package that has consistently put on terrible racing all year; at least the season ends next week. I almost wish we could fast forward through the 2020 season as well since there’s no major changes coming. Give me a brake, how can NASCAR seriously subject it’s fans, drivers, and sponsors to another repeat performance of this years product? I think the Race Team Alliance bought speed 51 so that when the major TV networks walk away the RTA has an outlet to try and patch races through.

  2. Avatar

    Didn’t watch or listen to it. Motorcycle riding. I really thought NASCAR would caution flag Golden Boy into the final, but he wrecked. Only option they had was to disqualify the field. You can’t blame Bush for not passing Hamlin if he could. Three cars make it very lucrative for Gibbs and the organization, this year and next year plus it helps gain sponsors.
    I think Jack Roush warned of this when Toyota entered racing. The WWII era vet knew of what he was speaking.

  3. Avatar

    This rules package has ruined ISM (phoenix) raceway. Too much grip. not enough horse power equals a boring race. Having said that, Chase did what Chase does. I can only imagine how big a hand Rick Hendrick will have in designing the next gen race package. Hey Rick, maybe the plans are in the Clinton library you helped to build with your generous million dollar donation.

  4. Avatar

    Let’s be real. Did anybody watching the end of that race really believe that Hamblin out ran Busch on two tires? They can claim there are no team orders in NASCAR, but as long as Logano was in contention for that last “play off” spot, there’s no way that Gibbs, or Toyota, were going to allow Busch to pass Hamblin for the win. Busch had one job at the end of that race, and that was to protect Hamblin’s a$$, and to make sure he got into the final round.

    • Avatar

      At least he didn’t have to spin himself out to do it.

      • Avatar

        Nbc started focusing on Hamlin at the start and never stopped. Kyle took one for the team obviously. The screeching coming from jr and Burton is intolerable. What the heck is wrong with their producer. Next year this race will be a championship race. A snoozer.

    • Avatar

      No unless Hamlin spun his tires or seriously messed up. We watched earlier this year NO tires beat 4 fresh tires. That is what this package gives us. Clean air racing. I agree with MisterSlideways, wish we could just skip the 2020 season of this package.

  5. Avatar

    I gave up the struggle to stay interested in a race where I only saw’heard about 10 cars in the entire field. since I really don’t care which JGR team wins the crapshoot ‘title’, I see no reason to try to stay awake next week. This had to be one of the least compelling ‘races’ of the year…unless you are a big Joe Gibbs fan.Highlights were few and far between…unless NBC just didn’t bother to cover any of them. That is a distinct possibility. Pathetic race, pathetic coverage, pathetic format.