Race Weekend Central

Couch Potato Tuesday: For Me, Clash Broadcast Was a Nightmare to Watch

Welcome back to another year of critiquing of motorsports on TV. This will be my 14th year here at Frontstretch, giving you nuggets to think about in regards to race broadcasts. Crazy when you think about it.

This past weekend, NASCAR ventured west out to Los Angeles to enter uncharted territory. The Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum, likely the largest stadium in the country, was converted into a quarter-mile oval for 150 laps of action. Admittedly, the sim racing events on iRacing that I saw leading up to Sunday made me think that it would be a wreckfest. Aside from the second half of the second Last Chance Qualifier, that wasn’t really the case. It was far more competitive than I thought it would be.

Before we get into the nitty gritty, I must provide this disclaimer: My experience watching Sunday’s action will be quite different than most readers of this column. This is not FOX’s fault.

At 2 a.m. Sunday morning, I discovered that my local FOX affiliate, WXXA FOX23, was not going to air the first 3.5 hours of coverage from Los Angeles. This is because FOX23 was airing the #518Gives fundraiser for the Center for Disability Services from 2-5:30 p.m. ET. That would mean that all of the first edition of NASCAR RaceDay, the heats, the LCQs and half of the second NASCAR RaceDay would not air on FOX locally.

Such a situation stinks, but it’s not the first time that something like this has happened in Albany. Back in 1997, CBS’ broadcast of the inaugural Interstate Batteries 500 at Texas Motor Speedway was pre-empted in Albany so that WRGB could air an Arthritis Telethon. They did eventually air the race, but at 12:15 a.m. that night. Given that there was some pre-race and post-race coverage back then and four hours of racing, the broadcast would have wrapped up around 4:45 a.m. I was 12 at the time and didn’t have a TV in my room, so I couldn’t watch.

Back then, over-the-air subchannels as we know them today didn’t exist. Today, your over-the-air channels could have half a dozen sub feeds. What’s on those sub feeds? Likely one of a number of general entertainment digital channels. There are nearly 30 of them available over-the-air in the Albany area, but only a small percentage are available in cable systems locally.

The first 3.5 hours of FOX’s coverage was shifted to Channel 23.3 in Albany, space normally occupied by Laff, a digital network dedicated to sitcoms, comedy TV shows and sometimes movies. I admit to watching from time to time. They air Night Court on there and I’m always up for that.

Unfortunately, putting a race broadcast on a station normally used for Laff is not a good idea. Why? Well, there was no announcer audio for the entire 3.5 hours that they aired from Los Angeles. This was exasperating and I was admittedly clueless as to what was going on. I asked around and determined quickly that this wasn’t a national issue. It was just in Albany.

I sent a tweet to FOX23’s Twitter page as to what was causing the issue, but received no response. Nearly two hours in, I got a Facebook message from a man who (like myself) covers the local dirt racing scene here in the Albany area. He had talked to someone with technical knowledge and apparently announcer audio is put through a third channel for sound and he didn’t think Laff was set up for that. As a result, we got ambient sounds from Los Angeles, but no announcers. Based on the comments I’ve read here over the years, some of you might like that. However, you need the voices to put things into context.

Obviously, with Tony Stewart making his booth debut for FOX and everyone getting back to work, I can’t critique a race broadcast without announcer audio. So I had to watch those 3.5 hours on first the FOX Sports app, then FOXSports.com. The app was approximately one to two laps behind the broadcast, while the website was four laps behind. This was far from an ideal setup, and I’ll be happy that it doesn’t happen for the rest of the season. Luckily, once 5:30 p.m. came along, the coverage moved to FOX23 and I didn’t have to worry about this ridiculousness.

Unfortunately, the pre-race setup meant that I had to deal with feed freezes from time to time. As a result, I cannot give full breakdowns of a couple of the pre-race features because I effectively was unable to see them through no fault of my own. For example, one piece saw Kurt Busch and Larry McReynolds on a tour bus going to one of Lisa Vanderpump’s restaurants (I know, it sounds really strange). It froze 15 seconds in, then unfroze after it ended, so I couldn’t really tell you what it was like other than to tell you that the premise was weird.

Another piece had Daniel Suarez join Joel McHale (Community, The Soup, Card Sharks, etc.) for a meal. Here, Suarez basically describes the basics of his career to McHale. This piece came off as a little weird as well.

Similar to NASCAR RaceHub last week, NASCAR RaceDay was based on a set in the west end grandstands. This resulted in a wacky instance in which a random dude walked in front of the camera while they were live. ESPN’s Ryan McGee clipped the weird circumstance.

Wow. I don’t even know what to say. How did that guy get in front of the cameras? Jeepers. Chris Myers kept his cool, but I have no doubt that he was rather ticked off.

Sunday saw the debut of Tony Stewart for FOX in the broadcast booth alongside Mike Joy and Clint Bowyer. Stewart will be in the booth through Daytona, but beyond that is a mystery. Stewart does bring some previous experience in the booth when he did a couple of Busch races in the booth for TNT back in the mid-2000s. He had a rather giggly time back then.

In 2003, Stewart was just in the booth to have some fun on a Friday night. This time is a little more serious. Sunday saw Stewart bring a lot of focused commentary to the broadcast. I found Stewart to be quite knowledgeable and filled in quite a few gaps. Yes, Stewart had never raced at the Coliseum. Then again, no one else had. Despite that, Stewart brings a different feel to the broadcast, something that Clint Bowyer cannot inject into telecasts. 2022 is going to be up and down for FOX based on whoever the third person is in the booth. As of this writing, I don’t know who the third person will be other than at Daytona.

Broadcasting from a football stadium is usually not too difficult of an endeavor for TV networks. However, this is a completely different circumstance since you have to cover the circumference of the facility as opposed to simply end to end.

FOX employed a lot of quick cuts in their production both Saturday and Sunday and it made things a little difficult to follow at times. I’m not alone in saying that since a lot of people made their opinions known on Twitter when it came to that issue. Given the space constraints, there were a lot of robotic camera usage as well. There were some establishing shots that showed the cars all the way around the quarter-mile track, like one through the arches on the east side of the stadium. That was nice.

Possibly the most explosive moment of the race was when Ryan Blaney threw his HANS Device at Erik Jones’ car after Jones put him in the wall. Unfortunately, FOX failed to catch that. We just had Mike Joy react to the HANS Device being thrown. There was a multiple second gap, then a cut to the HANS Device sitting on the track. As of this writing, no video of the actual HANS throw has surfaced.

See also
Stock Car Scoop: Was NASCAR's Clash at the Coliseum a Triumph?

Post-race coverage was pretty decent. Viewers got interviews with the top four finishers (Joey Logano, Kyle Busch, Austin Dillon and Jones) along with post-race analysis before the coverage from Los Angeles came to an end.

Looking back, Stewart was likely the high point of this broadcast. He showed this past weekend that he’s got the chops to really do some good on FOX. Unfortunately, he’ll only be there through the Daytona 500. You have to have a good mix in the booth to have a good broadcast and that’s going to be a mixed bag for the entire season, literally dependent on who the third person will be that week. Having a revolving door pretty much cannot benefit FOX in any way.

The on-track action was pretty good. Nowhere near as many shenanigans. Apparently, a lot of the people at the Coliseum Sunday were at their first race. If they came into it with the knowledge that this isn’t the norm for NASCAR, maybe they’ll come back for more. Had I considered going, I would have ditched my car somewhere and used the Metro E Line (a light rail station is located across the street from the stadium on Exposition Boulevard. Some of the parking lots were charging $100 a car to park like they do for USC Football games (note: USC is literally across Exposition Boulevard from the stadium).

I do admit that due to the ongoing part shortages, I didn’t think this race should have been held this year. The fear was that a lot of teams were going to end up with thrashed cars. Ultimately, only three or four of the 36 that made the trip got trashed (Kurt Busch, Aric Almirola and Justin Haley, most notably). Still, it was a legitimate worry.

The atmosphere at the race was very different than any race I’ve ever been to. Based on what I could see on FOX, it was a much younger crowd than normal. Perhaps some of the USC students crossed the street to check it out. That said, it seemed like FOX was focusing on a certain group of young women during the broadcast. That was a little weird.  We’re not getting to the level of what ABC did with Jenn Sterger since the booth never acknowledged this on-air, but it was noticeable.

Having Pitbull perform doesn’t seem that strange knowing that he co-owns Trackhouse Racing with Justin Marks. Ice Cube performing was something else. It seemed so weird when it was happening. I know a lot of longtime fans didn’t like that, but I didn’t mind so much. Maybe doing the performance in the middle of the race is what made it seem so weird.

That’s all for this week. For this weekend, NASCAR teams will be finishing up their preparations for Daytona. That doesn’t mean that there won’t be racing to watch.

The DIRTcar Nationals are now underway at Volusia Speedway Park in Florida. The Short Track Super Series will be at All-Tech Raceway for four nights of Modified racing. The World Series of Asphalt starts off nine nights of racing at New Smyrna Speedway Friday night, while Monster Energy AMA Supercross returns to Angel Stadium for their third visit of the season. That’s just some of the action available to watch. TV listings can be found in the Television drop-down menu above.

For next week’s edition of Couch Potato Tuesday, we’re going to preview FOX’s season. As of this writing, there are still a number of roles that haven’t been announced. Perhaps by next week, a lot of the guest analyst roles will be filled.

If you have a gripe with me, or just want to say something about my critique, feel free to post in the comments below. Even though I can’t always respond, I do read your comments. Also, if you want to “like” me on Facebook or follow me on Twitter, please click on the appropriate icons. If you would like to contact either of NASCAR’s media partners, click on either of the links below.

FOX Sports
NBC Sports

As always, if you choose to contact a network by email, do so in a courteous manner. Network representatives are far more likely to respond to emails that ask questions politely rather than emails full of rants and vitriol.

About the author

Phil Allaway has three primary roles at Frontstretch. He's the manager of the site's FREE e-mail newsletter that publishes Monday-Friday and occasionally on weekends. He keeps TV broadcasters honest with weekly editions of Couch Potato Tuesday and serves as the site's Sports Car racing editor.

Outside of Frontstretch, Phil is the press officer for Lebanon Valley Speedway in West Lebanon, N.Y. He covers all the action on the high-banked dirt track from regular DIRTcar Modified racing to occasional visits from touring series such as the Super DIRTcar Series.

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com
We hate spam. Your email address will not be sold or shared with anyone else.

Share this article

20 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Sally Baker

Same issues with Fox as usual…too many closeups, too much concentration on the front of the field, too many bumper cam shots. Thought Tony and Clint was a good mix.

Bill B

The only good thing about having a rotating third person in the booth is that, if they suck, you know you won’t have to endure them more than one or two weeks. Tony did OK.

I did not know that USC was right across the street. Now I wonder if a good number of those “fans” that filled the stadium weren’t paying customers but college kids corralled into the stadium with promises of a race, a concert and probably free beer. College kids don’t usually have money to pay to see an event they don’t care about. I also doubt that they are Ice-T fans as he was popular before they were born.

Matty

College kids don’t usually have money to pay to see an event they don’t care about.”

HAHAHA. Have you ever been to a college football game? While at Wisconsin (some 15 years ago, mind you), most student ticket packages were purchased for the sole intent of selling for at least double the $ on the open market. Generally you’d attend the least valuable game on your own, be blackout drunk by halftime, and then MAYBE be present at the conclusion.

College kids have plenty of money to pay to see a lot of things they don’t *care* about, but have a good time attending.

Bill B

Well I guess it was different when I went to college. Not with the “being blackout drunk by halftime” part but the “going to an event I don’t care about” part. If it cost money you had to make choices. On any given week there could be ten events that would be fun but they all cost something. So if they were let in free then I can see it but if they had to pay to be there, then kids today must have money to burn. I sure didn’t.

Last edited 4 months ago by Bill B
Michael M

Yep, you’re absolutely correct, at Darlington they have very cheap tickets for college students on a large section of the back stretch. I’ve been amongst it several times and even was warned about it from the ticket sales supervisor. It is hilarious and pathetic at the same time, as you can imagine. The upside is they are ALL gone before halfway, they are there to be seen a little while,&get drunk. They are clueless about the actual race. Very funny, then plenty of room to finish the race for real fans. All planned from na$cars geniuses.

Bill W.

I agree with all of Sally’s comments and this is not unusual for Fox broadcast. The scoring needs to be on the top of the screen. Did mikey show up for free?

Jeremy

The promised Mikey there would be a race, a concert, and free beer! :-)

DoninAjax

Phil, get ready for a nightmare telecast of every event this year.

On another note , do you prefer Night Court with Ellen Foley (singer on Bat Out Of Hell) or Markie Post?

Christopher

Someone at Fox executive level really needs to do an intervention with Artie Kempner, who runs the Fox NASCAR broadcasts. Those painfully unfunny, incredibly awkward pre-taped production filler pieces are just too much to bear. This has been going on for 20 years now and apparently no one has ever bothered to tap Kempner on the shoulder and say ‘Hey, knock it off, those really, REALLY suck’. Fox seems bent on presenting NASCAR as if through he filter of a Warner Bros. cartoon.

As to Boyer, he’s improved somewhat from his frenetic, over-the-top lunatic approach from his first season, but that may have been due to having his former boss and a team owner with far more knowledge present.

Ron

I certainly agree with the pre-race filler pieces. Since we have a brand new car this year, I was hoping (and expecting) that we would have segments on the changes from the old car to the new one. There are many of us who don’t have cable and had no access to any of the off-season programs that had information like that. Furthermore, there were probably many people tuning in who aren’t interested enough in NASCAR to seek out information on car changes that were made in the off-season. I guess I should be grateful that DW is no longer part of the broadcast with the inane “boogity, boogity . . .” nonsense. Now how do we get rid of Michael?

Bill B

Just wait. I am sure there will be a piece on that next week when there are 20 hours of programming before the Daytona 500. And if there is a rain delay, you will get to see it 5 times.

DoninAjax

The best idea from FOX was Digger!

DoninAjax

Dripping with sarcasm.

Bill B

Yeah, those of us who know you knew it was sarcasm but apparently the 4 souls that down voted you didn’t… LOL

Charlie

Streaming the way ooof thee fut u r e. NBC take note. Anyway, I thought Tony Stewart was very good and Boyer was funny. Mike Joy talked about the sold out crowd. He burned his credibility with me when he introduced Dumb (Darrell Waltrip) in the Hall of Fame and said he was one of NASCAR’ most popular drivers. I was a fan and in the media during his heyday. Rusty spinning him didn’t change things, his failing to qualify over a series of events did. So maybe they can encourage him to retire. Or just go and kiss up to Rick Hendrick and Jeff Gordon. Jeff was not missed at all.
The fans, many of them, had to be wearing red. I guess it shows up when you can’t alternate the seat color. If there were 30,000 people there it is a miracle.
They did play some defense because of the parts situation.
All-in-all, I’m glad they tried it. The France family obsession with California nearly killed the sport when they moved the Southern 500. The second Bill France did that. His grandson didn’t learn. California does not have a real interest in this sport. And it never will. This time, though, they could kill it.

Mike

Pro bowl beat the clash in viewers by 2 million. So i guess nascar didnt beat nfl again. Oh well the only good thing about the clash was logano won and that made it worth watching for me. now on to daytona for another win.

jdquick

Simply couldn’t watch this race on a track that was made TV and not racing. Can’t wait to see how messed up the 500 will be. NASCAR is slowly becoming irrelevant in their constant attempts to be WOKE and hip.

Johnny Cuda

Welcome back Phil! Glad to have you for another racing season.

Mike Kalasnik

FOX coverage was terrible, when its usually solid. The introductions of the grand marshalls was way off, not in sync, and disjointed. They totally missed the actual “action” and often would cover the wrong things. I liked the very quick pit work by Jamie Little, but outside of that, it was very meh.

1911_Bandit

It’s just one race so far, and it was at a made-for-TV track, but with only 3 actual passes for a lead change has NASCAR improved the racing even one little bit with this Gen of a car?

Sign up for the Frontstretch Newsletter

A daily email update (Monday through Friday) providing racing news, commentary, features, and information from Frontstretch.com